Girlfriend Wants to Get Married, Dilemma

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]imhungry wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]Derek542 wrote:

Actually probably more than anything this is what she wants, for you to fucking talk to her, women love to hear your inner thoughts and fears. This is not giving in, this is being an adult and discussing the truth about commitment, what it means to you, your view of what a marriage means in regards to financial, emotional, etc. Then like IH says you both can either move on or make plans as a couple and not a co-dependent “game” bullshit that most young people want to fall into. Having difficult discussions not fights but discussions is what you need to be having now, so that if you do decide to get married in the future this will be how you handle most issues. [/quote]

What a great post. I have never known a woman who did not love to hear people’s inner thoughts. Everyone’s inner thoughts! But especially her man’s and particularly when those thoughts offer reassurance that he is on the same page, feelings-wise. Even if he doesn’t want to act on the feelings in the same way.
[/quote]
What are your thoughts on the OP and on ultimatums in general, Em?[/quote]

I don’t know. They’re young, but they’ve been together for quite a while. I really have no strong opinion, other than that Derek’s advice is spot on. She needs something from him, but I’m not convinced it’s a diamond today OR ELSE. I think it would be a mistake for the OP to treat her like an asshole gold digger when she probably just wants to know that it’s real and he wants what she does.

I would hate for her to spend her life believing she had to beg him to marry her and then he reluctantly agreed, eventually, under duress.
[/quote]
Ok. Fair enough.

I just wanted another woman’s perspective on this, since we have predominantly male point of view on here.

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]orion wrote:

[quote]LoRez wrote:

On the other hand, I think that describes what happens in a marriage with inexperienced individuals. Not necessarily immature, just inexperienced. I think if both people understand those dynamics, things can and do work quite a bit differently.[/quote]

You have seen the reactions of Debra and Emily in this threads.

By denying that “game” works they basically deny that there even are “dynamics” men could hack into.

We both know that they do exist and what a difference they make if you work them hard.

If those two fight that knowledge with every fiber of their being could you please tell me how the average woman can not only learn to accept it, but also to control it?

How?[/quote]

I fight this with every fiber of my being?? No I don’t! I have acknowledged over and over again that I see differences between the sexes, both generally speaking and in my own relationships. I only point out that your attitudes limit you to lousy women. The exact type you fear. I found the link you posted laughable in its fear-mongering. Men describing their wives as EVIL, oh noes! Do you really believe that intelligent, competent men are victimizable to this sad degree? Do you forget that men’s infidelity rate is higher than women’s? And why have you not yet even begun to digest the narrowing wage gap between men and women? :frowning:

[/quote]

Yes, I do think that highly intelligent and competent men are easily victimized by women especially if the idealize them and NO THAT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THEY ONLY HAVE THEMSELVES TO BLAME which is exactly how you feel about it.

How do I know?

Magic.

All it takes is men that idealize women and have been taught that women are fluffy and innocent little creatures and the resources of a whole nation state behind her and any semi retarted cunt can shaft a Nobel prize winner.

Also, the infidelity rate is irrelevant, because if women are hypergamic, men are necessarily polygamic, if they can. So, if a man “cheats” that does not necessarily mean the end of the relationship, if a woman does it she usually has already decided that its over, at least the sexal part of it.

Even if that were not so, if a man does it and gets caught he can get anally raped by the system.

If a woman does it and gets caught, he can get anally raped by the system.

Weather forecast either way:

High chances of anal rape.

For men.

[quote]orion wrote:

If a woman does it and gets caught, he can get anally raped by the system.

[/quote]

How come? ( Genuine question.)

[quote]Alpha F wrote:

[quote]orion wrote:

If a woman does it and gets caught, he can get anally raped by the system.

[/quote]

How come? ( Genuine question.)
[/quote]

No fault divorce.

Its like, for the children maaaaan


[quote]orion wrote:

[quote]Alpha F wrote:

[quote]orion wrote:

If a woman does it and gets caught, he can get anally raped by the system.

[/quote]

How come? ( Genuine question.)
[/quote]

No fault divorce.

Its like, for the children maaaaan
[/quote]

I understand now.
I am assuming she is not entitled to the man’s money, though. She walks with nothing, right?

[quote]Alpha F wrote:

[quote]orion wrote:

[quote]Alpha F wrote:

[quote]orion wrote:

If a woman does it and gets caught, he can get anally raped by the system.

