[quote]ready wrote:
[quote]TheBodyGuard wrote:
[quote]AndrewG909 wrote:
[quote]TheBodyGuard wrote:
- Incorrect. You can buy commercially produced feed ranging from 10% protein all the way up to 40% - which is too high by the way. Rabbits, et als, the so called “natural” food of the dog fall somewhere around 18%. And by the way, I’m riffing here, not looking up source material for exactness. The take home message - you can buy a commercially available feed with the protein/fat content you desire;
[/quote]
Like I mentioned earlier, I feed my dog Blue Wilderness (chicken) and it has 42% protein. Can you explain why that’s too high and what percentage is more acceptable. Blue Wilderness also makes a duck formula and I believe that has 34% protein. I would hate to switch her food since I just recently changed it and also because she seems to like it better than any food I’ve given her before.
Also is one form of meat better than another - chicken better than duck? or does it not really matter.
And I usually give my dog raw eggs, pieces of banana, broccoli, and walnuts. are any of these things bad for dogs?
[/quote]
First, dogs are actually classified as omnivores, unlike your common house cat who is absolutely a carnivore. Next, there is disagreement among experts as to what is “too high”, but we know dogs can assimilate high levels of protein. However, as I’ve said earlier, most prey animals in the wild are at around 20% protein and that protein comes with moisture (blood, fat) to aid digestion and the kidneys. And if your dog is pretty much sedentary like most pets, what do you need all that protein for? Compare that content to what mushers feed their dogs and you’re still high and I cannot think of a more demanding vocation for a dog than mushing. The mushers are around 30 protein / 40 fat. So ask yourself, why in the world would a sedentary pet need a 40% protein feed? I’ve also seen the higher protein feeds out there now make it difficult to keep weight on a dog.
Actually, I just looked at the Blue Wilderness and for the chicken formual, you’re 34% protein and 15% fat. That’s not terribly high by any means but you do know that if your dog is not a very active dog, you’re wasting that protein. Just for perspective, look at the following table:
Species Protein % Fat %
Antelope 22.5 .9
Beef USDA choice 22.0 6.5
Beef USDA standard 22.7 2.0
Buffalo 21.7 1.9
Chicken 23.6 .7
Deer (Mule) 23.7 1.3
Deer (Whitetail) 23.6 1.4
Duck (Domestic) 19.9 4.25
Duck (Mallard) 23.1 2.0
Elk 22.8 .9 67 137
Pig (Domestic Pork) 22.3 4.9
Pig (Wild Boar) ** 28.3 4.38
Rabbit (Cottontail) 21.8 2.4
Rabbit (Jack) 21.9 2.4
Squirrel 21.4 3.2
Turkey (Domestic) 23.5 1.5
Turkey (Wild) 25.7 1.1
Even for a growing puppy, bitch’s milk is only 7.53% protein and 9.47% fat. Anyay, if your dog is thriving on the feed, then you have no problems. You just might be paying more than necessary to feed a sedentary dog pet. For the canine athlete, I like ratios closer to what the mushers are doing.