Don't Be A Teacher

[quote]Bauer97 wrote:
mike08042 wrote:
purdiver wrote:
Both my parents are/were teachers. My dad recently retired after teaching for 36 years. The pay really isn’t that bad. Sure he started making around 5k but when he retired he was approaching 60k. I’m sure someone in a business field with that much experience and a masters would be making more, but being a teacher allowed him to have free time to always be able to participate in my activities growing up and actually spend time with the family.

60K??? Damn, that isnt bad. Maybe the system in Canada is alot worse… My dad wasnt even close to that after 20 years…

The pay scales for teaching vary so drastically by region it’s ridiculous.

Where I’m at in PA, my fiancee is starting her first year as a teacher this coming fall, and she starts at $41,000.

Pay scale, with your masters and something like 15 years of teaching, tops out at $103,000. Not too shabby if you ask me.

However, move down to Florida, and I think that same pay scale tops out at something like $44,000.[/quote]

Yeah, my anatomy teacher has a bachelors in some kind of sports science from UM, and then a masters from Auburn University in the same field I think, and he probably makes about 40k a year, and he’s been teaching for 18 years so far.

For the most part though, most teachers here in Florida definitely don’t make a lot. I think the most I’ve heard a teacher make with a masters and over 15 years experience is maybe 50k max. After that, you need to become administration to see some larger figures.

[quote]jtrinsey wrote:
I just finished my freshman year at college where I’m going to earn a math degree (maybe a double in physics as well). Going into college I wanted to be an actuary, as I know there’s supposed to be a good amount of employment opportunities and a ton of room for pay advance.

However, lately I’m thinking that I would get a lot more satisfaction out of being a teacher than working as a suit in some corporation. Sports have always been a big part of my life and I’d really like to coach, which I don’t think I’d be able to do working a “9-5”.

To me, money isn’t as important as job satisfaction.[/quote]

I say this with only your best interest at heart, with God as my witness: be an actuary. Don’t let your spirit be sucked away by a dying system. Our educational system uses your desire to help children as a weapon against you. By feeding this monstrosity with the goodness of your heart, you allow this ‘thing’ to live on. It’ll trade your life, your desire to make the world a better place, for an extra 15 minutes of existence. It is dead. Let it go.

HH

[quote]jtrinsey wrote:
I just finished my freshman year at college

To me, money isn’t as important as job satisfaction.[/quote]

Congratulations on finishing your freshman year.

I know Teachers, Police Officers and others who are extremely happy and do a great job. It all depends on your particular take on things. I am self employed but haven’t always been. I was in the “corporate suit” bureaucracy world for several years and often considered doing something else that I’d enjoy much more.

The thing that kept me satisfied was the enjoyment that came from the things I have been able to do for my family and others.

As you mature and assume additional responsibilities you may find that financial concerns will test your enthusiasm for your chosen field if your heart is not in it.

With housing, energy and just about everything except Teacher compensation
moving upwards, I imagine the pressures of that particular field are increasing daily.

God bless the good Teachers out there.
We need them all and I think they deserve a little extra time off if for no other reason than to get a second job to pay their bills.

[quote]doogie wrote:
HH,

Get out now.

You’ll be better off.
Your students will be better off.
Your co-workers will be better off.

No one is forcing you to teach.
Teachers like you (who bitch and moan) are a cancer. Your disease infects your students and then spreads into the classrooms of dedicated teachers. You are the guy everyone avoids during their off period, because they know if you corner them they will be subjected to a 45 minute bitch session about how “these kids today just don’t…” or about how “the administration just doesn’t…” or even about how your hemmorhoids are flaring up today.

Teaching is great. Teaching is EASY if you actually care and if you actually get yourself organized.

When is the last time you used a personal day to visit another school to observe great teachers? When is the last time you did homevisits?

THE FIRST DAYS OF SCHOOL–buy it, read it about 200 times this summer, and get your shit together. I’ve never met a teacher with excellent classroom management who didn’t love their job.

Bottom line, love it or quit.

[/quote]

Doogie,
I respect your views as I know you are well-read and have principles. (No pun intended!)

I don’t think I was bitching and crying. If you read my posts, I simply warn others about what has been done to my profession. When I began teaching, in 1981, many good teachers were still around. The decline was not yet obvious, at least not to me. I made an error and have to live with it. That doesn’t mean I can’t warn others not to do what I did. Maybe they’ll have a wonderful experience. (Then ‘comes the dawn’.)

