[quote]Amsterdam Animal wrote:
Are you fucking kidding me with this bullshit explanation. You see a fellow bro in iron who is about to rip his tendons b/c the weight is crushing him, you go spot him. Thats lifting 101. If he is still conscious after you finally swallowed your pride and walked over to spot him, then you tell him how you want to be addressed in the future afterwards.
If that was you standing there, I would put you under the bar after I dumped the weight and wait for you to fail miserably. Then I’d sit there untill you addressed me by the proper name I picked out for that day and if you got it right, I would help you get up. Oh and the proper name would have been asshole.
AA
[/quote]
Bullshit explanation? Because a “bro in iron” is worth more than a brother in arms? A guy that works out next to me in a particular gym is worth more to me than a man who has pledged to carry my dead body for however many miles it takes so I can receive a proper burial? That same man would be ashamed if I let someone disrespect me, which in turn disrespects our unit. Ever heard of esprit de corps?
Is military etiquette different from civilian etiquette? Yes, nowadays it is. That’s why my standards have relaxed. However, I bet if you made fun of just about any man’s title 150 years ago, you would be challenged to a duel to the death. This would be true if you were in the Wild West, New England, Great Britain, or Feudal Japan. What was different then? Everyone could have been armed, which is where you’re at today in the military.
Again, the OP was doing a Zercher squat, and at worst he would look a little foolish. If he was really going to hurt himself, I probably would have been the first to help him out. I seem to have hit a nerve here, which is a little strange, because nobody freaked out when TC said he wouldn’t save a rude man from a mugging in “Testosterone Knights.”
http://www.T-Nation.com/readTopic.do?id=793047&pageNo=0
Admittedly, TC is a much better writer then I am, but I was trying to convey the same message about courtesy, which I think a lot of people here agreed with.
Finally, I think calling someone “boss” or “chief” who obviously isn’t in charge of you is more cowardly and offensive than calling someone “asshole” or “fag” or whatever. If you walk up to a random man and call him a “fag,” which most men consider a major insult, you’d probably expect to get in a fight. In this case, at least you are prepared to back up your name-calling. If you patronize a random man who is not your boss by calling him “boss,” it’s only a slight insult. If the man doesn’t challenge you, you feel superior to him, as he didn’t have enough self-respect to stand up to you, irregardless of whatever family or societal obligations that man may have not to react with violence. If he does challenge you, he overreacted. Either way, you get off by knocking the guy down a bit.
Any other military folk care to weigh in on this?