I started to type a reply in X’s Amerika thread, but I realized it was getting very long and was going in a different direction to take on a life of its own. Thus, in order to avoid completely hijacking the thread, I started a new one.
[quote]Professor X wrote:
If that is the case, why do countries without such strict regulations and age requirements for alcohol survive without so much death surrounding the use? Youth rebel. We all did. If it weren’t so taboo to discuss issues without constantly talking about “the children”, and if policies reflected this, there would be less to rebel against. Wouldn’t that decrease the allure?[/quote]
I agree with the notion that American society would be better served by lowering the legal drinking age. I can’t say for sure whether their fatality numbers are any different, but I did have a chance this past summer to experience first-hand how youth in a country with a lower legal drinking age tend to behave themselves. In many of the pubs I went to, there were people much younger than me just having a few pints with their friends and taking it easy. In some of the pubs (ones that were family owned, I presume) there were even some very young people pulling my pints for me. I’m talking maybe 15 or 16 years old. And these “kids” acted more “adult” than many people I know in their late 20’s-early 30’s and beyond. Never once did I see anybody getting out of hand or “rowdy drunk”, as some might say.
At one pub, I struck up a conversation with a bartender who was around my age (late 20’s), born and raised in Ireland. Interestingly, he had lived in New York City for six months to help open and manage a bar there. I voiced to him my observations and opinions about the difference between drinking in America and Ireland and he put it to me about as well as I ever could have myself (paraphrased): “In America everyone’s drinking to get drunk; In Ireland, people drink to enjoy their drink and the company of others.” I know this is a blanket statement and there are many people here in America (even people on this site) who fit his description of Ireland better than that of America. I’d have to say on the whole, however, he about hit the nail on the head.
My dad (who I went on the trip with) and I had many discussions about both the drinking culture and the overall health of the people we encountered. Aside from the seemingly more responsible drinking, we also noticed that people in Ireland as a whole look much healthier than Americans when it comes to size and weight. I can count on one hand how many people I saw that were overweight or obese. “In shape” may be another story, but as far as weight goes they looked much better.
These are just some of my thoughts and ideas from my discussions with my dad, Oliver (the bartender), and my own observations:
(1) A lot of young American drinkers these days are all about doing shots. I don’t know that I can recall ever seeing one person doing a shot in Ireland (I’m not saying that they don’t do them, just that I think it’s rare).
(2) People in Ireland drink slooooow. In some instances I would see people nursing their pints for as long as 30-45 minutes.
(3) I think I only saw two or three McDonald’s restaurants the entire time I was in the country (we circled the entire southern half of the island), and beyond that maybe a Burger King. Fast food is rare there.
(4) Pubs are restaurants there. Restaurants are pubs. You don’t have your Applebee’s, O’Charley’s, Logan’s, etc. chain restaurants there. As such, most pubs stop serving food at 9 or 9:30pm and the music begins. I only encountered one pub that served food until later, and even then it was only until 10:30pm.
(5) I saw no late-night/after-hours clubs in Ireland that are open until 4, 5, even 6 in the morning like you see some places here. People go to the pub, have some pints, and go home. I think the latest I can recall any pub being open was 1am. Most were done by 11pm or 12am.
(6) I did not see a single 24-hour food establishment in Ireland.
I will say that the only “big city” I visited while there was Dublin, so my observations may be skewed. We tried to stick mostly to backroads and small towns (although all roads in Ireland seem like back roads compared to here; no offense meant to any of our Irish members, it made for some interesting driving experiences :-)). However, I think all of these factors listed above contributed to an overall sense that I got of a more responsible and healthier society in Ireland. I am only reiterating something that many of us have known for a long time, but when it comes to alcohol consumption and diet, America is a complete mess with the excessive consumption of food and alcohol at all hours of the day and night, partying all night long, and the general feeling of the need to just “Go, go, go!” all the time…
Disclaimer: Okay, I now realize this post has mostly become just a bunch of rambling. I’m hoping it might start some good discussion, though.