[quote]extol7extol wrote:
Hello Varqanir-[/quote]
Hello extol7extol.[quote]
People like you often say things like, “History is full of atrocities committed by Christians in the name of Christ.” But unless you can prove that these were really Christians in a way that I must accept, that is, according to the Biblical definition, you are just falsely assuming that anyone who claims to be a Christian is really a Christian.[/quote]
I have never assumed that, falsely or otherwise. I cannot speak for “people like me”, as I have never met one.
I am a bit puzzled that you would require proof that such and such historical figure was a “real Christian”. I confess that I am unable to do this, unfortunately, because God has not allowed me a peek into the Book of Life, in which the names of the Righteous are written.
I’m sure it is, indeed, easily said by you.
For the sake of argument, however, please refer me to the Biblical teaching which vehemently denies that Popes Urban II and Innocent III (who both launched great crusades), as well as Alexander VI (who gave the order for the Spanish to convert the heathen in the Americas), were “true Christians”. What of their cardinals and bishops, and indeed, the knights who hacked and slashed the infidels under papal command?
On which side of the 30 Year War were the true Christians? On which side of the skirmishes in Belfast?
Ignorant people like myself? Do you believe that insulting me adds weight to your argument?
[quote]These people whom you mention above I expect to act that way. I expect them to do those things.
You cite Augustine. Augustine was a damnable heretic. I will also add John Calvin (French theologian) and Martin Luther (German theologian). Both of these men gave nod to the putting to death of men whom they deemed heretics. Neither of these men were true Christians.[/quote]
You seem so sure of yourself. An admirable trait. But are you saying that you, personally, can divine with absolute certainty who is a true Christian and who is not? Does your definition of true Christianity supercede all others?
If so, then you are superior to the hundreds of millions of Christians who have, over the last two millennia, argued, tortured, fought and killed one another…and indeed, are still fighting and dying today…over that very question.
I would not presume to judge whether your particular brand of Christianity is “true” or not: only God may do that. However, I do seem to recall that the book of John tells us “whosoever believeth in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life”.
Although I have no way of proving this to your satisfaction, I venture to guess that the men whom I referenced above believed in Jesus quite fervently, and that many of them honestly believed that they were doing the Lord’s work in killing the infidels, much in the same way that many Americans believe that we are doing the Lord’s work by killing Muslim terrrorists today.
Is George W. Bush a true Christian? I imagine that he thinks he is. But that is for God…not him, nor me, nor even extol7extol…to judge.