[quote]power_bulker wrote:
FightingScott wrote:
11/25/2008 - Upper Back
Dumbbell Row:
65X10
115X5
135X5
155X10 (Fell Apart)
155X15
I would train back all day if I could but I got to get on the road. Weather is bad.
I noticed from a few logs that people prefer the DB row. What do you think of the DB row vs. BB row (assuming you use good form in the BB row)? It seems like I can progress faster on the DB rows, but the form is inconsistent. [/quote]
Sorry, but this will be long. I just love training back.
Both have given me incredible results. What sets the Barbell Row apart from the Dumbbell Row is both its weaknesses and its assets - it is very demanding on the entire body. It’s right up there with Deadlifts.
The Summer Before Last I concentrated heavily on Free Back Squats and Barbell Rows. I think I left my Senior Year of High School Messing around with 155-185 on Barbell Rows and I came into college flirting with 275. My form was pretty loose. If you need a reference point, just look at Ronnie Coleman in The Unbelieveable Video or Jay Cutler whenever he does them. I strongly believe this looser form is actually the way to go for Barbell Rows.
As long as you keep your lower back arched and strong you will be safe. Some people may criticize this way of doing Barbell Rows and suggest that you’re doing a movement that’s obviously using hips and hamstrings as well as lats. Whatever. As long as you keep your lower back arched you will be safe and as long as you keep a perpendicular enough of a body angle you will hit the lats and you just simply won’t be able to cheat that much. This is the way I see all the super strong people doing Barbell Rows. I have done them the super strict “Pendlay” way and I find that this is more dependent on the upper back than the lats, and that a great amount of energy is expended trying to stay perfectly still and strict - so much that it compromises the effectiveness of the exercise. Keep reps in between 6-12.
Do 1 heavy set (maybe 8) then 1 lighter but still heavy set (maybe 12). I figured this out before learning about DC. Try to make a PR on each set, but don’t leave the gym if you don’t make a PR for weight or reps in at least 1 of these sets - it should be doable.
In this time my bodyweight also went up from around 150 to 175. I also got slightly leaner and I was lean to begin with. Almost all the weight I gained was in my lats, lower back, traps, and glutes. In hitting Barbell Rows heavy I also increased my Deadlift a fair bit. So in terms of full-body strength gains I think Barbell Rows are superior to Dumbbell Rows. In my experience, they are better than Cleans or Olympic Style Pulls of any sort. I would advise you to train your Barbell Rows on Lower Body days after you Squat so that they do not interfere with your Lower Body workouts.
I find Dumbbell Rows to be the best for packing on strength and size in the Lats. That, and you can move up in weight with Dumbbell Rows very quickly. The gains come fast and they haven’t stopped for me yet - but you will not see the total-body strenght gains in adding weight to Dumbbell Rows that you will see from adding weight to Barbell Rows. Nor will you see the same Bodyweight Gain - which could be a plus depending on your goals. Dumbbell Rows have also given me more Lat Size than Barbell Rows. I know this for a fact since Barbell Rows gave me lats instead of just bare ribs, but Dumbbell Rows have given me a large web of stretch marks right where my lats meet my triceps.
As far as form goes, I do mine sort of like the set up Kroc uses - except instead of putting my free hand on a back raise I do them in a Power Rack and put my free hand on a barbell that rests on about the 5th pin (about Mid-Shin if you’re rack pulling). I also take the narrow sumo stance that he takes. I do not use a belt because with the rep ranges I use (10-25) I find that it inhibits breathing. This is the heaviest set Kroc had ever done at this point and the reps are pretty slow and involve a lot of cheating. I think the ideal rep speed and form for this exercise can be seen when he’s doing 225X25 or 175X30something strapless. So imagine that cadence and strictness with the set up similar to what he uses in this video.
Unlike Barbell Rows, my form is pretty strict. I allow my shoulder to round forward at the bottom of the row so I can fully stretch my lat, then I pull as fast as I can and pull the dumbbell into me - right in the middle of my abs. I don’t move my feet or hips at all. Speed is key for getting the most reps possible. I currently try to do them strapless. I would recommend that on Barbell Rows you use straps all the time to maximize the weight you can pull but on Dumbbell Rows make sure you keep pushing up both your Strapless and Strapped numbers or just always tug strapless. For some reason, I also feel that a set of strapless dumbbell rows with 155 for 15 will work my lats better than a set done with straps at 165. Maybe it’s just something about having to squeeze the bar harder. But If I’m rowing a 185lb dumbbell with straps, then my lats will probably get a better workout from than they will from a 155er - but the difference in weight needs to be pretty signifigant for you to justify using straps on Dumbbell Rows. So remember that when you’re struggling without straps and you’re tempted to throw on some straps.