Jillian Michaels vs the body positivity movement

This is worth a watch. I don’t know that much about her, other than biggest loser, but she killed it here.

1 Like

You’ll be happy to know that she is a Trump supporter who appears on Fox News often.

I don’t care because it’s not relevant to this context.

Now if she was put in charge of making national health policies I think it would be appropriate to be much more critical.

2 Likes

Well that is beyond frustrating to watch.

1 Like

No way I could watch the whole thing.

2 Likes

Nope. I got about 5 minutes in. I’m amazed I made it that far.

2 Likes

Body positivity movement got hijacked by the overweight community. The reality it origionally came about for indviduals born with birth defects or indviduals suffering from disfigurement from injuries like burn victims. OR women dealing with the psychological stress of women dealing with a mastectomy.

Let’s not get started with healthy at any weight mentality.

From what im understanding with drugs like ozempic… The whole body possitive thing is sorta becoming less of a thing as of late.

6 Likes

One word sums all those idiots up: DENIAL

Ironically, were you to ask all those “larger sized persons” (LOL, all these made up words crack me up…who says them but doesn’t just automically think “fatasses”?) if they thought that smoking was bad for your health, I bet all of them would agree.
This video IS difficult to watch, but I pushed through it just because I am so fascinated with all the ways these clowns lie to themselves that they are healthy and that their excess weight has not negatively affected their lives. She should have asked them “If there was a fire right now, and we had to run up (we’ll make this easy) 4 flights of stairs to escape, how many of yall would make it out?” Or how many would just sit on the stairs and cry and say they are neurodivergent and have anxiety and the fire is discriminating against them?

4 Likes

Body positivity was always marketing fad. It was killed by GLP-1 drugs and the buccal fat removal fad. The world has moved on to doing hip thrusts and dumbbell SLRDLs for 30 minutes a day.

4 Likes

If there ever is a human virus outbreak a la 28 days later, everybody in that circle, sans Jillian, will definitely be attacked quickly. My plan is to run towards a group of “body positive people”, and then sneak out through them while the zombies get bogged down. Fortunately for us, “plus sized persons” will not be able to spread the virus as they’d have to catch someone. Oooh, wait….too soon?

3 Likes

Instead of being empowered with tools to understand and change their situation, they’re being taught to protect their emotions at all costs.

Changing fat person from a description to an identity then triggers feeling attacked because its no longer telling a person that fat is bad, it is telling the person that THEY are bad.

Then its not a debate. Its a fight. And there’s no such thing as a fair fight. So the studies are wrong, the facts are lies, and on and on and on. You’re just another bad guy attacking them.

Its the same way with alcoholism. When faced with the choice of change or die, a lot of people would rather die. Thats why self diagnosis or identification and admission is best. You call aomebody something, they’ll take it to the grave trying to prove that you’re wrong.

5 Likes

It wasnt too long ago the movement was floating the notions doctors were “ Fatphopic” and that they should not weigh patients.

6 Likes

I saw a video with her being pissed about people using glps (like its cheating).

I think its bc no will need to buy her “fitness products” anymore

1 Like

I believe that is covered in Zimbieland.

2 Likes

Oh yeah, the “Big Hoss” in the supermarket!

Haven’t there been studies done that show even though the up-front costs to health insurance companies to approve GLP-1’s to their policyholders IS expensive, that the long term cost savings is quite significant due to less: diabetes meds/treatments, less kidney dialysis treatments, less heart disease and all the associated meds/procedures, and overall less hospitalizations due to the insured getting down to much healthier weights? It seems pretty common sense to allow a drug that cost a grand or so a month, versus someone in and out of the hospital multiple times, double, triple bypasses, etc. Hospital ANYTHING is crazy $$$$$ for insurance companies.

2 Likes

It’s probably that and the ego tied to being in shape. A lot of people think using GLP1 is cheating or for weak minded lazy people.

I get that.

But I also think that there is a genuine value to the psychological changes that that come from the security and confidence of being independently in control of your body.

That’s very different from

I agree completely. I think in the majority of cases, GLP1 is not the answer but hey if it works for someone and they’re happy then good for them.

It is. That is why they all gain the weight back when they stop using it.

1 Like

Yeah but I think that has more to do with the fact that people put little effort into actually learning why they are fat and how to change it. I know a handful of people that have hopped on with zero learning about foods or any exercise and yeah they lost 20 pounds in a few months but then when the side effects kick their ass and they hop off they gain it all back. I think it could be used as a tool to lower your weight while you learn about diet and exercise and then when you come off you are in a better place to maintain your healthy lifestyle.

1 Like