I will read the book you recommended. But, I don’t think it’ll convince that I’m not standing on the deck of the Titanic when I know I am.

HH

HH,

Have you considered opening a DOJO?
That way you could teach, train, would be self employed and could take off when you wanted by letting a couple of black belts handle the classes.

Then run for the local school board and let the hammer fall.

[quote]Chris Aus wrote:
Headhunter wrote:
After 25 years of teaching, having students go on to West Point, Notre Dame, Brown, and becoming dept chairman, I feel I have the right and duty to say: DON’T TEACH.

Be a CPA, a scientist, an actuary…just don’t teach. I know several here are in process of becoming teachers. Don’t. I know its not my business…I just hate to see others suffer.

Realize that you are watching a profession be destroyed by bureaucrats, politicians, and apathetic parents. It will be destoyed and eventually replaced by some sort of technology. Don’t be there to watch it happen.

HH

reasonable money with very good hours, lots of free time, and TONS of holidays…

sounds okay to me[/quote]

Mrs. Pittbull was a teacher. At least an hour per subject of preparation per day, correcting home work, preparing for any tests finals and now for state requirements and Federal Requirements make for a big job. I would not be a teacher. I do not have the temperament to deal with adolescent misbehavior. Nor after 14 hour days plus time on week ends through out the school year does a 9 week break seem to compensate

someone pm’d me about teaching in china, i figured part of my reply was relevant to this discussion so here it is, (heavily edited). Just to give a different perspective;

hey dude

I totally recommend doing it. I graduated law school in England five years ago and was desperate to travel. I had a choice of four countries, china, Japan, Spain and Peru. I was really into Japanese culture and manga and all that crap so I took Japan off the list, same with Spain cos it was too close to England and Peru bc of all the political, social problems and people vanishing and shit. I knew 100% about china. I thought it was the same country as Japan. I knew nothing at all so I figured that would be the most interesting place. I bought a lonely planet guide for emergencies but didn?t open it until two years later looking for a photo i might have stuffed inside it.
It has been and still is the best decision of my life - it totally changes your perspectives on the world around you, how you feel and deal with difficult situations and more importantly helped me really figure out who I was and what I wanted to do with my life. I?ve always wanted to do something with my writing and this inspired me in so many ways. If you?re (still a poet then you?re going to be writing amazing stuff bc living in somewhere this diverse and strange strips away all pre-conceptions and literary conventions you?ve acquired). I was really lucky because I brought that sense of adventure with me and completely avoided all the other foreigners. I didn?t know a single word of Chinese when I got there, now can speak fluent Chinese, people who talk to me on the phone think I?m Chinese or that I?m bullshitting if I say I’m a foreigner. I didn?t study Chinese AT ALL. I never sat down to study or took lessons, its mainly a process of osmosis because you hear it all the time. It is not at all necessary to learn the language to get by. Sure it helps but if you don’t (formally) study you learn the most important words first and your language becomes much more useful than ?This is Qing Chon, see Qing Chon run?.
I’ve also been really lucky because I worked with some decent schools. My first school was owned by a company called SHANE which is good for starting out because they provide all the basics. The salaries are ok, but just ok. The price of living there is really, really cheap. I stayed with them for three years until they wanted to promote me to director of studies (i.e. school owner’s bitch) so i left and got a much higher paying job doing fuck all teaching rich businessmen and adults - but I really missed teaching kids so that got boring so i found another part time job teaching English in a local college and writing for a local newspaper making really decent green. I these three jobs at the same time (as well as study for a degree in English lit by long distance) because you don’t need to do the same crappy hours as everyone else. It kills me that the people I go to school with are still in my hometown (Manchester) doing 9-5 jobs in tiny cubicles and offices. Most schools send you out to other private schools or school trips. Best thing is that most foreigners don’t want to work at all, they just stumble in half drunk and tell the class ?tell each other about yourselves for the next three hours? so if you?re really kinesthetic or creative you get promoted easily, get lots of overtime and (simply) have the time of your life.

I met the strangest people but also the best, I’m lucky enough to have met three Chinese guys who are now my brothers - have met a great girl who next year is going to be my wife (also Chinese) and also made a comparable difference in myself, my outlook and a really appreciation of my life. After you see a guy with no face diggin through rubbish bins for food, you get really thankful for what you have (or buy him a raccoon suit). Bc China is still a developing country everyone works really hard and plays really hard and again it ills me to come back to the west and see the total apathy people live by.

