[quote]Headhunter wrote:
stokedporcupine wrote:
two points about the Chinese being good at math that most people don’t consider
first, the Chinese, like the germans, have a system based on performance. In other words, if you don’t perform, your out. Also, most of the Chinese exchange students that get sent here are the “best of the best”, its not like in America where almost anyone can participate in organized exchange programs. So, one contributing factor to the apparently “high” percentage of Chinese who are very good at math has more to do with selective processes then innate ability. ie, china isn’t land of the free and home of equal opportunity. not all of their students are as “special” as ours are. (ok, i’m done being cute, lol)
next, about the abacus, i know nothing. but what you say sounds more like the Chinese get more practice at mechanically computing arithmetic answers then your average American student (who goes for the calculator to solve 7x3). If you forced the average American student to practice their addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division algorithms twice a much as they do now, then the average American’s mathematical ability would improve drastically.
there are different ways to count and to conceptualize number systems, some of which are better then others for different purposes. ah, but this is a whole different topic.
i’m just always skeptical of this “Chinese good at math” thing. it always sounds to me like these people just practice more on average then your average American, who doesn’t realize that before one can “conceptually grasp” numbers, they need to actually memorize some multiplication tables.
After teaching math for 28 years, I would like to add that Asians are better at mathematical COMPUTATION but less so at creative mathematics. Great mimicry, poor creativity.
Part of this is cultural — to be innovative was often a threat to subsistence cultures. That new crop technique might create a bountiful harvest, or it might kill everything and you’d starve…better to stick with the tried and true.
China will eventually rule the world, btw. When you have 1.3 billion people, you produce more engineers, scientists, businessmen, and so forth. That’s okay…the Chi-Comms are pricks, let them have the thankless task of policing the globe.
[/quote]
As long as they have an oppressive regime in charge they will not rule the world. As soon as the oppressive regime disappears they will lose direction and fracture.
They will not rule the world but they may run Asia for a while.