[/quote]

How come? ( Genuine question.)
[/quote]

No fault divorce.

Its like, for the children maaaaan
[/quote]

I understand now.
I am assuming she is not entitled to the man’s money, though. She walks with nothing, right?
[/quote]

First of all, she does not walk.

He walks, because she will get the children and that means she gets the house, appartment, whatever.

Second, of course she gets money to raise her children, which is ok, assuming that they are his, at this point he might find out that at least one is not. Not as unlikely as one might think. What she does with that money is entirely up to her, which is not ok, and if you think that debtors prison is a thing of the past, try not to pay child support, even after losing a job.

Also, your child support is not calculated by what you actually do earn, but by what you should be able to earn, according to some judge.

Plus, depending where you live she still gets half your money and alimony on top of it.

Hey, I already try to get my dick wet as if I got paid for it, but if you actually paid me
 if I wanted to design an incentive system to ram marriage into the ground I honestly do not believe that I could do better.

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

I fight this with every fiber of my being?? [/quote]

LOL! My thoughts exactly. Orion you’re turning out to be quite a drama queen! That said considering how infrequent both Em and I have actually posted compared to you and the other guys here you sure make us seem pretty damn special and give us lots of attention. =)

[quote]debraD wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

I fight this with every fiber of my being?? [/quote]

LOL! My thoughts exactly. Orion you’re turning out to be quite a drama queen! That said considering how infrequent both Em and I have actually posted compared to you and the other guys here you sure make us seem pretty damn special and give us lots of attention. =)
[/quote]

That is because you are damn special.

If would guestimate that both of you are in the top 10% of your gender when it comes to intelligence and self awareness and if you immediately dismiss the most self evident features of the female mind there is no hope of convincing the other 90%, let alone make them woman up and get their shit together.

Ultimately that means that women cannot be expected to reign in or even acknowledge their baser instincts and most if not all societies that came before us had it exactly right when men did it for them.

[quote]Uncle Gabby wrote:

So here’s the choice you give her, if she wants to marry you, you’ll take her to the justice of the peace tommorrow, tie the knot, and buy the gold bands that makes her your property (and vice versa), but no fancy wedding, and no diamond, ever. Or, you’ll give her the diamond and the bridezilla wedding, but she has to wait two years. If she ops for the diamond and the bridezilla wedding, I’d bail. But if she ops for the J O P, you’d be a fool not to keep her.[/quote]

I agree completely. This is a great way to weed out weather she want commitment or a big fancy wedding so she can have HER day. If she’s serious you can put together something quick and easy and get it done. That’s what my wife and I did. Just me and her and a little place called The Hitching Post.

[quote]orion wrote:

[quote]debraD wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

I fight this with every fiber of my being?? [/quote]

LOL! My thoughts exactly. Orion you’re turning out to be quite a drama queen! That said considering how infrequent both Em and I have actually posted compared to you and the other guys here you sure make us seem pretty damn special and give us lots of attention. =)
[/quote]

That is because you are damn special.

If would guestimate that both of you are in the top 10% of your gender when it comes to intelligence and self awareness and if you immediately dismiss the most self evident features of the female mind there is no hope of convincing the other 90%, let alone make them woman up and get their shit together.

Ultimately that means that women cannot be expected to reign in or even acknowledge their baser instincts and most if not all societies that came before us had it exactly right when men did it for them.

[/quote]

Orion, thank you for the nice compliment, but disagreeing with you does not constitute unawareness of gender dynamics. I don’t cheat and I’m not even tempted. I don’t harangue anyone. That is not in MY nature. Women are not made from one mold any more than Asians or men are.

I would offer Deb and I as examples that you’re off track. Anyone reading us would HAVE to see that we are different in many ways. Her job is technical and she is clearly more direct, less wordy, more analytical, and less sympathetic when posting. In other words, more traditionally male in her intellectual orientation. Yet personally, I don’t find her unfeminine in the least. She is just not as far along the “feminine” spectrum as I am, with my nurturing job, my emotional orientation, and my boundless desire for picket fences. I don’t know if you’ve ever seen pictures of our respective bodies, but they seem to tell the same tale. Deb is more muscular by far than I am, with a heavier bone structure. This is largely to do with Deb’s willingness to expend more effort than I in the gym, but some of it is physiology. I have a lot of trouble gaining muscle and lose it very quickly. I’m a runner, as she is, and if I miss a week I have recovery work to do for that reason. I’m going to guess that her muscle memory is much better than mine. I am in very good shape, but no one would ever look at me and think “strong.” More just “female.” Deb would earn both designations, along with an “omg hot hot hot.” :slight_smile:

I don’t know what her base instincts are, but I can’t imagine, reading what she writes here, that they match your vision of modern womanhood.

