Witches Burned Alive

[quote]Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
StrongSurvive wrote:

Hey I’m not really the one projecting humanity on to God. All organized religion is bullshit. For some reason people refuse to believe morality could be hardwired into our DNA.

Oh but I forget, there HAS to be some defect. How else would the Church/Mosque/Synagogue/Temple keep control?

:)[/quote]

You do have a strange religion - a deity that will not punish evil, a morality built into your physical being, a penchant for controlling the lives of others . . . weird stuff . . .

What’s the name of your religion again - I want to avoid you guys like the swine flu!

[quote]Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
StrongSurvive wrote:
How could God watch His creation burn like that?

He wept.

Instead of doing something. Mmkay.

There is no true love or kindness without free will. We must have the choice of evil if the choice for good is to have any meaning. Etc.

God is a pussy who does little more than cry. Ok.

Thank God he doesn’t live up to your simplistic “Rambo-style” expectations.

Hey I’m not really the one projecting humanity on to God. All organized religion is bullshit. For some reason people refuse to believe morality could be hardwired into our DNA.

Oh but I forget, there HAS to be some defect. How else would the Church/Mosque/Synagogue/Temple keep control?

:)[/quote]

I agree with some of what you wrote. I think we need these istitutions. I have seen many abuses in the Catholic church for one example. I have seen Islamic fascism. Now I’m a Lutheran. I have not seen a lot of bad ion my church. no sex scandals, no beheadings etc.

But without these religions, we would have lost the good in them and what they did. Early on these beliefs helped shape our governments and helped to preserve knowledge. And they killed people and attempted to control their citizens to a much greater degree.

Us Lutherans were the first to break away from the Catholic church. I would like to say it succeeded because of the superiority of how Luther looked at things, but I would be lying if I didn’t mention that the German princes wouldn’t have to worry about hell and now didn’t have TO PAY TAXES TO ROME! Earliest tax dodge I know of.

To me big organized religions have good in them and you have to focus on that. but like any big organization in them, there will eb bad. It doesn’t mean the message is bad.

People these days recoil at you using religious beliefs that have trained your morality and telling them not to do this or that. Let’s say sex. Don’t have sex until you are married.

Don’t put your morality on me! I’m pregnant or have an STD, someone else help me!. This is one reason we the people pressure the government for various laws in regards to behavior right or wrong.

I practice in a small town in Pa. You would not believe in the amount of unwed grossly obese unmarried welfare cases I see strolling their kids around all day. We are paying for their lapse in judgment and morality. Pick one.

What I mean is if you use religious means to guide your decisions, good ole right and wrong, I think most would be better off. Or maybe a better way of putting it, is which one of the ten commandments is a bad idea. Because many religious people display hypocrisy, does not mean the teaching are bad.

In this country, lets say that all of a sudden no one cheated on a spouse, or had risky sex. Most would agree that this would better all of us. More stable homes, less people on welfare would free up tax dollars by the billions.

To me religion has taught me personal responsibility and kindness and respect for others. this does not mean I won’t grit my teeth at people taking advantage of the system or not speak out against abuses.

Let’s look at health care now. Years ago I read an article were a prominent researcher said we could reduce our health care costs by 50% if people chose healthier life styles. I would agree that is a plausible estimate. I do not know the figures, so I’ll put that one out there.

Do you ever hear a candidate in this country say that people need to shape up, change their lifestyles, knock off the booze and ciggies and seem some brocolli for once? Again no personal responsibility.

Believe it or not there are bible verses about how to eat, and versus condemning gluttony. Does it really matter if more people took their cues from the bible to get in shape?

I think more people in this country need more moral guidance that would overall benefit us. where ever they get it is okay to me, but it would seem that the teachings of Jesus would be a great place to start.

[quote]IrishSteel wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
StrongSurvive wrote:

Hey I’m not really the one projecting humanity on to God. All organized religion is bullshit. For some reason people refuse to believe morality could be hardwired into our DNA.

