Joe Rogan vs Carlos Mencia

I don’t really care for Mencia, Rogan is okay sometimes. But both are comedic Steven Hawkings compared to Dane Cook. He blows.

[quote]dre wrote:

And you know someone has been busted when they only attack the other person and not actually attack what they are saying.

[/quote]

I personally enjoyed the ‘he is jewish’ defense in regards to ‘who will build the wall’ joke. As if jews don’t know anything about being immigrants. The Jews are the original exploited yet unwanted immigrants, and have been so since long before the United States or Mexico existed.

[quote]ranmao wrote:
Ok the whole stealing thing is bad, but why are people getting so worked up over his name change? There are plenty of entertainers that have changed their names. Also the Honduras thing, he mentioned it on his show,so it’s not like it was some big secret.[/quote]

i think the problem people have with his name change is that he did it intentionally to emphasize something he is really not. By using his real name, he would have a harder time getting away with the mexican jokes that he uses. but as carlos mencia, nobody even thinks twice.

[quote]Steve4192 wrote:
dre wrote:

And you know someone has been busted when they only attack the other person and not actually attack what they are saying.

I personally enjoyed the ‘he is jewish’ defense in regards to ‘who will build the wall’ joke. As if jews don’t know anything about being immigrants. The Jews are the original exploited yet unwanted immigrants, and have been so since long before the United States or Mexico existed.[/quote]

Completely agree.


And Dane Cook makes me laugh my arse off.

“Who gets killed by bees? I would punch every bee in the face!”

Wow, Joe Rogan is only marginally fun, but wow he actually fucking doesn’t take crap.

[quote]dre wrote:
Steve4192 wrote:
dre wrote:

And you know someone has been busted when they only attack the other person and not actually attack what they are saying.

I personally enjoyed the ‘he is jewish’ defense in regards to ‘who will build the wall’ joke. As if jews don’t know anything about being immigrants. The Jews are the original exploited yet unwanted immigrants, and have been so since long before the United States or Mexico existed.

Completely agree.


And Dane Cook makes me laugh my arse off.

“Who gets killed by bees? I would punch every bee in the face!”[/quote]

Dane Cook is half and half with me. Most of his stuff is just “meh” to me, but he’ll have one or two jokes that have me rolling. And sometimes that’s enough to carry a show, other times, not.

That video is pretty damn funny. Joe Rogan’s Myspace has some more infomation on the whole thing.

[quote]Backlash79 wrote:
That video is pretty damn funny. Joe Rogan’s Myspace has some more infomation on the whole thing.[/quote]

ehh, sounds like some sour grapes on this thread. I’d love to one day be a sellout and get a show and make a shitload of money because someone funnier/smarter/better looking leaves. I’d LOVE that opportunity. Those of you clowning on him are showing a lot of jealosy.

And while I’ve always liked Rogan from way back, he’s never gotten the notoriety in the comedic world that Mencia has. Rogan would never be a name for much had it not been for fear factor. But you still have to give him props for the commando style raid on Mencia. Doing that kind of stuff these days can get you ostracized - very not PC and that takes guts to do.

[quote]malonetd wrote:
dre wrote:
Steve4192 wrote:
dre wrote:

And you know someone has been busted when they only attack the other person and not actually attack what they are saying.

I personally enjoyed the ‘he is jewish’ defense in regards to ‘who will build the wall’ joke. As if jews don’t know anything about being immigrants. The Jews are the original exploited yet unwanted immigrants, and have been so since long before the United States or Mexico existed.

Completely agree.


And Dane Cook makes me laugh my arse off.

“Who gets killed by bees? I would punch every bee in the face!”

Dane Cook is half and half with me. Most of his stuff is just “meh” to me, but he’ll have one or two jokes that have me rolling. And sometimes that’s enough to carry a show, other times, not.[/quote]

I agree, not all of his stuff is great. But for some reason when he can get me laughing really hard with some of his stuff.

Maybe because he’s just so damn stupid, just like me.

Is that bad?

