[quote]orion wrote:
John S. wrote:
orion wrote:
John S. wrote:
orion wrote:
Headhunter wrote:
orion wrote:
vroom wrote:
lixy wrote:
Why do you Yanks always have to bring up WWII?
It’s a free pass allowing the bearer to be an arrogant asshole due to the behavior of his or her ancestors…
Americans as a moral aristocracy because their grandfathers were forced at gunpoint to fight in a war?
Really?
"Demographic evidence discredits the argument that a draft is necessary to enforce representation from racial and socioeconomic groups. Addition?ally, three of the four branches of the armed forces met their recruiting goals in fiscal year 2005, and Army reenlistments are the highest in the past five years.
A draft is not necessary to increase the size of the active-duty forces. Our analysis using Pentagon data on wartime volunteers effectively shatters the case for reinstating the draft."
http://www.heritage.org/Research/NationalSecurity/cda06-09.cfm
During WWII, the lines at enlistment sites were huge. Entire graduating classes from our high schools would go and join the Marines.
Great.
Many may have enlisted on their own.
We will never know though, because of the gun and all.
To be proud that your grandparents where forced at gunpoint (as in, what they thought was irrelevant) to march on a battlefield and kill or be killed does make as much sense as being proud that your great-great-great-grandparents were forced at gunpoint to pick cotton.
Orion, are you that stupid? you do not see the difference? We where attacked, Many joined up on there own free will, some where drafted, But incase you don’t understand, WE WHERE FUCKING ATTACKED.
And that has to do what exactly with the prize of tea in China?
Alright, first Are you high? You seem to be making some stupid statements, and some that make no sense. Please put the bong down eat something and come back in 4-5 hours and try to say your point again.
Ahh, you do not understand therefore me be stoned…
Ok, a little bit slower…
I said they were coerced to fight, a form of slavery really, no need to be proud of ancestors “decision” and get all teary eyed because of WWII.
YOU posted, WE WERE ATTACKED GODDAMMIT; WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU?
I replied, that this is irrelevant because you practically conceded that yes, they were forced to fight and only added why you think the US government had the “right” to re-introduce slavery.
So, forced they were, forced decisions are not moral decisions because the element of free will is missing, therefore bragging rights you have not, because your grandfather went for the same reason mine did.
They would have shot him if he didn`t.
[/quote]
To save freedom sometimes you have to fight, yes a few were forced to fight, but a lot chose too. They where not forced to stay passed the wars end. If your country goes to war part of your duty for country is to fight. If you do not understand this you are high.