This is a great launching point for a rant, especially since both of my coaches just teamed up to bug me to hit up an open mat. They’re both so far now, but I’m overdue.
To me it all depends on what someone wants to get out of grappling. I chose to never pollute my head with points strategies, deliberately going out of my way to know very little about the specifics. I get the concept, though.
Going for points is, in my opinion, nearly mutually exclusive with training to handle violence with your bare hands. Not 100 percent, because you’ll always be growing more capable than before, but that re-ordering of priorities is how we ended up with so many schools where very little is done on the feet and “serious” competitions with shameful and un-watchable butt-scooting and donkey guard.
I know of a few rooms where, say, my old bouncing co-worker, who does not lift or train, could walk into and have zero people capable of consistently bringing him to the ground under normal sparring conditions. He’s 50 and probably around 350lbs right now. I’ve never sparred with him, but I’ve watched him work.
Contrast that with the place I mentioned in Portland, where I’d say most normal-sized purple belts and above would figure something out within a minute or less. Even the blues and senior whites will have a somewhat organized toolbox and get him down occasionally, even if he’s a bigger puzzle box than most. Browns and blacks would likely be very quick and decisive about it, or at least be able to if they chose to be aggressive.
As a sport, it’s perfectly fine if you want to play points games. All grappling competitions are games, and sub-only isn’t THAT much closer to a “real” fight than IBJJF points rules are. I only competed in sub-only, which was a worthwhile experience but not something I aspire to do at a high level.
Introducing points introduces incentives to train in a way that’s less effective in a violent situation. IBJJF rules and points are basically the same thing that happened with Judo over the last century, but less entertaining for casual spectators to watch.
From everything I’ve learned about all this, what’s going on in that room in Portland is probably closer to Judo as it existed before becoming an Olympic sport than Judo is today. In Kano’s time, Judo was training all of grappling that worked, excluding all “too deadly to train” techniques that can’t be trained with intensity against resistance.
As to my favorite “BJJ” competition format, I present more of my coach’s coach’s ideas.
My coach floated the idea of me competing in one of these “burners” that his coach put on, but I decided that the risk outweighed any reward and did not put my name forward in my late 30’s. This “Reality Check BJJ” is, all things considered, my favorite BJJ competition format I’ve ever seen. As a concept, it introduces a significant amount of realism that forces you to respect strikes in your grappling.
As an aside, ALL of the curriculum at Jay’s school respects strikes. That’s why you’ll learn a side control escape there where you glue your ear to the person’s arm in the hopes that they rip it away to strike, allowing you to get back up in base (to your feet). It’s basically a Turkish Get Up, but with a body.
His whole curriculum is (mostly) cross-compatible between gi and no-gi, as well. I really can’t say enough good things about the genius of the methodology this man had developed. Kind of like original Judo, part of the genius is in what he DOESN’T include on the curriculum.
He’s produced quite a few high-level grapplers and locally competitive fighters, but no UFC champions. What he has produced is a LOT of VERY dangerous people who have real capabilities. The first gal in this video (wearing the leggings) was a three or four stripe white belt at the time, and her organized response and his coaching is quite evident here.
Edit: During the course of my rant I lost sight of addressing the rather wild idea of sub attempts for points. I’m not surprised it was more fun to watch, as it encouraged more activity.
To me the really interesting thing to ponder is how “BJJ” would look after 10 years of re-ordering the training priorities around winning in this competition format. Would something emerge that tops donkey guard?
If I exclude my local competition format I linked above, I think F2W put on the best grappling competitions overall. It is probably the most watch-able, too. I’m proud to have gotten tapped out by a few people who’ve competed and won in it!