Oh but I forget, there HAS to be some defect. How else would the Church/Mosque/Synagogue/Temple keep control?

:slight_smile:

You do have a strange religion - a deity that will not punish evil, a morality built into your physical being, a penchant for controlling the lives of others . . . weird stuff . . .

What’s the name of your religion again - I want to avoid you guys like the swine flu![/quote]

The Religion of I Don’t Know.

I’m not so arrogant as to claim I know what will happen after we die. I also like to question things instead of accepting them at face value.

[quote]tom63 wrote:
Don’t put your morality on me! I’m pregnant or have an STD, someone else help me!. This is one reason we the people pressure the government for various laws in regards to behavior right or wrong.[/quote]

How about we don’t pay for them because they couldn’t keep their legs closed before they were ready to pop out a child? I mean really, a lot don’t care because they KNOW the government will pay for them. IMHO, the age of consent should be 20, and should have the law changed so that to be able to have a child you MUST have a steady job or a partner with one.

Do I care how draconian that sounds? No. Not really, it makes my wallet a little less lighter. And that can only help my bulk.

[quote]Makavali wrote:

The Religion of I Don’t Know.

I’m not so arrogant as to claim I know what will happen after we die. I also like to question things instead of accepting them at face value.[/quote]

Interesting - for a religion called “I Don’t Know”, you guys have a lot of beliefs. Shall I posit a few of them based on your posts in this thread alone?

There is no higher deity or moral authority to which man is accountable (I think you’ve made that belief quite certain)

Arrogance is bad (so if arrogance is bad, then humility is good)

Understanding (Inquiry) is good (therefore ignorance is bad)

murder and genocide are evil (therefor life must have an intrinsic value - life good, death bad)

Morality is a good thing (and not dependent on a religious creed - therefore immorality is a bad thing)

Men are responsible for their own actions and bear the responsibility for their bad deeds (can’t blame God or the Devil if there isn’t one)

Then the first belief and this next one blow any sense of right and wrong for you right out the window!

Our morality is hard-wired into our DNA - so if a man does bad things - he’s just wired that way.

You have made a lot of judgments on what is good or bad, but then you don’t leave any room to actually define something as good or bad. If our morality is hard-wired, then our actions are preset. When faced with the opportunity to kill, rape, torture - the person hard-wired to do those things simply will do them - and he will be right according to his own internal moral code - but wrong according to yours - so who would be right?

and since there is no supreme moral authority outside of that person (who are we to judge their wiring?), then there is never any justification for punishing anyone for something that only your hard-wired morality says is wrong.

No right or wrong, no good or bad, no evil or just - there is only is - so the final doctrinal statement of the Church of I Don’t Know could be summed as that you hold that man is his own moral authority and therefore there is no ultimate moral authority beyond the individual and therefore all things are permissible if a person’s private morality says it is . . . .

You can’t justify laws or punishments because there is no such thing as justification - because there is no higher moral authority to justify anything to . . .

That way lies sorrow and madness . . . .

[quote]IrishSteel wrote:
There is no higher deity or moral authority to which man is accountable (I think you’ve made that belief quite certain)[/quote]

Actually, I don’t know whether there is or there isn’t. I just find it hard to believe a power that great could make “mistakes” which seems to be a common factor in a lot religions.

Anything in too large a volume is bad.

Inquiry has led to a lot of breakthoughs in the modern world. Ignorance gave us the Dark Ages.

Actually, I’m very cold on this one. Murder is bad to me because it removes potentially beneficial genes from the gene pool, reducing my descendants chances of benefiting from said genes.

Loss of life potentially fucks us all over.

Morality isn’t as divine as people make it out to be, a lot has to do with ensuring a smooth transition into the next generation of humans, trying to avoid murder, rape etc.

Indeed.

[quote]Then the first belief and this next one blow any sense of right and wrong for you right out the window!

