[quote]BobParr wrote:
[quote]roybot wrote:
Dredd - screenwriter/ novelist Alex Garland (Sunshine, 28 Days Later, Never Let Me Go) continues his winning streak by grafting his own unique brand of smart sci-fi onto what is essentially a John Carpenter movie.
The retro soundtrack and '80s style, pull-no-punches gore are very welcome additions in a time where inherently violent material is watered down to draw in a wider audience, usually leaving the end product creatively dead in the water.
If you like, it is a 200 floor, futuristic version of The Raid, but while The Raid has a superior quota of bone-crushing fights, Dredd has The Raid beat in just about every other area.
Everything I thought would be weak or gimmicky were brilliantly handled: the slo-mo drug is not just an excuse for 300-style visual excess. Hint: it can prolong suffering as well as pleasure.
Lena Headey as Ma Ma was not your typical super powered end of level boss ninja chick. Her rise to power and subsequent fall is very much facilitated by the world she was born into.
The deaths of at least two minor characters linger in the memory of the two trapped Judges and feed into Dredd’s absolute vision of justice vs. Anderson’s more naturally intuitive vision of what true justice is.
She’s a psychic and a mutant , BTW, a perk of living near the border wall separating Mega City One from the radioactive Cursed Earth.
It’s not a reboot either : Dredd’s career is in full-flow and his rep as Mega City One’s toughest judge precedes him. We never get to know Dredd other than through how others perceive him which is how it should be. He is a walking grimace. Karl Urban is great: he disappears into the role and is not your typical tough guy in the sense that crowds would clear on his arrival: nobody but his fellow judges know who he is ;).
Maybe my fave movie of the year so far. An absolute old school blast.
[/quote]
I saw the posters and assumed it was a remake of Judge Dredd (Sylvester Stallone), which was a failed action movie based on a fairly obscure comic book. Sounds like it’s not the same character at all.
[/quote]
It’s not a remake of the Stallone movie. Both movies were based on the Judge Dredd comic strip which Paul Verhoeven credits as his primary inspiration for Robocop. Robocop’s violent satire was ripped straight from the pages of Dredd’s mother comic book 2000AD and those fake commercials you see in Robocop, Running Man, Predator 2 are quintessentially ‘Dredd’.
P.S. I’m a fan of the original Dredd stories so I judged the movie (pun maybe or maybe not intended) on its own merits. I didn’t sentence it to life in an iso-cube.
P.P.S. The Dredd / Anderson dynamic is straight out of the comic. But the backstory doesn’t matter. This is Dredd training a rookie.