[quote]aikigreg wrote:
Backlash79 wrote:
That video is pretty damn funny. Joe Rogan’s Myspace has some more infomation on the whole thing.

ehh, sounds like some sour grapes on this thread. I’d love to one day be a sellout and get a show and make a shitload of money because someone funnier/smarter/better looking leaves. I’d LOVE that opportunity. Those of you clowning on him are showing a lot of jealosy.

And while I’ve always liked Rogan from way back, he’s never gotten the notoriety in the comedic world that Mencia has. Rogan would never be a name for much had it not been for fear factor. But you still have to give him props for the commando style raid on Mencia. Doing that kind of stuff these days can get you ostracized - very not PC and that takes guts to do.

[/quote]

I don’t think it’s jealousy at all. Sure, the guy got a show on CC and is making some nice coin now, but I really could give a rat’s ass about that.

I just don’t think he’s funny at all. I think he’s a one trick humor pony and that’s all he’s got.

Not jealousy, just pure unadulterated hatred.

Before seeing all this crap I wasn’t much of a fan of Joe Rogan. I gave him points for being a big MMA fan, but that’s it. However, I spent about 2 hours last night on youtube checking out some of his stuff and honestly, I’d put him up there with Chris Rock, Eddie Murphy, and Richard Pryor. Every bit I saw him do I laughed my ass off. The one about Noah’s Ark is hilarious. And King Kong and humans being monkeys, I was in tears. Not to mention the guy actually seems to be pretty intelligent. I used to think he was an assclown but really, the guy has got my respect.

[quote]dre wrote:

And Dane Cook makes me laugh my arse off.

“Who gets killed by bees? I would punch every bee in the face!”[/quote]

It’s not so funny when your little brother repeats it every chance he gets. I fell in love with him watching his Comedy Central bit, but during the Retaliation Era… Not so much.

[quote]aikigreg wrote:
Backlash79 wrote:
That video is pretty damn funny. Joe Rogan’s Myspace has some more infomation on the whole thing.

ehh, sounds like some sour grapes on this thread. I’d love to one day be a sellout and get a show and make a shitload of money because someone funnier/smarter/better looking leaves. I’d LOVE that opportunity. Those of you clowning on him are showing a lot of jealosy.

And while I’ve always liked Rogan from way back, he’s never gotten the notoriety in the comedic world that Mencia has. Rogan would never be a name for much had it not been for fear factor. But you still have to give him props for the commando style raid on Mencia. Doing that kind of stuff these days can get you ostracized - very not PC and that takes guts to do.

[/quote]

I’ve laughed at Carlos Mencia’s stuff on occasion and I’m sure he’s not the only one stealing material from other comedians but they fact that he does puts him down a notch in my book. I’d be more likely to avoid his show now than before.

That vid is blocked now. Man they took that off quick.

[quote]DtotheG wrote:
dre wrote:

And Dane Cook makes me laugh my arse off.

“Who gets killed by bees? I would punch every bee in the face!”

It’s not so funny when your little brother repeats it every chance he gets. I fell in love with him watching his Comedy Central bit, but during the Retaliation Era… Not so much.
[/quote]

He’s your little brother, can’t you make him shut up?

/never had a little brother

an interesting video from bobby lee:

i think brian reagan is one of the most talented comedians out there.

What comedian today is just completely original?

[quote]Professor X wrote:
What comedian today is just completely original?[/quote]

I think the beef is with the sheer amount of material Mencia has been jacking since he started, coupled with the fact that he’s now doing other’s bits on his show which is netting him millions. If you’re going to be a comic, the majority of your material should be your own shit, or stuff your writers did for you, and apparently his HBO special that got the ball rolling towards his Comedy Central gig was a complete rip off.

Rogan has a little blog about the incident explaining a little bit about the background to the whole thing.

[quote]Backlash79 wrote:
I’ve laughed at Carlos Mencia’s stuff on occasion and I’m sure he’s not the only one stealing material from other comedians but they fact that he does puts him down a notch in my book. I’d be more likely to avoid his show now than before.[/quote]

I’m quite a comedy connoisseur and have watched 100s, probably 1000s of hours of stand-up. Let me tell you that LOTS of them steal from each other.

They may craft the joke and tell it differently, but the practice of trading jokes is very common.