Our morality is hard-wired into our DNA - so if a man does bad things - he’s just wired that way.[/quote]

Um. LOL.

Morality is wired in, but a lot of people seem to have the ability to ignore it. There are a lot of urges we all successfully repress simply because they wouldn’t work in modern human society.

Bad = Detrimental to humanity

Again, we have the ability to repress said hard-wired coding.

I’d like to say I’d go with the majority, but the majority seems to be under the spell of religion. Take religion completely out of it. You see, just like religious people I can justify doing or not doing something.

[quote]No right or wrong, no good or bad, no evil or just - there is only is - so the final doctrinal statement of the Church of I Don’t Know could be summed as that you hold that man is his own moral authority and therefore there is no ultimate moral authority beyond the individual and therefore all things are permissible if a person’s private morality says it is . . . .

You can’t justify laws or punishments because there is no such thing as justification - because there is no higher moral authority to justify anything to . . .

That way lies sorrow and madness . . . .[/quote]

I CAN justify laws and punishments, just not all of them. I’m pretty sure the ones I can justify are the ones you think of, like stealing, murder, rape etc. Each of those can be rationalized as being bad because they are DETRIMENTAL to society, and therefore bad for humanity, ergo should not be allowed.

Of course, things aren’t black and white like religion likes to make it. I might make mistakes. But that’s part of being human.

I also note you bring up the Church. How many of the commandments are actually law today? Don’t steal, don’t kill, and don’t lie (even then only when it comes to those two).

I’m not sure how much of this is going to make sense, I’ve been up for nearly 48 hours, and quite possibly have been smoking a joint. But I’ll never tell.

[quote]Makavali wrote:

I CAN justify laws and punishments, just not all of them. I’m pretty sure the ones I can justify are the ones you think of, like stealing, murder, rape etc. Each of those can be rationalized as being bad because they are DETRIMENTAL to society, and therefore bad for humanity, ergo should not be allowed.

Of course, things aren’t black and white like religion likes to make it. I might make mistakes. But that’s part of being human.

I also note you bring up the Church. How many of the commandments are actually law today? Don’t steal, don’t kill, and don’t lie (even then only when it comes to those two).

I’m not sure how much of this is going to make sense, I’ve been up for nearly 48 hours, and quite possibly have been smoking a joint. But I’ll never tell.[/quote]

I’ll skip all of the preceding stuff - since I was trying my best to list out what appeared to be your basic beliefs - if I got those wrong - you’ve cleared those up. Great.

Now on to the red meat . . .

You CAN justify laws and punishments? - only as long as everyone else agrees with you . . . that should last about . . . 5 seconds.

Who cares if it bad for humanity? Who has the right to determine that that should be the scale for morality? What if my morality says the fewer humans the better?

Your morality is based on what you have determined to be detrimental to society? Who gets to decide what is detrimental to society - we may not be able to agree on what is or is not detrimental to society - Take NAMBLA for instance - Some would say they are,some would say they are not? Who gets to decide which is right?

What if I don’t believe in the concept of private property - who’s to say I am not right? Who gets to force their belief system onto me because they believe something different?

Don’t go blaming the Church on me . . . which Church would we be referring to here? I’m not Catholic or Protestant, Russian or Greek Orthodox, certainly not Lutheran or Episcopalian, pretty sure I got away from The Church of England - definitely not in the Kingdom Hall, skipped the Church of Christ and the Church of God on the way in, I’m too insane for the Pentecostals and too calm for the Snake Handlers . . .

Puff puff pass

[quote]IrishSteel wrote:
Don’t go blaming the Church on me . . . which Church would we be referring to here? I’m not Catholic or Protestant, Russian or Greek Orthodox, certainly not Lutheran or Episcopalian, pretty sure I got away from The Church of England - definitely not in the Kingdom Hall, skipped the Church of Christ and the Church of God on the way in, I’m too insane for the Pentecostals and too calm for the Snake Handlers . . .