I totally recommend it. If you?re interested in teaching in china i can pass your cv on to the two schools I mentioned above. I would totally avoid using websites to apply, you need to have a contact you can speak to in person or on the phone because they usually have some experience and can help you decide which country suits you best.

[quote]Headhunter wrote:
Chris Aus wrote:
Im not saying thats its a walk in the park, but seriously those conditions arent bad… with a reasonable starting wage which on average is comparable with law, economics, accounting, nursing degrees etc

Quiz time Chris (and anyone else) :slight_smile:

Suppose that teacher pay goes up 2% per year but inflation is 3%. How long until you’re purchasing power is half of what you started with?

Remember, there are no promotions in teaching, just more duties. An accountant, fireman, and so on can get promoted. Teachers can’t, unless they go into admin (which is no longer teaching).

If it helps, you can use $30,000 to start (slightly above the national average), and an exponential growth model.

Answer later! Have fun! :wink:

HH

[/quote]

Noone tried it, or maybe didn’t notice it. Anyway…hint…

30000(.99)^x = 15000

Solve the equation for x.

HH

[quote]Go-Rilla wrote:
HH,

Have you considered opening a DOJO?
That way you could teach, train, would be self employed and could take off when you wanted by letting a couple of black belts handle the classes.

Then run for the local school board and let the hammer fall.[/quote]

Pardon the picky teacher: For me its DOCHANG ;).

I actually am considering going partners in a local small business. A good friend started it several years ago, it’s grown A LOT, and he wants me to come in with him, since he is being overwhelmed. If it makes enough $$$$, I will leave teaching.

I have thought of opening a martial arts academy, but that’s a tough business to make go. I don’t mind hard work but I have lots of old injuries and sparring every day (at 51) is rough. Also, several have closed in this area over the past few years as well.

HH

[quote]jtrinsey wrote:
I just finished my freshman year at college where I’m going to earn a math degree (maybe a double in physics as well). Going into college I wanted to be an actuary, as I know there’s supposed to be a good amount of employment opportunities and a ton of room for pay advance.
[/quote]

Make sure you finish your vee’s in university. If you like spending all your free time studying than you will love being an actuary. I’m studying 3-4 hours everyday of my summer break.

To the OP: have you considered private school? Granted, it’s not perfect either, but the really good schools are a hell of a lot better than the average public school out there.

And yes, certain parts of teaching aren’t so much fun. But if you yourself love learning, find the world to be interesting, believe that the intellectual development of young people is of paramount importance, and find it thrilling to see a classroom of students ‘get it’, it is a job with powerful rewards.

I worked for Google (was there for the IPO) and a startup in the area even though my background is in philosophy and classics. After a few years I bailed out for teaching and I’ve never regretted it. Yes, my coworkers are not as passionate as I am. Yes, some of the parents are snotty. Yes, my principal is a chump.

But you know what? Sometimes all I have to do is remind myself to close the door to my classroom and teach like hell, regardless of what’s happening outside. The students deserve better than the shitty teaching they get most of the time, and I can’t think of anything I’d rather do.

Being a teacher apparently has good benefits.

[quote]spartanpower wrote:

Teachers and soldiers are worlds apart, because soldiers don’t fucking cry, they just get the job done.

I’m not a teacher because it doesn’t appeal to me, simple or not.[/quote]

You’ve never read Jarhead have you? In between his nonsensical metaphors and gibberish philosophy, he spends a good couple hundred pages complaining about the military.

[quote]mike08042 wrote:
purdiver wrote:
Both my parents are/were teachers. My dad recently retired after teaching for 36 years. The pay really isn’t that bad. Sure he started making around 5k but when he retired he was approaching 60k. I’m sure someone in a business field with that much experience and a masters would be making more, but being a teacher allowed him to have free time to always be able to participate in my activities growing up and actually spend time with the family.

60K??? Damn, that isnt bad. Maybe the system in Canada is alot worse… My dad wasnt even close to that after 20 years… [/quote]

$60k is damn good money for a teacher, IMO. My in-laws have been teaching for 30 years; one (high school) makes $38k, the other (juco) makes about $45k. Hell, in college (10 yrs ago) my department head had been in that position 20 years and only made $58k.

[quote]blitzkrg wrote:
Being a teacher apparently has good benefits.

Trysting Teachers Caught In Act | The Smoking Gun [/quote]

No Kidding!

