[quote]therajraj wrote:
[quote]DBCooper wrote:
[quote]therajraj wrote:
[quote]DBCooper wrote:
He’s lying. He’s full of shit. First of all, as someone who has actually played baseball and thrown 85+mph, I can tell you that Sheen was not even coming close to 85mph in that movie and his throwing motion was so poor that if he could throw 85 with that delivery than with a more mechanically-sound delivery he would be throwing even harder than that.
Furthermore, steroids aren’t going to help put that much velocity on someone’s fastball in that short of a time. 6-8 weeks is about the same time it would take to regain arm strength if someone hasn’t thrown in a while, so even if he could throw 85, he reached that false speed simply because it took him that long to stretch his arm out and regain his arm strength.
This is just some bullshit attempt by Charlie Sheen to try and get more people to watch Major League again so he continues to remain somewhat relevant in the public’s mind.[/quote]
So it’s impossible for steroids to increase a persons fastball 6mph in 6-8 weeks (still a slow fastball by Major League standards), but it’s possible for drugs to turn a player who hit 3 home runs between April '09 and August '09 into a 50+ home run type hitter by September '09? For anyone not following, I’m referring to Jose Bautista.
Also If you write a huge wall of text I’m just not going to bother reading your response.
[/quote]
I have a feeling I’m entering into an intellectual quagmire by engaging you in a conversation as ridiculous as this. But I’ll try.
First of all, your comparison of Sheen to Bautista is asinine. I have never claimed that Bautista is on steroids so I really don’t know why you would bring him into the conversation. If you can come somewhat close to convincing me that Bautista is anywhere close to being relevant to this conversation I might respond. Otherwise, just drop the Bautista thing entirely. I’m not Cuban32 and I do not intend to engage you in a pages-long argument that goes nowhere.
As for Sheen, no it is not impossible for steroids to increase the velocity on one’s fastball, but it is very unlikely that steroids are responsible for adding 6mph in 6-8 weeks to Sheen’s fastball. First of all, the only way steroids are going to put velocity on a fastball is by strengthening the pitcher’s legs and lower back, and even then this tends to allow a pitcher to throw longer at the same speed more so than it allows them to throw harder overall.
I’ve never seen a healthy pitcher, EVER, add 6mph to their fastball in 6-8 weeks simply from gaining strength. It happens due to fixing a major mechanical flaw, recovering from injury or working back into throwing shape after the offseason.
My point is that what Sheen attributes to steroids is probably just him regaining his motion and arm strength naturally. If steroids were really capable of that kind of addition in velocity, Roger Clemens wouldn’t have seen his velocity steadily dip as he grew older. It would have at least stayed the same, if not gone up, if this was true.
At the time when he allegedly started using steroids, Clemens was still throwing mid to high 90’s on a regular basis. Why didn’t he make the jump into a consistent triple-digit velocity. If it was as simple as taking steroids, EVERY pitcher would take them.
Look, Sheen was apparently a pretty decent player in high school and I don’t think he was more than maybe 26 or 27 when he filmed Major League, so if he had the potential at one point to throw hard, then I could see how he was able to put that kind of velocity onto his fastball in such a short time. Think about it. If you could add 6mph to any Major League pitcher, they’d all be entirely different.
There is a huge difference between 85 and 91 and 97. You know when you see that kind of jump in velocity normally? Between the first and second or third week of Spring Training when pitchers are still working themselves into shape. That’s all that Sheen did. [/quote]
I only read the first 2 and last 2 paragraphs of your post. I was under the impression you were in agreement with cuban32’s assessment of Bautista. Am I wrong?
In regards to adding velocity to a pitcher would you say it’s much easier to add MPH at lower speeds than at Major League type velocity? Is increasing your fastball from 85 to 91 exponentially more difficult than getting it to go from 79 to 85? The reason I consider it possible Sheen isn’t lying is because his end result was still a mediocre velocity by MLB standards.
I don’t disagree that he could be bullshitting for publicity, either it’s working since we’re talking about him heh.[/quote]
I could care less about Bautista. He plays on an irrelevant team in an irrelevant city. It would not surprise me if he was using HGH since it can help you track the ball much better and HGH in moderation, without using testable banned substances, won’t result in a huge size gain. But an increase in production of his magnitude isn’t evidence of anything other than an increase in production. It’s pointless to engage in this discussion unless there is some actual, credible evidence linking him to steroid use.
As for Sheen, yes, 85mph is well below the average Major League fastball. But Sheen is not an MLBer, so why Sheen is being held to MLB standards on your part makes zero sense. 85mph is still pretty hard at the non-professional level, especially for someone who doesn’t play competitively. The point is that if Sheen can pick up a baseball out of nowhere and go from 79 to 85mph in 6-8 weeks after having not played competitively since high school (meaning he hasn’t been playing OR practicing) that means he must have much more room to put more velocity on his fastball.
I have a friend who played in the minors for the Reds for a few seasons. He was a pitcher and threw right around 90mph. He retired after his wife got pregnant and it was clear he wasn’t moving out of A-ball anytime soon. To my knowledge, he doesn’t play at all anymore. He’s only 29, so I’m sure if he got back into shape he could get to 85mph pretty quickly. But that is because it does not represent the limit of his arm strength. His limit is 90. And he certainly isn’t going to be able to go from wherever he’s at now to his full potential in 6-8 weeks. Am I making sense here?