[quote]nephorm wrote:
vroom wrote:
Funny how often people wash their hands of things around here by claiming people deserve what they get.
Let’s chart the argument.
Point 1) There is no AIDS crisis.
Point 2) AIDS is preventable, and the individual has the greatest amount of control over whether or not he or she contracts it.
Point 3) Therefore, pumping money into AIDS research to the detriment of other, non-preventable diseases is backwards thinking.
Counter-point 1) Tell that to the Africans!
Counter-counter point 1) It’s just as preventable in Africa as it is in any other part of the world… and pumping money into a vaccine doesn’t solve the root of the problem, which is rampant unprotected sex.
Counter-point 2) Hey, talking about condoms isn’t kosher there!
Counter-counter point 2) Then that’s why they’re dying, isn’t it?
I never said “they deserve what they get.” In a perfect world, where we had infinite time, resources, and brainpower to study every disease and cure it, this would be a non-issue. But in the real world, where we have to make decisions about how to direct our efforts and allocate scarce resources, well, you have to do a little triage.
How would you feel if this were obesity, by the way? If there were an obesity “epidemic” sweeping through, say, the US… and there was also a large, third-world collection of countries just filled with people keeling over dead after eating too much krispy kreme? Maybe the government even put out information about “good eating habits,” but the natives got very angry about the whole thing, saying that eating healthy food was like putting a condom over their tongue. Or some such analogy. Would you want to take money away from breast cancer research to get these people gastric bypasses, or to invent a weight-loss pill? [/quote]
Neph,
Do you keep up with current events or anything? The Bush administration has told any country desiring American money to fight their AIDS non-crisis that they cannot distribute condoms as part of their programs.
I see that you have a truly profound understanding of the problems faced in Africa regarding reproductive rights and education and the status of women there as well. I’m sure you also think they have plenty of food and money to go around, too.
WMD