[quote]therajraj wrote:
[quote]DBCooper wrote:
However, I also think this spells the end of Lincecum in SF. They’re paying him something like $15-17 million a year through 2013, then he’s an unrestricted free agent. If he starts to taper off sharply, which it looks like he’s in the middle of doing, they could sign him relatively cheap, but if he’s on the decline why even bother? I think this is a sign that the Giants have decided which of their pitchers are the best long-term prospects and they’ve gone ahead and locked them up. I think they’re right too: Bumgarner is 6’5" 235 and has never missed a start in his professional career. Matt Cain is 6’3" 215 and has also never missed a start. These guys are built for the long haul and Lincecum simply isn’t.
And I think the Giants management is probably pretty frustrated with Lincecum. He doesn’t work out hard or seem to have any idea as to how to train in the off season. His weight is constantly fluctuating and the fact is that he’s lost velocity on AND command of his fastball every year the last 2 or 3 years now. I can’t believe I wasted a fucking third round pick on him in my fantasy league. It was a momentary pang of nostalgia.[/quote]
Although he’s provided elite pitching, he’s technically been in decline since his 2nd Cy Young year. The decrease in his strikeout rate and increase in walk rate are usually telling signs . The guy has been absolutely abused the last 4 years, he’s always among the league leaders in pitches thrown/start and total IP. Add in his velocity issues, the unconventional arm taxing delivery and his decision to drop his slider to save his arm and what you’re left with is a risky investment.
I think the Giants have gotten most of Lincecum’s even though technically a player’s prime is generally 26-32.
[/quote]
I don’t think his windup has anything to do with his velocity drop as far as arm strength goes. I think what it has done it has prevented him from finding a very repeatable motion and his control has suffered as a result. With loss of control and the ever-present strikeout mode he seems to be in from the first pitch of an at-bat to the last, he ended up running up high pitch totals even when he was throwing well. I think the high pitch counts and his slight frame, combined with a seeming indifference towards off season conditioning, have eroded his fastball considerably.
The thing that worries me is that as his velocity has dipped he clearly hasn’t gained better control along with it, and he doesn’t seem to have increased movement on any of his pitches, especially his fastball. I remember when Bonds first faced him in a Spring Training intrasquad and he fucking hammered him. He was throwing 100mph but Bonds said it was straight as an arrow and he backed it up by shellacking one of them. He’s gained a little bit of lateral movement with the two-seam grip but he doesn’t have any sink to the pitch.
He was always this type of pitcher in terms of control. But when he was throwing 95-97mph and his offspeed stuff had more snap as a result, he could get away with pitches that caught a little too much plate. But now, that shit gets pounded and pounded hard. He’s never really improved his control all that much from his first year in the bigs. If he had, the decrease in his overall stuff wouldn’t be problematic. It wouldn’t even be an issue. Everyone loses a little stuff as they get older, but the really good ones learn how to PITCH better as they age. Matt Cain is a perfect example. When he came up at the age of 20 he threw 96-97mph. But other than that and a curveball, he didn’t have much else.
But as he’s gotten older the fastball is down to about 92-93, but he has really good command and he knows how to pitch on top of the zone with it and below the zone with his offspeed stuff. And now he can spot any of his pitches in any count at the down and away location. Lincecum hasn’t shown this sort of evolution at all and with his windup I don’t know if he’ll ever be able to gain that sort of command of his pitches.