[quote]strangemeadow wrote:
[quote]louiek wrote:
[quote]strangemeadow wrote:
[quote]louiek wrote:
[quote]strangemeadow wrote:
[quote]louiek wrote:
[quote]strangemeadow wrote:
[quote]pat wrote:
[quote]Swolegasm wrote:
Heavy metal, punk, skunk, death metal, thrash etc any of that ‘‘music’’ [/quote]
Contrarily, I hate hip-hop…I tried to like it, but I am a musician, not a great one by any stretch, but I get what it takes and I hate music made by computers. I don’t hate the use of computers per se, but I hate the fuck out of music devoid of actual musicians. There’s no soul, no spirit, no expression except for the MC. If he’s not spectacular, it’s just shit, to me. I know it’s very popular and all that, but I like my music with musicians in it.
Like when ICE-T did his Body Count experiment. I loved that, real musicians doing real shit. Hey, that actually gives me an idea for a new thread…[/quote]
Hip-Hop and rap isn’t music. Music is played by and made by people. Hip-hop and rap are what I call “audible social commentary/pop art”
I will agree it’s an expression and it’s “sound”, even sound containing chords and melody, but samples, midi files and arpeggiators aren’t music.
[/quote]
Rappers are poets who perform vocally to music and therefore are musicians and song writers. Producers are musicians because they make original music. Whether you enjoy it or think their content and attitude is appropriate and worthy of being entitled art is your own opinion. All genres have a predominate type of person that latches on to the style, and hip-hop is no different than any other genre.
Yes, Waka Flacka Flame, Lil Wayne, Nicki Minaj, just money making pop shit for 14-year-olds.
Yes, Pharaoe Monch, Shadd, Brother Ali, The Beatnuts, Wax & EOM, Wu-Tang Clan, the original Mobb Deep, Aesop Rock, Atmosphere, Playdough, R.A. The Rugged Man, Apathy, are all musicians.
ALSO: Getting into discussion of what “music” and “art” really are never results in anything because it’s all relative. Just say you don’t like hip-hop and you don’t understand it instead of saying it’s not music.[/quote]
Well, yeah, I think you’re wrong. A poet is a poet, not a musician. A hip-hop “producer” who just uses loops and midi files and edits them isn’t a musician.
I do agree that an argument about music/art is a relativity thing, but, no, I stand by my post. I think anyone who can actually play an instrument would agree.
It’s like me going to Home Depot and buying a book case and assembling it and saying I’m a cabinet maker. I’m not.[/quote]
Says everything about your misunderstanding of rap and instrumental production and nothing about about what you’re criticizing. Which is pretty much just like everyone else who says negative things of that nature about hip-hop; ignorance.[/quote]
Please enlighten me about rap. I think I’ve got a pretty good understanding of music, as I’m actually a musician who can play, and who understands theory. I also produce bands and singer-songwriters in my studio. I do know how these songs are constructed, ProTools, AutoTune, loops and midi files and harmonizers. Honestly, anyone with half a brain and 40K can make a pro level rap song.
I know, I know, really coming off ass and ass, but some of us musicians are taking a stand as to what really qualifies. Maybe it makes me a purist musical jerk off, but I’m ok with it, I can make music.
But please let me know what I’m missing about rap, I know I don’t sound open, but I’ll listen.
[/quote]
Unfortunately for your argument, we’re not discussing pro level rap songs. We’re discussing true hip-hop.
You claim you can form instrumentals with the same skill level as DJ Premier, 9th Wonder, The Alchemist, Da Beatminerz, Hi-Tek, Kanye West, Pete Rock, Marley Marl, RZA, Lord Finesse, or even low-level professionals such as Boonie Mayfield and lesser known professional, Stoupe Enemy of Mankind to name my favorite. That makes you a cunt. You can define a musician anyway you’d like, but in the real world, a musician makes music, and to claim any of their art is not music is very dumb.
Rappers aren’t musicians either? Because, they’re just poets. Poets who interact with music, engaging in flow, pattern, and delivery to compliment an instrumental with their rhyme schemes and pacing. In writing, they utilize emotional connection and personal experience to create a thought pattern, and they use their skills to make it sound listenable while over music. And of course, it has to actually be GOOD for others to enjoy it. At least, good enough that their fans or fans of the genre in general will connect with it on some level. Kinda sounds like a fucking musician to me.
Given your previous opinion, you will not change your mind, because you have an idea of rap and hold a claim to “real music,” which takes away from artists who utilize computers in their music making process. Plenty of people think the way you do, and I can see why people think that way. I have nothing against that way of thinking, as it’s ignorance.
I find the biggest problem with hip-hop to be that it evolved into rap-pop VERY quickly. So quickly, that most people who didn’t grow up with hip-hop now think it’s not music, not an art form, not real, not good, full of ghetto trash, full of liars, full of people who don’t know good music, when in reality, Common did a song called I Used To Love Her, which is how a LOT of real hip-hop heads feel about the current state of rap in popular culture.[/quote]
The statement makes me a cunt? That tells me I’ve either challenged your (musical) values, or you feel hurt or threatened. Sorry Dude, that wasn’t my intention. I just thought being a musician meant you actually had to be able to play a musical instrument or be a composer. By compose I mean like orchestras. I think Webster’s would qualify that.
But what ever, carry on…
[/quote]
You haven’t threatened or hurt anything. You’re just wrong, and that statement negating the work of artists makes you a cunt, implying similarly that graphic designers are not artists because they use Photoshop. Unfortunately so. I love all music, hip-hop included, and recognize skill inside each field.
mu·si·cian
Noun:
A person who is talented or skilled in music.
mu·sic
Noun:
The art or science of combining vocal or instrumental sounds (or both) to produce beauty of form, harmony, and expression of emotion.
The vocal or instrumental sound produced in this way.
You job sounds fun btw, I used to want to do that kind of thing.