[quote]hspder wrote:
JPBear wrote:
If we are nothing but random physical beings, which ended up here by accident, how can you claim that goodness and kindness towards others is better than self centered pursuits? Maybe you get more joy from having friends than you do from feeding the desires of your flesh, but not everyone does. If there is no external moral standard, then things wouldn’t be morally good or bad, they would just be different.
May I butt-in for a moment again?
(same disclaimer as before applies here: don’t take this as an insult to your intelligence ? it’s just that as a science professor I can’t help but blurt out science every chance I get)[/quote]
How many times and in how many ways do you need to get in that you feel smarter than us? We know you have a Ph.D. That is a GREAT accomplishment and you should be proud. But God is not a respecter of persons, so all of your learning is meaningless if you use it to spend an eternity in Hell.[quote]
There is plenty of scientific evidence to support the theory that moral standards are a product of Evolution. One of the most obvious pieces of evidence is that a lot of other animals – including all primates – have similar standards; in fact, Humans and other animals share a whole heritage of tendencies, including cooperation and repayment of favors (which drive goodness and kindness towards others, even if at a subconscious level).[/quote]
Well as a scientist, you should also ask yourself if there is another, more plausable explanation for this.
It would stand to reason that a common Creator instilled these things in His creation. Similarities in form and function only serve to show forth a common Creator.[quote]
Another piece of evidence is that moral standards are remarkably similar between different major faiths, including the ones that only had contact with each other in the past couple of centuries ? but differ on specific aspects that were “amazingly” convenient for the survival of the species in THAT specific environment.[/quote]
Please give specific examples to support this claim.[quote]
Behavioral economics (among other currents of thought) greatly support what lothario is claiming: that those moral standards are very much in self-interest, even if it’s long term. The physical response one has when doing a good deed (that lothario described) is also a product of Evolution and is greatly responsible for the success of all species that present similar characteristics. Some compare it to the pleasure that we experience during sex, i.e., it’s a mechanism to provide an incentive to a behavior that got “selected in” because it was necessary for the survival of the species – humans who experienced that pleasure were more likely to adopt the associated behavior, hence survive longer, be more successful and have more kids, propagating the gene that drives it.[/quote]
Again, commonalities in creation are explained better by a common Creator – rather than machinations of randomness.[quote]
Of course, as all innate behaviors, they are not universal to all members of a species; the fragility of DNA, and the susceptibility to conditioning create diversity of behaviors – but there is a fundamental, innate moral core in most advanced mammals, a group of which we are just one member among many. [/quote]
Yes, and God has placed it in us all![/quote]
To put it in just one sentence: yes, goodness and kindness towards others are in fact in our best self-interest, and are innate behaviors that we share with many other species and allowed our survival (i.e., without it, we would have fallen victim to extinction through natural selection).[/quote]
Then how come the world and mankind is so bad. How come, left to our own, we would kill each other, rob each other, etc. Why do we need a police force with weapons? Wake up! We are not innately good. We are innately BAD. The only goodness in us is what God has imparted. [quote]
Based on this, one can easily define as “morally good” what improves our quality of life / chances of survival and as “morally bad” what doesn’t – or, rather, what reduces our quality of life / chances of survival.
“Amazingly”, that definition has been shown to yield exactly the same results as the codes of morality defended in Holy Scriptures.
What does this all mean?[/quote]
It all means that you have fallen for a false religion based on randomness, devoid of the Divine. You have created a God (‘natural selection’) of your own (or Darwin’s) imagination and you press observable pheonomena into your false scheme. Now granted, the same can be said for those who believe as I do, the difference is I call it faith (yes, in God’s Word) but faith nonetheless. You claim, however, sceintific fact. That is just ludicrous.[quote]
The theory goes like this:
We basically are what we are (in spite of being a product of randomness) because we could not be any different or we wouldn’t exist by now.[/quote]
Weren’t you part of the gaggle that flamed believers because of “circular reasoning?” Well what’s up with this?[quote]
I think the reason people have such problems believing this is possible through randomness is that it is hard to grasp the numbers involved – it is hard to grasp how old the Universe is, and how many stars there are.[/quote]
The reason that people have a hard time believing this is that it didn’t happen that way![quote]
A well-known metaphor that helps understand how this can be possible is the monkey theorem:
A monkey hitting keys at random on a typewriter keyboard will eventually type out the collected works of William Shakespeare.[/quote]
That is complete and utter frivolity. This could and would never ever happen! It is like saying I can blow my house up with TNT and get the Taj Mahal. Fantasy…[quote]
Of course, this is all theory and I can?t prove beyond any doubt that this wasn?t all the product of a Higher Power, but hey, you were the one who asked how can an alternative, atheist, explanation exist – it does, and it’s not rocket science…
[/quote]
This is the alternative explanation? Long long ago and far far away, it rained on the rocks and the rock slime seeped into the cespool of the oceans and out popped life?
Now who is telling the fariy tales?
Bow the knee to Jesus today! “Ye must be born again!”