[quote]Smashingweights wrote:
[quote]pat wrote:
[quote]Smashingweights wrote:
[quote]pat wrote:
[quote]Smashingweights wrote:
[quote]Gettnitdone wrote:
The future of the QB position: RG3, Luck, Kaepernick, Cam, Wilson and now Geno Smith.
[/quote]
Cam. No. Geno. No.
Otherwise that is a good list.[/quote]
Cam yes, Geno no.
What will really define these guys in the end is how they adjust as they start to lose their legs. The lightning fast running QB has a 5 year shelf life on average. When they slow down they need to rely more on reading defense and dropping back, like normal. Of list, I think Luck has the best chance at longevity. That being said, all of then are amazing players, at least for now.[/quote]
If you take away Wilson, RG3 and Kaepernicks legs, they would still be good passers. Cam? Not so much. Without his running ability he is no good. Not to mention he is a head case.
Wilson, Kaep, RG3 and Luck all have one thing in common that Newton lacks in spades. Composure.[/quote]
I agree Cam’s biggest weakness is composure and maturity, but his measurables are all really good, including his passing. Trust me I have no love for Cam but he’s really talented. That I cannot deny.[/quote]
I agree than Newton is very talented but IMO his talent all stems from his legs. If he had te mobility of Manning, Marino or Rivers then he would be a nobody QB. Without his ability to run (or possibly more importantly the threat to run) he would be serviceable QB at best. I agree he is talented but I think he is a bigger version of Vince Young. Newton isn’t terribly accurate so when his legs go he will be done. I do not think he has the arm to be a strict drop back passer and his lack of mental fortitude (something he shares with VY) will ultimately be his downfall IMO. You cannot lead an NFL team when you mope around, sit by yourself and cover your head with a towel after every interception.
I agree though that he is talented but I do not think he has staying power like Luck, Wilson, Kaep and RG3.[/quote]
I agree save for his passing accuracy. From what I have seen, he is a good passer and a good passer under pressure. But yeah, moping, covering your head with a towel and slumping off is the behavior of a weak minded person.
It’s the consequence of always being the best where ever you went and now, your matched talent wise. If he cannot address his maturity, man up and take his lumps, you are right he won’t last to long.