[quote]pushharder wrote:
[quote]thunderbolt23 wrote:
What we need is something like a Dwight Eisenhower-Adlai Stevenson race in this country. Smart, experienced, trustworthy pols who have different ideas, plenty of disagreements on policy, but the public generally trusts the other one to govern effectively if their preferred candidate loses.
[/quote]
That’s what you got in McCain and Romney. They were smart, experienced, trustworthy and had plenty of ideas and disagreements.
You’re pining for more moderates just like the ones who’ve already been defeated.[/quote]
McCain didn’t lose because he was a moderate - he lost because of fatigue with the GOP, and had the GOP ran a true-believer right-winger, it could have been a clean sweep. Don’t forget what won 2008 was an appeal to “no red state, no blue state” thinking.
As for Romney, it’s hard to beat incumbents, but putting up a hard-right winger wouldn’t have made it any closer, or won the election. Romney’s weakness was his upper-crust nature and frankly tired economic ideas in a time of economic uncertainty. Hard-right wingers may not have the upper-crust sensibilities that turn off voters, but they have the baggage of appearing well outside the mainstream personally (witness any of the Tea Party darlings), amd their economic message would have been largely the same as Romney’s, if not more discordant.
The GOP brand has been broken for some time becausr of the Bush years (not just Bush himself, but the Congress during his time as well) - and it has lost the big tent status necessary to form coalitions to win national elections. Having a hard-right winger as the standard bearer shrinks the tent more, not less.
In any event, it isn’t simply about running a “moderate”. It’s also about run in someone competent and up to the task, and the clown show shows few who fit that bill. It juat so happens that the hard-rights are the worst of the bunch in terms of competence. Whether that is cause or correlation is a different topic, but it is what it is - mainstream America in the real world isn’t going to hire Cruz or Rand Paul to run anything.