[quote]JeffR wrote:
1-packlondoner wrote:
Wow, there’s a lot of people great at cutting and pasting to make their arguments. Just think, if you’d been taught ‘critical thinking’ you probably could have made your points yourselves with both a dash of originality and without having to resort to insults and name-calling. But I digress…
Hey, packlondoner. I wanted to thank you for the pleasure you are giving me. It isn’t often that one of the “90%” of your friends actually has the guts to have their ignorance challenged. I’m serious. It takes guts to come on to a forum where your stale ideas are subject to criticism. You and I both know that most of your friends will cloister themselves in an insulated world peopled by others who agree with them. You, on the other hand, have had the fortitude to vomit up your sterotypes and misconceptions for all to see.
I sincerely thank you.
Now let’s get to it!!! As far as the name calling thing goes, I do believe your first post was full of said insults. If memory serves, I saw “petulant,” “teenager,” and some very unkind swipes at our leadership.
If you are shy about being insulted, it might not be a good idea to cast the first stone.
Now, as far as the cut and paste crap. In an argument with most adults, “feelings” won’t get you very far. If you make a statement, aka…Europe did most of the fighting and the Americans only came in at the end, you are going to have to defend it with facts. I’m sorry if I hurt your feelings with the intellectual boning, but this is how one learns.
Too many point to reply to actual quotes but I’ll address a couple.
Excellent.
- Re WW2, the point is you would think that to read some of the prior posts on this thread that the US single-handedly fought and won that war whereas, as I pointed out, millions had fought and died before you were ‘officially’ on-board.
That’s much more palatable. Your first post was far different. It gave no credit to the Americans working and dying prior to war being declared.
Oh, have you ever heard of the Eagle Squadron? American pilots fighting from September 1940 on during your Blitz.
Get pissed off all you like - It’s a fact. I never said you weren’t welcome once you were there but to ignore or belittle the efforts of everyone else that fought and died is an insult to their memory.
Exactly my beef with your first post. It ignored and belittled the Americans.
Maybe the revisionist history idea means that EVERY country maintains they were responsible for winning it.
Listen to our democrats/revisionists with a grain of salt.
Maybe even Germany is now saying they wre on our side against those pesky Austrians. lol
I hope not.
2)There is another prevailing attitude I’m discovering which is treating Europe like it’s a single entity. Many many countries with different languages, cultures (you know that word?)
Oops, an insult!!! I know you are aware of OUR culture.
and religions make up the EU, and its only natural that they have different priorities. Of course there will be disagreements - Do you always get on with South and Cetral America? Err…? That’ll be a big NO then.
I thought you guys were mature adults? Don’t you guys work things out reasonably?
Oh, wait. Damn it. Those pesky European Union discussions.
3)Re who didn’t want to go to war. Every news poll,
This would be a nice time for a 2003 cut and paste job. Trust me, I could prove you wrong on the 90% number in your own country.
every person I have spoken to
I believe you on this one. Fortunately, I don’t move in your “Love, not oil” crowd. Therefore, I’ll have to take your anectodal reference at face value.
I saw you in this recent demonstration:
From UK indymedia:
Valentine’s Day Protests
Just before Valentine’s Day on Sat 11th Feb, around 600 people took part in Reclaim Love III, providing a counter-point to the greeting card and gift frenzy of Feb 14th - partying at Eros statue in Piccadilly, London - saying ‘Love not oil is the most important resource in the world’
- Every time Tony Blair is interviewed he STILL has to justify why he went to war when the country didn’t want him to.
Again, need some March 2003 information. Thanks.
Again - not opinion - FACT. I won’t talk for the US because I’ve only been to the coasts and I hear Middle-America was largely pro-war but still…
You might want to avoid Middle-America. They don’t share many of your values. You are likely to be called on your many misunderstandings of history.
Finally, I’m not surprised that you’ve only been to the coasts. Birds of a feather.
There’s a train of thought that if you publicly disagree with the war in the US you are branded unpatriotic, whereas over here you can complain all you want about it and they’ll still do whatever the hell they want. Not sure which is worse…
You are unpatriotic if you publically and privately wish for our defeat in Iraq.
Yes your Government lies.
My friend. I’m going to try and be gentle here. I didn’t need my government to tell me anything at all to convince me that Iraq had to be dealt with. Seriously, the pattern was there for anyone to put together. There was going to be a day of reckoning.