[quote]Yes, I do think that highly intelligent and competent men are easily victimized by women especially if the idealize them and NO THAT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THEY ONLY HAVE THEMSELVES TO BLAME which is exactly how you feel about it.

How do I know?

Magic. [/quote]

How I feel about it? I don’t blame groups, orion. It’s silly. Half the population is fucking everything up? No, that’s ridiculous. I don’t hate men or blame men or judge men as inferior or superior as a group. I judge some men as superior, others as inferior. Women get the same treatment from me. I also don’t judge marriage as failed. Statistically speaking, of the 40-50% of marriages that last, probably half are truly GOOD. So that would be about 25% of the whole. Not all are based in Japan. Of the ones that fail, probably 25% were truly BAD. We have some men on the boards here talking about really toxic marriages and divorces. Others have divorced without much drama and gotten on with life. Like everything else some good, some bad, most somewhere in between.

If I observe a shitty marriage I generally do make a judgment of who is the greater problem, but I go both ways. Sometimes her, sometimes him. Depends. I have friends who bitch about their husbands, but whom I judge to be at fault in the marriage.

Not at all sure what I’m fighting with every fiber of my being unless it’s your miserable outlook and over-generalizations. Men, I’m good with. Being a woman is fine with me. I’m not in conflict with my nature or theirs or anyone’s.

Op, tell her exactly what you wrote here. If you feel you want to marry her, at least get her a ring. However, be prepared for her to harass you with a wedding date and all the stress that comes with wedding preparation. I’m saying this only because you two had been together for 5 years, and the fact other people around her are getting married, she kinda feel left out.

I usually shake my head at this kind of stuff; a beautiful ring, a beautiful dress, wedding ceremony blah blah
 what about marriage? Do some young women even think about the enormity of the whole thing? And what next? Children? Divorce? Excuse my cynicism, but personally, I wouldn’t even get married at 24. Too young. As a woman in my mid twenties, I’m more focused on my career, my money and growing my business portfolio. Love and fucking marriage and children are the least of my worries.

I often wonder if those young women who put pressure on their boyfriends to get married have actually put deep thoughts into that ‘‘option’’. I don’t know what love is and don’t give as shit about it but I would have thought that if a girl truly loved her bf and he asked her to wait another year because he ain’t ready, she would at least give him the benefit of the doubt and wait. She doesn’t have to do as the other girls do. That’s their relationships. She should focus on hers and trust her man. And, if the following year he has yet to propose, then she can move the fuck on, knowing the guy is commitment phobe and a time waster, and, find someone else.

Be as truthful as you can be, tell her how you feel about the situation. Women and men think differently. She might think that after 5 years, you ‘‘owe’’ her commitment and you may think she may be overreacting for not understanding you and not accepting your decision not to marry just yet. It’s all about communication. Truthful communication. I’m sure your gf wouldn’t like you resenting her for ‘‘forcing’’ your hand. That’s not a great way to start a marriage.

Get her a ring. That’ll keep her happy for a while
 then please her with a nice anal session :wink:

[quote]Edgy wrote:

[quote]Chushin wrote:

Oh my.

Derek is on fire!

It’s almost as if he has some experience with a successful relationship
[/quote]

it’s all BS, Chushie - his ‘wife’ is really a thai ladyboy
[/quote]

I am going to tell JLO

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]orion wrote:

[quote]debraD wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

I fight this with every fiber of my being?? [/quote]

LOL! My thoughts exactly. Orion you’re turning out to be quite a drama queen! That said considering how infrequent both Em and I have actually posted compared to you and the other guys here you sure make us seem pretty damn special and give us lots of attention. =)
[/quote]

That is because you are damn special.

If would guestimate that both of you are in the top 10% of your gender when it comes to intelligence and self awareness and if you immediately dismiss the most self evident features of the female mind there is no hope of convincing the other 90%, let alone make them woman up and get their shit together.

Ultimately that means that women cannot be expected to reign in or even acknowledge their baser instincts and most if not all societies that came before us had it exactly right when men did it for them.