3,496…Damn!

NOVEMBER 21–Meet Deanna Bobo. The 37-year-old Arkansas woman is the 3,496th teacher to be arrested this year on charges that she had sex with an underage student (in this case, a 14-year-old boy). Bobo, a special ed teacher at Raymond E. Wells Junior High School, is facing a felony sexual assault count for her alleged encounters earlier this year with the student. Bobo, who was arrested last week and released

HH,

Seriously, you can’t go into the classroom with that attitude. If that is how you feel about teaching, do something else. Life is too short to do something you don’t like, and your students deserve someone who passionately loves teaching.

If you are going to stay in teaching, go visit a great school. KIPP in Buffalo or Indianapolis or Gary are all close to you (but very new).

http://www.kippsankofa.org/index.html

http://www.kipplead.org/06/

This one in DC is more established:
http://www.keyacademy.org/desktopdefault.aspx?page_id=51

Hell, fly down and visit us or go to Houston and visit YES College Prep:
http://ideaacademy.org/

These are all schools catering to the poorest of the poor, from families with no history of valuing education, started by people who do love teaching and who decided to make a difference.

Try to spend sometime with ANYONE from Teach for America and see if you don’t love teaching again:
http://www.teachforamerica.org/flash_movie.html

You can be as unhappy as you want to make yourself, but the truth is you are the king of your classroom. Within those four walls, as long as you are doing what you know is best for your students day in and day out, none of the other bullshit matters.

[quote]doogie wrote:
Within those four walls, as long as you are doing what you know is best for your students day in and day out, none of the other bullshit matters. [/quote]

Amen, brother. Like I said up above, close the door and teach like hell.

[quote]doogie wrote:
You can be as unhappy as you want to make yourself, but the truth is you are the king of your classroom. Within those four walls, as long as you are doing what you know is best for your students day in and day out, none of the other bullshit matters. [/quote]

That’s not always the case. The Conservative government here a few years back got in power based chiefly off of an absolutely brutal slander campaign against teachers. They then put a high school dropout in charge of the education system (I kid you not), and the Premiere was a former teacher who’d been canned.

They attacked the education system with a vendetta. They purposely instituted reforms that caused a bigger mess, with the intent of “fixing” it before their term was up and looking like heroes. The end result was a bloody catastrophe.

The Conservatives legislated teaching to Hell and back. Inefficient curriculums were put in place, and your job’s on the line if you don’t pander to them. Politically correct double-talk was made the language of choice for report cards – parents can’t decipher them, and even if they could, implying anything negative about a student’s progress can earn you disciplinary action. Students no longer fail a grade, save in the most extreme of cases where a specific request has to be made to hold the child back.

It’s absolutely nightmarish. Unfortunately the Liberal government is proving to be just as bungling and incompetent. The education system put in place by the Conservatives in the 70’s was a fantastic one. But now? It’s insane. So many teachers left the profession during a two year period under the Conservatives that they ended up with a massive shortage.

In Ontario it’s required that you have a university degree, followed by a year in teacher’s college. They were experiencing such a shortage that they were taking people with no educational background to fill in the blanks. Textbooks for the “new curriculum” were half a year late in being produced.

End to end, a freakin’ mess. And the government blamed it all on the teachers. They had an excellent PR crew who proceeded to go out to British Columbia and do the same thing there.

[quote]Northcott wrote:
A Canadian horror story

[/quote]

I forgot to put the disclaimer that my post was addressing teaching in the U.S. and should not be read as referring, in any way, to teaching in America Junior.

[quote]spartanpower wrote:
tmanners wrote:
Chris Aus wrote:

HH

reasonable money with very good hours, lots of free time, and TONS of holidays…

sounds okay to me

Obviousy you don’t know any teachers. All teachers have huge workloads they take home after working 8-3 in australia. Ask them when they mark work, keep updated on the sylabus and set lessons. I’m traing to be a teacher and I am not thinking I’m getting off easy because they get 12 weeks of holidays a year.

Boo fucking hoo. You consider 8-3 with a lunch a huge workload? It’s a good thing you’re going to be a teacher, because the real world would swallow you whole.

High school teachers in the States work roughly 7-3 each day. The first 40 min and the last 30 min of each day are free. The teachers teach 6 out of 8 periods with a 30 minute lunch break. So, out of 8 hours, they’re only teaching for roughly 4.5. That’s an extra 3.5 to plan, grade, and masturbate to their little hearts’ content. If you’ve been teaching for more than 2 or 3 years and you STILL have to take work home, then you’re probably not doing much work at school.