Puff puff pass[/quote]

I’m starting to like you.

[quote]katzenjammer wrote:

This thread went off topic and turned into a religious battle fast.

LR

how very unusual, heh :wink:

[/quote]

Well, if America hadn’t invaded Iraq. . . .

(I figured someone had to do it.)

[quote]Makavali wrote:
tom63 wrote:
Don’t put your morality on me! I’m pregnant or have an STD, someone else help me!. This is one reason we the people pressure the government for various laws in regards to behavior right or wrong.

How about we don’t pay for them because they couldn’t keep their legs closed before they were ready to pop out a child? I mean really, a lot don’t care because they KNOW the government will pay for them. IMHO, the age of consent should be 20, and should have the law changed so that to be able to have a child you MUST have a steady job or a partner with one.

Do I care how draconian that sounds? No. Not really, it makes my wallet a little less lighter. And that can only help my bulk.[/quote]

Not to draconian to me actually. I like the ole societal pressure from the old days. that seemed to work well back in the day.

[quote]IrishSteel wrote:
My God is coming back to judge one day and that day of reckoning will be an awesome, fearful day!
[/quote]

Well, then I hope you’ve learned the Riddle of Steel.

[quote]Varqanir wrote:
IrishSteel wrote:
My God is coming back to judge one day and that day of reckoning will be an awesome, fearful day!

Well, then I hope you’ve learned the Riddle of Steel.[/quote]

Dude - I knew I liked you - A Conan reference!

wait a tic - are you being entertainingly funny or adolescent-ly pathetic?

Nah - you’re too good a guy to go for cheap shots. I’m going with funny - cuz that actually was pretty good - and I won;t even take offense at it!

[quote]IrishSteel wrote:

Dude - I knew I liked you - A Conan reference!

wait a tic - are you being entertainingly funny or adolescent-ly pathetic?

Nah - you’re too good a guy to go for cheap shots. I’m going with funny - cuz that actually was pretty good - and I won;t even take offense at it![/quote]

I just thought it worked on so many levels. Glad you appreciated it. :slight_smile:

[quote]Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
StrongSurvive wrote:
How could God watch His creation burn like that?

He wept.

Instead of doing something. Mmkay.[/quote]

He/she/it didn’t weep. Crying is a human thing, it happens when something unexpected and percieved bad happens. Since god already knew this was going to happen, he/she/it didn’t have a human emotional response to it. It happened because it was necessary for it to happen, that is all.

V

[quote]Vegita wrote:
Makavali wrote:
katzenjammer wrote:
StrongSurvive wrote:
How could God watch His creation burn like that?

He wept.

Instead of doing something. Mmkay.

He/she/it didn’t weep. Crying is a human thing, it happens when something unexpected and percieved bad happens. Since god already knew this was going to happen, he/she/it didn’t have a human emotional response to it. It happened because it was necessary for it to happen, that is all.

V[/quote]

Katz is likely referring to John 11:35, and extrapolating.

Fuck sake! The original poster should have posted a warning next to that link! I am sick to stomach after watching that video and I wish I had not watched it now!

Life is cheap in these countries as evidenced by that fucking video. I saw a documentary recently about children being accused of being witches by local priests in Nigeria, fucking religious bastards! Check out the link and the video link posted under the text.

http://www.channel4.com/programmes/dispatches/episode-guide/series-8/episode-1/

These people have their spiritual and religious roots based in pre-Christian beliefs namely witchcraft? combine this with the evangelistic zeal of the preachers and you have got one powerful, influential, messed up religion.

A buddy of mine has extended family in Nigeria with whom he visited for the first and only time years ago and he witnessed two burnt charred bodies on the side of the road being eaten by vultures and his chaparones didn’t even bat an eyelid! He asked WTF and they explained that they were local criminals and not to worry! He couldn’t get over how cheap life was there.