[/quote]

Orion, thank you for the nice compliment, but disagreeing with you does not constitute unawareness of gender dynamics. I don’t cheat and I’m not even tempted. I don’t harangue anyone. That is not in MY nature. Women are not made from one mold any more than Asians or men are.

I would offer Deb and I as examples that you’re off track. Anyone reading us would HAVE to see that we are different in many ways. Her job is technical and she is clearly more direct, less wordy, more analytical, and less sympathetic when posting. In other words, more traditionally male in her intellectual orientation. Yet personally, I don’t find her unfeminine in the least. She is just not as far along the “feminine” spectrum as I am, with my nurturing job, my emotional orientation, and my boundless desire for picket fences. I don’t know if you’ve ever seen pictures of our respective bodies, but they seem to tell the same tale. Deb is more muscular by far than I am, with a heavier bone structure. This is largely to do with Deb’s willingness to expend more effort than I in the gym, but some of it is physiology. I have a lot of trouble gaining muscle and lose it very quickly. I’m a runner, as she is, and if I miss a week I have recovery work to do for that reason. I’m going to guess that her muscle memory is much better than mine. I am in very good shape, but no one would ever look at me and think “strong.” More just “female.” Deb would earn both designations, along with an “omg hot hot hot.” :slight_smile:

I don’t know what her base instincts are, but I can’t imagine, reading what she writes here, that they match your vision of modern womanhood.

[quote]Yes, I do think that highly intelligent and competent men are easily victimized by women especially if the idealize them and NO THAT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THEY ONLY HAVE THEMSELVES TO BLAME which is exactly how you feel about it.

How do I know?

Magic. [/quote]

How I feel about it? I don’t blame groups, orion. It’s silly. Half the population is fucking everything up? No, that’s ridiculous. I don’t hate men or blame men or judge men as inferior or superior as a group. I judge some men as superior, others as inferior. Women get the same treatment from me. I also don’t judge marriage as failed. Statistically speaking, of the 40-50% of marriages that last, probably half are truly GOOD. So that would be about 25% of the whole. Not all are based in Japan. Of the ones that fail, probably 25% were truly BAD. We have some men on the boards here talking about really toxic marriages and divorces. Others have divorced without much drama and gotten on with life. Like everything else some good, some bad, most somewhere in between.

If I observe a shitty marriage I generally do make a judgment of who is the greater problem, but I go both ways. Sometimes her, sometimes him. Depends. I have friends who bitch about their husbands, but whom I judge to be at fault in the marriage.

Not at all sure what I’m fighting with every fiber of my being unless it’s your miserable outlook and over-generalizations. Men, I’m good with. Being a woman is fine with me. I’m not in conflict with my nature or theirs or anyone’s.

[/quote]

First of all, damn right, disagreeing with me does not constitute unawareness of gender dynamics.

It just means that you have it all wrong.

Then, that you do not feel the need to cheat, for now, is irrelevant. I do not feel the need to fuck a boxom 19 year old either if there isnt one around.

That does not mean that the basic biological programming is not there.

Also, well, yes, women are exactly as uniform as men or Asians are, but while men and male Asians would probably agree that all their basic urges are the same, women express their uniformity by insisting that they are all special little snowflakes.

I am aware that belonging to the biologically more valuable sex comes with a certain degree of narcissim and delusion but come on.

If we dragged a female dolphin, peacock or goose in here they would probably insist that there was nothing dolphinish, peacockish or goosish about them and I would entertain it with the same earnestness as your snowflaking.

Snowflaking btw is a technical PUA term.

Cause, you are like all soooo special, that we have technical terms for the most common delusions.

If that does not give you pause, nothing will.

Then, half of the population is fucking everything up?

No, but if I blamed any part of the population it would be men, because those spineless, sackless wonders have failed to do what every generation before them seems to have managed, keeping a lid on the most base female urges.

What I do believe is that one part of the population leads a live sheltered from personal resposibility and is allowed to indulge in baseless puerile fantasies at other peoples expense and those people share a common feature, a uterus.

Are there women who protest this, yes, but for the most part they just take it for granted.

[quote]Derek542 wrote:

[quote]Edgy wrote:

[quote]Chushin wrote:

Oh my.

Derek is on fire!

It’s almost as if he has some experience with a successful relationship
[/quote]

it’s all BS, Chushie - his ‘wife’ is really a thai ladyboy
[/quote]

I am going to tell JLO[/quote]

if this was SAMA, I would demand TOGTFO~

man, do I miss SAMA



For Orion