I’m sick of these fucking primadonnas that think they’re god’s gift because they’re “educators.” If a true professional wants a pay increase, he can either ask his boss for one or he can quit and get another job that pays better. Teachers just go on strike. That’s unprofessional. If a professional wants better benefits he can pay for them himself, ask his employer to change plans, or find a new employer. Teachers just go on strike. Unprofessional again. If a company wants to get rid of a senior employee because they make too much money or they are losing their edge, they can fire them. If a tenured teacher starts using the same lesson plans and tests over and over and begins to suck as a teacher, he can only be fired if the school’s administrators find a dead baby in his freezer. How is that equivalent to any other professional field?

So, basically, all of you teachers need to shut the fuck up and stop your fucking whining. Nobody cares how hard or thankless you find your job. Speaking of hard and thankless, have any of you fucks (US only) ever found yourselves crying about marking a paper with a red pen, and then you realized that there are men in the desert 15,000 miles away risking their lives to protect our country?

For the record, I know a few teachers, and the only ones that complain about their workloads are the ones that had never held a real job prior to becoming a teacher.[/quote]

Amen brother!

Teaching English in Korea is the easiest job ever. The education system is based around cash flow so naturally, it’s all Public Relations and little learning. Students here have 8 hours of school then often go to an institute after school for up to 6 hours… that’s 14 hours a day! And how do they compare to students in the US who spend 8 hours max a day going to school? Outside of being a little stronger in math, I think they’re actually a lot worse off. Their social lives are shit, school’s a joke, and they never learn what “no” or “deadline” mean. What starts in elementary carrys on through adulthood as well. Teachers have an 8 hour workday but they only teach classes for 4 hours… the rest of the time is simply spent keeping busy and EVERYONE is busy because if you’re not busy, there’s more work for you to do. So many teachers bitch all the time about how hard things are, and most start to believe it after a while… forgetting that the initial bitching was just a cover. This is the easiest job I think I’ll ever have. I get about 2 months of paid vacation, I can leave school early if I have a semi-valid reason… want to take a 10 minute dump during the middle of class… no problem! Just assign a puzzle or something else to keep the kids busy and off you go. How about class start and end times? Walk into class 10 minutes late… no problem! Shit, it usually takes the kids 10 minutes to settle down with a Korean teacher present so why show up earlier? Lesson planning? What’s a lesson plan? Oh, you mean in the states many teachers do a write-up of what they’ll be doing in class before it happens? Before every class!!! Ah yes, we do that once a semester and then get “helpful” feedback from people who we don’t know and don’t give a shit… I’ll never be fired as long as I’m not causing problems.

There’s a ton of beaurocratic bullshit, but I don’t let it affect me. If they want to fire me, they can. Otherwise, they can shut the hell up or yell at the wall cause I’m not going to listen. I won’t get fired though cause I don’t do anything stupid, and I come from the US… a place where logic determines action more often than “cultural expectations”. I’m not Korean, so I don’t have to deal with the beaurocratic bs. In the states I was an American, so again, I didn’t have to deal with beaurocratic bs. I never will deal with it because it’s stupid and I can always get another job. I have yet to be fired working this way.

Teaching in the states, Australia, elsewhere harder… 99% positive it is. Yet unless you’re at the elite level, your qualifications probably mean little. I had idiots for teachers all the way through college who had horrible presentation skills and often lacked mastery of the material they were teaching. To be fair though, I also had a few incredible teachers that cared to help me learn when I had a question, and to them I’ll be forever thankful.

I’ve done manual labor, worked in retail stores, done some management, and now work in education. I’ve never had a hard job, and the majority of people I know in all fields are quite unexceptional. People walking down the street all have a great story and are usually sociable if you’re just kind to them, but few people are exceptional… fits the definition of the word.

Teaching for me is a cakewalk… I think most people simply have never experienced hard work when they complain about their jobs. Learn to love your job. My job’s not about education… it’s about having fun with kids, teaching them a thing or two when appropriate, and self-improvement in all my free time. First define what you’re actually doing in your job and then it will be easier to enjoy it. I didn’t like my job at first because I thought a teacher is supposed to make kids smarter… duhhh, wrong… at least in my job. After I realized people didn’t want me to make their kids smarter, everyone was a lot happier.