[quote]Headhunter wrote:
ALDurr wrote:
Professor X wrote:
Headhunter wrote:
Yours.
[/quote]
I was talking about your mis-perception that anything that woman said had to do with race. You’re the pot calling the kettle black, except blacks actually have something to complain about and you don’t.
[quote]Headhunter wrote:
Criticizing black culture is not the same as racism. Black culture is a failed culture — 80% of children born to single mothers, 50% of black children never graduating from high school, the fervent desire to blame others for their troubles,
Rampant anti-intellectualism (such as beating classmates who actually try and learn), aggrandizing ghetto attitudes and popular ghetto culture.
[/quote]
I would agree that these are problems, but I’m unsure of those numbers. And criticizing black culture is also often a front for racist views that people don’t even know–or want to acknowledge–that they hold.
[quote]Headhunter wrote:
Not sad at all. And racism is NOT the same as denouncing a loser culture and those who freely adopt it.
[/quote]
Agreed. I’m not a moral relativist, some cultural practices, see slavery, female genital mutilation, honor killings, are abhorrent.
[quote]Headhunter wrote:
When kids in your culture beat a kid for studying, because that means he is ‘acting white’, that’s a loser culture symptom. When girls have baby after baby and it becomes the norm, that’s a loser culture symptom.
[/quote]
I’d agree that these are not good signs.
[quote]Headhunter wrote:
Sorry guys, face up to it. You embraced a culture that destroys black people. Bill Cosby told you its a loser culture and so do I.
[/quote]
YOU face up to it. White people created a culture that destroyed and dehumanized black people, and now you’re complaining about reaping what you sowed. Black anti-intellectualism is largely the fruit of WHITE efforts to keep blacks uneducated and powerless.
Of course any attempt to reverse systemic racism is whined about as “reverse racism”. While you also ignore the very real barriers that make life significantly harder as a black person in the US today.
[quote]Headhunter wrote:
I think I care more about black people than any of you.
[/quote]
LOL. WRONG.
[quote]Headhunter wrote:
Until and unless you adopt middle class values (education, responsibility, moral values), you ask for your own poverty and dissolution.
[/quote]
You say this as if there is no black middle class, or as if whites universally embraced these values, or as if embracing white culture would be a panacea for black problems–without addressing the obstacles in the way of that.
Cultural patterns are hard to break out of, and we are not responsible for the advantages and disadvantages our cultural milieu grants us by virtue of our birth.
And since I’m sure you strenuously oppose any efforts to target money or education or inculcation of “middle class values” specifically at black people (that’d be reverse racism dunn dunn dunn) I can’t see how we’re expected to take you seriously.
re: cultural racism
I think we can strike a balance between the paternalism and imperialism of the White Man’s Burden and the utter idiocy of absolute cultural relativism. There are some cultural values: like valuing industry, thrift, and education, which are universal positives.
Likewise there are cultural practices that are abhorrent, like gender selective abortion, apartheid, or the caste system. But the majority of cultural practices are neutral, like wedding ceremonies, death ceremonies, languages spoken, religions (debatable), birthday celebration, calendars, food, music, most of the things that make a culture a culture are morally neutral.
There’s no reason to obviate those cultural differences while we seek to destroy the real problems–that would be throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
Although our modern experience has shown us that cultural homogenization is almost inevitable in our increasingly global world, so I am somewhat skeptical of the ability of neutral cultural values to survive deliberate attempts at cultural change when even incidental contact with Western culture tends to result in massive changes to the native culture.
(See the experience of almost every 2nd and 3rd generation immigrant ever, they assimilate)