[quote]SexMachine wrote:
[quote]angry chicken wrote:
[quote]pat wrote:
[quote]angry chicken wrote:
[quote]NorCal916 wrote:
If you don’t understand the context, it can be conflicting. Trouble is, it takes a great deal of study to learn the true history and context. [/quote]
What context is there to understand?
Right now, we are all calling the Muslim extremists barbarians for what they are doing in Iraq (killing people, crucifying people, convert or die, etc…). But according to the Bible, God tells his people to put the men to the sword. Kill all the women who have lied down with a man. Save the virgin girls for yourselves. And to kill babies…On multiple occasions.
What am I not understanding here?
Those are the requests of a fucking psychopath…[/quote]
There is A LOT of context to understand in the OT. The historical context in which it was written would be very easy to understand for the original audience since they lived in those times. And your writing for a primarily uneducated nomadic (in the beginning) minority in the ancient world. Qualification of everything is something they would not understand.
The Pentateuch, from which you quoted primarily are legal and historical books. Primarily legal, and not a complete history. It was a history of the ancient Hebrews and it tells there story. Like any discipline, religion for the Judeo-Christian traditions studies it’s own history. You need to know where you came from to understand where you are at.
Some of the accounts are brutal, but they fit the world they lived in at the time which was brutal.
The customs of the time were barbaric, women were chattel and people sold their own family into slavery. This was not unique to the Hebrews.
And again, you are dealing with uncivilized, uneducated, brutal and barbaric people.
Explaining to them the intricacies or moral theory and explaining why you should do this instead of that was unconvincing.
You’re dealing with people who had to be told not to have sex with their livestock and that eating buzzards and vultures is not a good idea. They were also very superstitious would worship and sacrifice to pretty much anything.
So how do you get those people to listen and right their ways and get everybody on the same page? You speak to them in a way they understand.
This is what you do, this is who you offer you sacrifices to, this is how you treat each other, these are your commandments and if you don’t it’s your ass.
But it wasn’t all negative reinforcement. If you keep the commandments and obey you will be blessed. Your harvests will be plenty, your livestock will flourish, you will have plenty of land and lots of children. If you disobey and think you know better then your ass is grass.
Simple terms for simple people.
If we lived in the 18th - 14th centuries BC this would not appear strange at all to us. It would be quite normal and more than that it would seem to us somewhat advanced comparatively.
What seems to us gross and barbaric was normal to them. That’s the world they lived in.
It would actually be frightening if in 21st century western civilization if this type of stuff didn’t seem barbaric to us.
We have advanced, as we should have, since those times and in many ways we have the ancient Hebrews to thank for the advancements we have made, particularly in our understanding of morality.
If the ancient Hebrews did not succeed and thrive and become a great Israelite nation with great influence in the old world, who knows what kind of world we would live in today.
We have no way of knowing, perhaps we’d still be screwing our live stock had it not been for the advancement of the Hebrews in to the great Kingdom of Israel.[/quote]
I agree ONE HUNDRED PERCENT with everything you just wrote. I fully believe that the Bible was a WONDERFUL tool for population control. I think the people that wrote it (and later translated it and changed/refined it) were doing so with the goals of managing a civilization and moving in a positive direction. That’s all well and good back when, as you put it, people were trying to have sex with their barn animals. But we don’t live in those times anymore…
The whole idea that people think the Bible is… “TRUE” is what disturbs me. How any rational adult can believe that bullshit is FASCINATING to me. I’m not saying I don’t think it was useful or that it isn’t artfully written or anything like that. And there is a certain comfort in ritual that can be beneficial to achieving certain states of mind and productivity or tranquility.
But we have otherwise BRILLIANT people who actually believe in the equivalent of Santa Clause and the Easter Bunny… People who want to TEACH IN SCHOOLS that the earth is only 5000 years old (or whatever the number is) because “that’s what the Bible says”… That’s retarded…
Then they come with, “well God loves you, he loves everybody - just don’t be gay or eat shrimp (but he’s kinda forgotten about the shrimp part, but you’d BETTER not be gay)”.
It boggles my little brain how any rational person can A) believe that bullshit and/or B) WANT to be associated with an historically infant killing, rape condoning psychopath who will TO THIS DAY, send an innocent baby to hell because you don’t put a drop of water on his forehead (but says he loves you unconditionally - just don’t love any other Gods before him - NOT that any other Gods exist, mind you, there is only ONE TRUE GOD, but don’t worship any others, mmmmkay?).
[/quote]
-
This doesn’t concern you
-
Please see your NT and your spiritual adviser for why this does not concern you
-
This may concern you. Please see your spiritual adviser and the Midrash for why and how this May concern you.
Are you a Christian?
No: Go straight to 1. Do not pass go. Do not collect $200.
Yes: go straight to 2. Do not pass go. Do not collect $200.
Are you a Jew?
No: Go straight to “are you a Christian?” Do not pass go. Do not collect $200.
Yes: go straight to 3. Do not pass go. Do not collect $200.
[/quote]
Well, it kinda DOES concern me. You see, the otherwise rational adults that believe in these fairy tales are trying to use their RELIGIOUS BELIEFS as a basis for passing LEGISLATION that ALL people in this country have to abide by.
Anti sodomy laws for example. Did you know that in Virginia it’s against the law to have sex with anyone other than your wife in ANY OTHER POSITION besides missionary? THAT concerns me… When religious zealots inflict THEIR RELIGION onto other people by passing laws that marginalize people that don’t subscribe to that belief.
So until you get your bullshit religion out of MY STATE POLITICS AND LAWS, I’ll continue to attack YOUR religion. BECAUSE IT DOES CONCERN ME.