[quote]nerd_princess wrote:
Sorry I’m a little late to this discussion, but with all the touting of Robert Jordan’s books, I just had to post. I think Jordan wrote a good 7 books. Then, the 8th came, then the 9th, I mean nothing happened in those books, guys. The characters all just stared at each other while planning attacks, it was excruciating. He was clearly dragging it out to keep that money rolling in since everything he put out was an instant best seller.
The Sword of Truth series is equally annoying- starts out great, works for 5 books, then takes a nosedive into weird preachy territory. No good.
I’d love to tell these authors to just write 3 or 5 books and call it a day, is any story you have to tell in the familiar setting of fantasy novels SO AWESOME you need 10 books of increasing size to tell it?
Sorry, I know since I usually post in the figure athlete forums, I’m going to get screamed at for this, but it’s cool, had to be said.
[/quote]
I have to disagree about Robert Jordan. First off, let me say that I started reading the series right around the time Crossroads of Twilight came out and then New Spring came out shortly after and then Knife of Dreams so for me it wasn’t that long of a wait. Having said that, I am glad that his books are that long. Truthfully, I don’t want to read a book that is set in a comfortable fantasy setting and I know all the rules so nothing comes as a surprise. Jordan’s books started out that way (mainly just Eye of the World) and then built upon themselves to such an extent that one could almost write histories about the nations, peoples, customs, etc. I’m quite sure Jordan could have cut out all of the intracicies and customs that made it a unique world that rises above mere comfortable fantasy, stripped it down to the bare bones plot/action and wrapped it up in 6 or 7 books. It would have felt rushed, sucked, and he wouldn’t have become the huge name in fantasy that he is today.
I don’t think he was doing it for money because the man was a nuclear engineer before writing, he’s owned and lived in the same house in Charleston for decades, and the only frivolities he seems to have purchased were swords and a porsche. Hardly the deeds of a man clamoring for money. To say nothing of the fact that he already had an entirely new series in mind, but he had promised to finish up WOT first.
I do however completely agree with you on Goodkind’s series. First few books were good and then all the rest ended the same: characters have dilemna, solve problem, happy ending? beginning of next book, the way the characters solved the problem created another problem…characters have dilemna, solve problem, happy ending? repeat. And the last few books were half filled with him summarizing the previous books as if someone picks up the eighth book in a series without reading the previous ones. So hands down agree there.
I will say that I’m beginning to suspect GRRM’s A Song of Fire and Ice series to be for money though. The man puts out a few books, claims that the next one is half written and should be out shortly. Then people start ranting because it hasn’t come out so he says Jan 07 it will be done, then it’s Jan 08, now he’s saying it will be done when it’s done…and he still has several books planned after that.
To me, when an author is only writing as thier living, marketing their books through calendars, special editions, an HBO series, etc. and they can’t put out the rest of the series in a timely manner, that is ridiculous. All Martin has to do is write. Even a paltry 1000 words a day, 5 days a week, 50 weeks a year would be 250k. He’s had enough time to write 500k+ words on a book that was already half written.
So yeah, in that light your argument of more money has some validity IMO.
/end rant