[quote]laroyal wrote:
JMoUCF87 wrote:
ya know, i try and leave this thread be, but you people keep saying stupid shit, so i have to keep coming back and correcting you.
first of all what i said was not “irresponsible”. explain to me how this is irresponsible:
(1) ensure sufficient protein intake (again ~1.5g / lb.)
(2) get sufficient amounts of micronutrients from fruits and/or veggies and (for health reasons)
(3) keep your calories in check so your body is forced to use stored energy (i.e. fat) to cover the deficit
oh yeah and (4) lift heavy things so your body has a reason to keep the muscle (though this isn’t much of a concern at 25% BF anyway)
you said yourself, overweight individuals have “no concept of portion control”. so how does telling them “calories don’t count” help?
portion control = calorie control. fat people don’t do this. the result: they stay fat.
what IS irresponsible is telling someone who is experiencing a weight loss plateau that:
(1) calories don’t count and
(2) making them think they need to buy expensive and worthless supplements (HCL) and/or do wacky things like drink a shake with “orgnic blueberries, 1 whole omega-3 egg, spinach, and 1 tbsp greek yogurt” to lose weight.
So tell me, why is it my roommate who plays rugby and water polo so lean, yet eats frozen pizzas and hot pockets?
I KNOW, he must be taking his HCL and drinking his “organic blueberry omega-3 egg spinach greek yogurt shakes” when i’m not looking? :-/
It is easy to sit there and critique something you don’t understand. I am still waiting for some proof, a picture of you or someone you train or for that matter your “ripped” roomate. If what you do works for you and your clients? then by all means keep doing it.
The system that myself and ksommer uses works for us, our clients and is backed by 26 years of data, The success of Charles on not only an average perosn’s level but with olympians and pro athletes and T-Nation’s own CT. If what you do is so much more efficient and productive I would say you are selling yourself short in the communication’s field. Start contacting some pro teams or celebs and show em what you can do, people pay for results and results keep them comoing back!
[/quote]
I won’t respond to the client request as that is irrelevant to the issue at hand. You know i don’t have any clients, but what difference does it make.
energy balance is the primary determinant of weight loss do you not agree? can you explain through what physiological mechanisms a person can gain weight/fat on a hypo caloric diet? if so, I’d love to hear about it.
oh and by the way, speaking of CT, perhaps you should read over his article “Nutrition for Newbies Part 1” cause it goes over the basics, like how to determine your BMR (aka how many CALORIES you burn at rest) and how to adjust your CALORIES up or down depending on if you want to gain or lose weight/fat.
But I guess he was wrong too, cause calories don’t count…right?