Blair and Bush could have said that saddam had wings, and it still wouldn’t have changed the fact that he supported al qaeda, terrorists in Palestine, tried to assassinate our President, used oil to bribe world leaders, butchered, raped, maimed his people in wood chippers, fired on our planes, started two large conflicts in the Middle East, was openly flaunting international law and the peace treaty he signed. The list goes on and on and on.
No amount of “I hate the party in power” crap would change any of that.
So does mine. It is part and parcel of government. It doesn’t have to be some Area 51 conspiracy. It’s massaging unemployment figures.
Our unemployment figures are extremely low. Work to be had.
It’s, I don’t know, bankrolling a regime and then saying they are evil once they are strong enough to stand on their own two feet and don’t need you anymore.
Are you blaming the United States for the sociopathic acts of saddam hussein?
You could give me uranium shells, and I wouldn’t fire them at the local hippies.
It’s awarding billions of dollars worth of construction and oil contracts to all your old buddies and contributors and saying God said we should go to war.
This might be a good time to ask you to watch more than one U.S. news source.
You do have a knack of picking up on democratic talking points.
HALLIBURTON!!! If you knew what you were talking about, you would realize that Halliburton was the only company with the know-how to get the job done. If you had a clue about this issue, you would be able to recall the many instances where our democrats called solely on Halliburton because they were the best for the situation.
I’m going to give it to you plain: If George Bush said that the Easter Bunny laid an egg that said, “invade Iraq,” it still would have been the right thing to do. I’ve been kind enough to write you a list of reasons. Any one of those could have justified the invasion.
As for everyone saying how crap Europe is - the most absurd assertion I have ever heard. Unless of course art, history and culture have no meaning and you mean they’re crap because there’s not a Target or Cinabun every 100 yards.
Well, now. That’s another nice, little insult. I have you at many disadvantages. One of which, is that I’ve travelled extensively in Great Britain. I didn’t confine myself to one area. Even if I had, I probably wouldn’t have made such an absurd generalization.
Our culture, science, art, and music are the glory of the human race. People die every day trying to reach our shores. To distill our greatness down to supermarket chains, illustrates your breath-taking myopia.
Yes, Britain and Europe has been responsible for some pretty terrible things in history but that’s my point. Collectively we have grown up and are waiting for you to do the same.
What a bunch of rubbish. Shall we talk about the Balkans? Shall we talk about your bloody riots? Shall we talk about some of your members excluding Turkey from the EU? Shall we talk about the rise of Muslim anti-semitism in Europe?
Tell it to our lefties. The rest of us know the truth.
To sum up, Britain is America’s closest ally and if you ask the man on the street over here you will find that we (although not me as I have American family) don’t like you very much at all. Seriously. Not joking.
They did a nice job of hiding it when I was there. Seriously.
So what does that say about the way the rest of the world feels? Are you honestly so full of hubris that you think that all stems from jealousy and not from your Government’s actions and foreign policy?
I could think of plenty of reasons. You’d have to add getting in the way of lucrative oil contracts with sociopathic dictators. Exposing corruption, bribery, and malfeasance at the highest levels of european government. Exposing hypocrisy with regard to religion.
Shall I go on?
Re the reply to my little bodyfat joke - ‘Barely enough to sustain life?’ WTF? lol
Only cos you lot ate all the food you fat cheeseburger-eating motherfuckers. JOKE!
Funny, but not relevant.
Thanks again for everything. I hope you take the time to realize that there are other voices. You haven’t done yourself a favor living in an insular environment. I hope you are mature enough to learn from others.
JeffR
[/quote]
Hi again,
Very interesting post and good to hear you elaborate more on the points you made.
V quickly, as to my news sources - I am a TV Producer and have worked in the news and on current affairs shows - I have also seen news feeds that no-one was allowed to broadcast regarding what is going on in Afghanistan and Iraq - I really don’t feel my opinions have been formed due to the lack of knowledge but I think it’s fairly safe to say we are coming at this from two diametrically opposed viewpoints and that neither will give an inch.
Was about to point-by-point respond to the points you brought up that I took issue with but then thought you will just do the same back and then I will and so on and so forth.
Can’t be fucked with all this so I’ll just say that let’s all be friends and agree to disagree, leaving it for my part with the big question -
Post Gulf War 2, which we didn’t need to have, is the world a safer place or a less safe place? Answers on a postcard…
PS Can’t believed you called me a hippy. lol - Total insult to my T-man status. I EAT hippies. Laters