[quote]Professor X wrote:
Dragonvash wrote:
I saw the movie last night and wasn’t a fan of it. The negatives: I didn’t like the how the Transformers looked, the action was too cluttered and I had a hard time figuring out who was punching who, the comedy was extremely cheesy and over the top (Bumblebee taking a piss on the agent), Optimus looked weak, the finish was very anti-climatic, and too many humans.
LOL. As campy as the original concept for this was, I am at a loss when people claim any of the comedy in this movie was “cheesy” (have any of you actually watched that cartoon lately instead of just going off of nostalgia?). It makes me wonder what you expected and how you would have done differently.
I am of the solid opinion that even if Bay had rolled them out looking JUST like the fucking cartoons, someone would have a complaint about how they looked.
As far as the humans involved, this movie would have sucked ass if they had approached it as if the entire human race barely noticed them. Even in the cartoon they fought the military on a regular basis. We were just too young to understand what that meant.[/quote]
I remember the original cartoon very well. Giant robots changing into vehicles is a huge joke in and of itself.
Yet in the film, it was bad joke after bad joke and the way that they portrayed the Autobots made them look like clutzy, idiotic kids. Also it’s extremely funny that robots bigger than a house can hide in the yard from the parents. I’m talking about the scene when the kid was at his house looking for the glasses.
The original cartoon had it’s share of bad jokes but it wasn’t one after another. It seemed like this movie was trying to be more of an action/comedy. I thought the way they did the humor in X-Men was fine. They would place a joke here and there. They weren’t trying to center the movie around the humor and that’s what I thought they did with Transformers.
I would have made the film with the same kind of pacing and theme as X-Men. You didn’t have to wait forever to see the mutants, they had a great blend of action, comedy, drama and you could clearly see and understand the action going on in each scene.
I’ll agree that someone would bitch no matter what the Transformers looked like. I have my own preference for their appearance. I enjoy how they are drawn in the comics nowadays. So essentially it is a lose/lose situation but I’m still entitled to my opinion.
I’m not saying that the humans needed to be completely oblivious to the Transformers or that the military didn’t need to be involved. The secondary plots were unnecessary. The love story, the soldier trying to get home to his family, the kid’s relationship with his parents, etc.
I believe that you needed 1 or 2 humans to have a strong interaction with the Transformers but other than that, the humans could have been collateral damage as far as I’m concerned. I felt that was a strong reason why Alien Vs Predator was bad. I didn’t care about the human’s personal problems.
I just wanted to see some carnage. I would watch a different movie if I wanted a love story or human drama.
This movie should have been centered around the Transformers, not the humans.