[quote]Radcon wrote:
Lonnie123 wrote:
ALL manners are created by people, so in that sense they are all “fake”. There is nothing intrinsically “good” about helping an old lady cross the street or picking up someones pencil when they drop it… Its the same thing as sneezing and “Bless you.”
The handshake thing is the same exact thing. It used to be a way a showing that you werent carrying a weapon, and its simply been carried over to our society as a sign of respect. If you dont like it, dont do it… simple as that.
I appreciate your honest and polite thoughts. You do bring up a pretty good point. This is the difference I see though. Shaking someones hand to show that you weren’t carrying a weapon has a solid reason to it. Shaking someones hand now is a formal greeting, similar to saying hi. It shows acknowledgment, respect, or whatever.
Saying bless you back in the day served a purpose to those who believed it had spiritual implications. It hasn’t carried over into having any real purpose like other manners have.
My hang ups are these. It doesn’t seem like the most courteous and polite people say it the most. Relatively unpolite people say it possibly just as much if not more than polite people. That makes it seem pretentious to me and turns it into a negative. If something is going to be said after a sneeze, could it please make sense.
You know how when people over use words or phrases and they lose their meaning and become cliche. That’s basically what I’m saying has happened to bless you as far as being polite.
I think it has become cliche.
[/quote]
Saying “Bless You” after a sneeze used to make sense to a majority of the population because they honestly believed your soul left your body at the time. Handshaking used to make sense because people use to conceal weapons more often presumably.
Both have lost their original meaning and have now transformed into mere formalities of human interaction. I can almost gaurantee that you havent tipped anyone off as to the fact you were packing heat by shaking their hand, its a totally different meaning now adays. Bless You has done the same thing.
But the bottom line is, if you dont like it dont say it. I’d say 90% of a room will not say it after someone sneezes anyway, you wont be the odd one out.