[quote]SteelyD wrote:
[quote]Smashingweights wrote:
I don’t disagree with what you wrote. However, when you say you’ve not seen ‘traditional bulkers’ track macros, I don’t know whether you’re talking about Internet forum bulkers or real life bulkers. [/quote]
In real life, the biggest guys I’ve ever met (no idea natural or not, but stay with me..) who I’ve talked about diets for getting big have advocated “eating big but eating smart”. However, that does not mean that they “just ate everything”. I have a hard time believing that truly big guys who have competed, let’s say a decade or more ago just ate without having some rough but pretty accurate idea of what they were eating.
It’s not outrageous to think that some big dudes can gain on (I’m making this up) 5000 cals daily, but just gorge on the weekends in their off season. 6 days of immaculate eating + 1 day of ‘git fud in mah belleh’ doesn’t make a serious weightlifter a fatass over night.
[quote]
Just between you and I, do you think it’s necessary for a lifter to get up to 20+% bodyfat in order to gain muscle optimally?
Flame free.
Serious responses back and forth.
Scouts honor.
I’m still LOL’ing at your photoshop mastery. [/quote]
Do I think it’s necessary? Absolutely not.
Do I think it’s acceptable? For me-- absolutely. For you? I don’t know. I’m not you. For him (any ‘him’). I don’t know. At the risk of falling into your bucket, it’s really what each person can handle.
Also, I don’t know “20%”. Honestly, in real life, I’ve met 2 lifters (competitive or gym rat) who ever got a real BF thingy done. A few more people have gotten calipers and a bunch more use the electric fat thingy at the front desk. The number is meaningless to most people and I’m in the ‘estimating bodyfat % by the vast majority of people is a crock of shit’. Not that the best and brightest BF estimators don’t post here at TN, but I remain skeptical.
I’m happily married to my hot wife. I have kids and a mortgage. I don’t need to see my abs to feel comfortable on the beach (NTTAWWT). That’s an advantage for me and, indeed, gives me some cushioning (pun intended) because my goal is more like 80% strength related 20% physique. Yes, I’ve tightened up here and there.
So, there are some folks who PL who are somewhat physique oriented. Some are just after the number. From my perspective, if I hit a wall, I may switch things up to break the plateau, but if I can’t, the first thing I do is start eating.
Either way, I don’t fall into any ‘camp’. I’m just a dumb dude who goes to the gym to lift as much as I can. I don’t come here to impress anyone and I don’t really care if e-dudes think I’m obese. I’m mostly here to pick up nuggets of wisdom and for the LULZ. If I can help someone, I’m happy to do that. I logged my training and diet in O35 for a few years, so no secret to what I did to gain weight. I used to get regular PM’s from folks that I helped (scary thought, eh?). I do believe my 5-6 years of “bulking” has brought some great gains for an old dude with a broken back. I do believe I’m looking at coming down slowly now-- not for abs, necessarily, but to maintain my lifts at a slightly lower weight. The physique will take care of itself.
Let me reiterate. I don’t do ‘bulk dogma’. Someone earlier posted you gotta find your own way. ABSOLUTE TRUTH. If someone convinces you to never go above a certain BF%, then yes, you could possibly be holding yourself back from your optimum potential, but that doesn’t mean you still won’t make gains. Both methods work, you just have to pick your path.
TL;DR – Fatboy wan’ Punkin’ Pie Po’tart[/quote]
I think we are pretty much on the same page.
I’m sure some/many “traditional” bulkers count or track their macros somewhat but definitely not all or most IMO.
I also think there is a difference between big guys who have competed like you said and your gym rat bug guys who don’t.
We all know how easy it is to grab an extra handful of “Snack A” or have a little bit bigger scoop of “Food B”
Those things can add up QUICK without even knowing it.
You might think it’s an extra couple hundred calories and we are really talking 1,000+!!
But like I said, I think we are basically on the same page.
The issue is with what some people see as “acceptable” levels of bodyfat.
Different people have different approaches and if people wouldn’t try to shove their views down other people’s throats as THE way then this wouldn’t be an issue.
Mmmmmmm pop tarts