[quote]Charlie Horse wrote:
[quote]Oleena wrote:
As for standing up to the cops on principle; it’s really pointless. Nothing is going to come of what BG did. Some officers are not going to stop being dicks and questions aren’t going to stop being asked. Officers aren’t going to start being better trained in the law because of this either.
BG was completely in his right to do what he did and the officers didn’t do anything that could get them sued, so really this is just a standard situation where no one was harmed and thus no difference can be made law or training wise. It’s unfortunate for his mental “must prove a point” sake that BG wasn’t roughed up a bit.[/quote]
I have a problem with your post.
Is it your position that we shouldn’t do any thing about our rights being violated because it won’t make a difference?
If we don’t look out for our own rights who will?
I think it is better if everyone knows their rights and exercises them in small ways like the op’s situation because it is easier and safer to exercise them then rather than when they are locked up for being wrongfully accused of murder(like in AC’s post). The police don’t become corrupt are overnight it happens because the citizens allow them to get away with small violation of their rights then it escalates. If we aren’t going to look after our own rights maybe we don’t deserve them.
Also I didn’t like the wanting him to be “roughed up”, his child was in the car. I guess there is some kind of private disagreement going on here.
[/quote]
The problem is, no rights were actually violated. BG exercised his right and the cop talked some smack but nothing happened. It was basically terrible customer service. While I wish complaining about the cop’s “customer service” would do some good, I don’t think it will unless you can make them pay somehow in court. That’s just the way our system works.
I don’t want anyone roughed up; I was just making a joke to the sad fact that more could have come of this if he was. Sometimes the state of things is just so sad you have to laugh a bit.
Edit: Interesting point about more people exercising their rights and the education therein. I’ve thought for quite some time that a high school law course should be mandatory.