Well, I could suggest a corrective path and I’m sure others could, but I meant I have never seen a corrective path suggested by persons actually in government or receiving any real airing as serious ideas.
My proposal would be this:
The President of the United States would announce, "You have been told, Americans have been told for generations, that your Social Security payments were going into a trust fund to pay for your retirement. This was not true. I’m ashamed that your government has to tell this to you, but you were lied to. The government treated your Social Security payments as tax revenue and spent it, and gambled that when your time came, future generations could be taxed to pay your benefits.
"All the while, actuarial experts told them that it was not so, that the system would collapse.
"The same is true of your Medicare payments.
"And furthermore, it’s not only the government that has, frankly, conned the American people. Very many corporations and many unions established deals where for your work today and in your working years, they’d pay generously in your retirement years. But for a large part they didn’t invest their earnings made during your working years to be able to pay you in your old age: they gambled that future profits could cover these enormous obligations.
"I have to tell you today that estimates are that the Federal Government’s unfunded liabilities – monies owed in the future which we do not now have invested – total 99 trillion dollars. I know this amount is practically inconceivable. But for comparison, although our taxes are high and raising rates even higher might not collect anything more because of resulting damage to the economy, our tax revenues are ‘only’ $2 trillion per year.
"In other words, it would take 50 years of tax revenue, with every penny going towards these unfunded liabilities and none towards ongoing services and needs, to meet the obligations that the government has promised to pay.
"Or in still other words: It is not that I do not want for the government to pay its obligations. And it is not that I do not think the government should pay its obligations. It is that the government CANNOT pay its obligations.
"It simply is utterly impossible for it to be done and the time has come to recognize this fact.
"What we need to do, now, is essentially a bankrupty reorganization. We need to determine who can be paid, and how much, in the most equitable manner possible, although fundamentally it is extremely inequitable that the American people have been promised these future benefits from their taxes but for the greatest part cannot receive them.
"As an initial proposal and an example of what might be decided to solve this problem, we can establish an age where, as many working years are left, it will be an individual’s own responsibility to provide for his retirement, and unfortunately, all his tax payments were simply that, taxes that were spent and are gone. This might for example be age 45. And then we could establish a sliding scale where individuals older than this limit receive a percentage of what was expected according to how many working years they have left, with those presently near retirement receiving as close to what was expected as possible and those further away, having more time to earn and save in the meantime, a smaller percentage.
"This alone will not be sufficient: we will also have to extend the retirement age.
"We will also need solutions for the bankruptcy of Medicare, and in the private sector, solutions will be needed for unfunded pension plans.
“Americans were led to believe that they were receiving for their work not only the benefits immediately received, but great benefits for the future that were being held in a trust fund for them by the government. I am here to tell you tonight that the ‘trust fund’ quite literally consists of a drawer full of IOU’s and a hope of being able to get the money from taxing future generations, but the amount of debt is now far more than can ever be raised. We have to swallow the bitter truth that the money is spent; it is gone; and what we will have in the future is what we earn in the future or can now save, for ourselves as individuals responsible for ourselves, for the future.”