[quote]red04 wrote:
Vicomte wrote:
Ronsauce wrote:
I’m also not saying that it comes down to just parenting, but I believe it is 100% incorrect to assume that parenting or the lack thereof has no effect on how everyone turns out.
I don’t believe it’s the parenting itself, but rather the child’s interpretation of the parenting. So, really, the parenting is irrelevant as it can be interpreted the same way despite it being different. It’s the child’s choice.
If your Dad says, ‘You’re amazing kid!’ you can think, ‘Yes, I am amazing!’.
If he says, ‘You suck, kid!’ you can think, ‘Fuck you Dad, I’m amazing!’.
Different paths, same destination.
That’s so oversimplified that it becomes meaningless though. The kid would need to know what amazing is first to be able to fall back on his own encouragement, if all he is greeted with from his family, “friends,” terrible support system from a poor city(unmotivated, underpaid, overworked teachers and such) is negatives it would be irrational to NOT believe them.
Then at that point, if the kid does have the chemical imbalances that lead to depression he will give up on exploring his own strengths and just assume everyone is right about his failures. The kid would never have a chance to figure it out like you say.
I guess this is where you reply that your philosophy is that kids like this don’t deserve a chance to live beyond their teenage years where the pressure to make themselves good enough for the impending independence causes more suicides than any other age group. They’re just flawed, better not to have them anyways?
[/quote]
The worse a situation is, the more people in it will believe there is something better out there, even if they think it isn’t meant for them at first. Kids like you describe almost all have the dream of ‘getting out of this place’ or ‘making something of themselves’ (at least the ones I’ve known), the only thing is that they never do.
It’s not like they don’t know there are better things. You think slaves don’t realize there’s something better to be had?
I don’t care how shitty your situation is, there’s always the idea of hope. If you give up on that, then, yes, you deserve what you get.