Most of us can count ourselves lucky we live in a society that is appalled by such violence. Although if you rewind the clock a few hundred years you would find the same thing happening!

[quote]worzel wrote:
Fuck sake! The original poster should have posted a warning next to that link! I am sick to stomach after watching that video and I wish I had not watched it now!

Life is cheap in these countries as evidenced by that fucking video. I saw a documentary recently about children being accused of being witches by local priests in Nigeria, fucking religious bastards! Check out the link and the video link posted under the text.

http://www.channel4.com/programmes/dispatches/episode-guide/series-8/episode-1/

These people have their spiritual and religious roots based in pre-Christian beliefs namely witchcraft? combine this with the evangelistic zeal of the preachers and you have got one powerful, influential, messed up religion.

A buddy of mine has extended family in Nigeria with whom he visited for the first and only time years ago and he witnessed two burnt charred bodies on the side of the road being eaten by vultures and his chaparones didn’t even bat an eyelid! He asked WTF and they explained that they were local criminals and not to worry! He couldn’t get over how cheap life was there.

Most of us can count ourselves lucky we live in a society that is appalled by such violence. Although if you rewind the clock a few hundred years you would find the same thing happening!
[/quote]

First of all thank you for a great post and some good insight . . . now the crazy part . . .

I went and rewound my clock (ok just reset it on the computer)back to 1675 and this priest appeared out of nowhere, grabbed my computer threw it to the ground, screaming “heretic” the whole time . . . I finally calmed him down with some bourbon and rum and a baseball bat . . . yes, the liquor was for me, duh!

You’re absolutely right - there are idiots in every generation.

[quote]Varqanir wrote:
IrishSteel wrote:
My God is coming back to judge one day and that day of reckoning will be an awesome, fearful day!

Well, then I hope you’ve learned the Riddle of Steel.[/quote]

Conan: He is strong! If I die, I have to go before him, and he will ask me, “What is the riddle of steel?” If I don’t know it, he will cast me out of Valhalla and laugh at me. That’s Crom, strong on his mountain!

Subotai: Ah, my god is greater.

Conan: [chuckles] Crom laughs at your four winds. He laughs from his mountain.

Subotai: My god is stronger. He is the everlasting sky! Your god lives underneath him.

of course he’s talking about Tengri.

Cheers IrishSteel!

I constantly read arguments here on T-Nation about how this religion is shit and that religion is even shittier but it is ‘people’ who distort religious ideals for their own ends and this is the core root of all this fucked up shit! Common sense and a respect for your fellow human being gets swept aside when you have laser-focused individuals perpetuating fucked up versions of what THEY see as the truth!

It can only take one strong willed person to influence people en mass and that is the problem. Having one view of the world and how it should be is a dangerous thing and an ignorant one at that!

Check these idiots out!

[quote]worzel wrote:
Cheers IrishSteel!

I constantly read arguments here on T-Nation about how this religion is shit and that religion is even shittier but it is ‘people’ who distort religious ideals for their own ends and this is the core root of all this fucked up shit! Common sense and a respect for your fellow human being gets swept aside when you have laser-focused individuals perpetuating fucked up versions of what THEY see as the truth!

It can only take one strong willed person to influence people en mass and that is the problem. Having one view of the world and how it should be is a dangerous thing and an ignorant one at that!

Check these idiots out!

[/quote]

Aye! good stuff - but I would clarify one point that you make -

I don’t believe it’s even the having one view of the world . . .take for instance Mother Teresa or Father Damien - one view and an amazing life of sacrifice . . . I think it simply comes down to a$$holes cloaking themselves in the robes of whatever religion or non-religion is easy for them to adapt to and then allowing the sickness already in them to fester and boil out onto humanity - we see the robes, little realizing it’s the sob in the robes that is the source of the vile putrefying ugliness . . . but I think that was your point, eh?