Men afraid of commitment?

[quote]SkyzykS wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]SkyzykS wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]SkyzykS wrote:
It depends on the guy, I think. After my early years of short term uncommitted banging around I looked forward to commitment with the right woman. A pretty distinct theme of similar characteristics which I liked in a woman had developed, and I finally found one I wanted to settle down and start a family with (she felt the same way too), so that is what we did. Earlier this month we celebrated our 6 year anniversary of marriage and yesterday was our sons first birthday.

On the other hand I have known a few guys who have always been very insecure and act like they have lost a limb if they don’t have a girlfriend. When they are single their one and only goal is to lock a woman down into a commitment (but not marriage), and until they do they are the whiniest most discontent entanglement of neurosis you can imagine. I speculate that they don’t feel like a man unless they have a woman on lock down, but at the same time since they know their own self (in a bad way)- don’t feel like they are good enough and have to keep proving their manhood (the ability to get women). One of the bad parts of these types of guys is that they will act like they are willing to jump through every imaginable hoop just for the right girl, but it’s all a lie.

Henry Rollins sums them up pretty well with this-

,and then it’s on to the next one.
[/quote]

Hmm. I don’t know. My limited experience is pretty much all long term relationships, and I believe that they’ve all exited reluctantly, or became reluctant after I said “enough,” and finally meant it, which takes a while for me.

I don’t think my question is about cheating - I shouldn’t have muddied things - more about how I can handle probing about what I’m doing with regard to dating others without being dishonest and without discouraging the questioner. Early dating things.

I just feel like my experience is the exact opposite of the stereotypical evasive guy, hopeful woman. Except it IS true, I am looking for a relationship (love) but just, I don’t know, not so quickly and before I’ve had time to catch my breath and kiss a couple of men, or maybe three, and see.

[/quote]

Yeah, I probably wasn’t so clear either. It takes a while to distill nebulous thoughts into succinct statement. The time frame I was speaking of is more than just a few months- More like a couple of years before it goes kaput.

I didn’t mean cheating either. More along the lines of a mans tendency to be dishonest about basic drives like sex, sense of security, vulnerability, Stuff like that. When a man says he is willing to forgo some of the basics he is not being honest with himself. Not honest with the other person either.

Given that I’m a probably more than a little aspy, I hit this stuff directly and appreciate the same in return. Sometimes that delicate dance around certain subjects like “what do you want out of this” just turns into a clumsy mess of ulterior motives and tickling each others ears.

So yeah, Honesty. Thats the best way to approach that getting to know each other phase. In any long term relationship I’ve been in I have said very quickly “Don’t tell me what you want me to think you are. Lets just do some stuff together and let me get to know you.”. Everybody loves world peace and thinks puppies are cute, but if a woman goes hiking with me after saying she loves hiking- but doesn’t have the shoes and hates it the whole time- She lied. Vice Versa- I’m not willing to act like I enjoy dinner theater nor would I make any attempt to do so just to develop a relationship.
[/quote]

Yeah, I agree. At this point I’m as likely to lead with my negatives, with which I’m pretty comfortable, as I’m also well aware of my strengths. A funny early conversation my ex-bf and I had was about what we’ve been called. I copped to “insufferable know-it-all,” while he admitted to having been recently called “a pompous prick.” Which was true on both sides.

But back to the point, because I think I do a good job of selecting men I like and who like me, with everyone cheerfully acknowledging flaws, what do I say when they start saying things like “just so you know, I’m not seeing anyone else” or asking about others? Should I decide these are the sorts of men I should seek or should avoid, or what?

AC, where are you? I’m ready for Phase II.[/quote]

If it’s within a month- I’d avoid but thats just me being theoretical. I’ve never dated a woman even short term that wasn’t relaying from last to next and consider that a foregone conclusion.

On the other hand, most guys I know, myself included are single for a period of time before starting another. Even then there is a good month or two of consistent companionship (feeling out period) before deciding on exclusivity.

Thats why I consider trying to lock it down too quick a red flag. It’s needy and possibly deceptive. Lots of single guys cheat on their wives and S.O.s
[/quote]

Hmm. That’s a tough one, because we’ve known one another for a while, had a couple of dates during an off time (breakup) with my ex-boyfriend last year, and now have picked it back up. He apologized this morning for bringing it up, by the way, and acknowledged that it was premature. I’ve been to his house several times, so he’s not cheating on anyone unless he’s seeing other people while he’s out of town, which he is a great deal. (Maybe too much for me to consider a relationship, but although I want to ask whether this brutal schedule is usual, it feels too early, so with an effort I’m being cool.)

I’m not sure what the question is, if there is one.

People are still largely products of their culture and our culture still holds the “fuck a lot in your early 20s, settle down find a wife and start a family by your 30s” as the norm. Ive seen a few of my friends get married at like 22/23 god knows why, but it usually didnt last very long.

A friend of mine was on a fast track towards marriage, not of his own volition, but it seemed to be progressing down that path with no concerns from him before the girl got cold feet and fucked off back to her home, upon which she got engaged to some dude she had been friendzoning for however many years, within like a few months of the breakup too. Complete 180 in man choice too, friend is a good looking tall charismatic tradesman, the dude she got engaged to is this foppish trumpet player or some shit.

[quote]Aussie Davo wrote:
I’m not sure what the question is, if there is one.[/quote]

Question is: how do I gracefully handle questions or probing about whether I am dating others without damaging what may be a budding serious romance? So in other words, I want to give the potentially serious thing time to develop as it will, but without putting all my eggs in one basket. I don’t want to lie, and I don’t know what the correct phrasing or response is. I want to keep my options open.

[quote]People are still largely products of their culture and our culture still holds the “fuck a lot in your early 20s, settle down find a wife and start a family by your 30s” as the norm. Ive seen a few of my friends get married at like 22/23 god knows why, but it usually didnt last very long.

A friend of mine was on a fast track towards marriage, not of his own volition, but it seemed to be progressing down that path with no concerns from him before the girl got cold feet and fucked off back to her home, upon which she got engaged to some dude she had been friendzoning for however many years, within like a few months of the breakup too. Complete 180 in man choice too, friend is a good looking tall charismatic tradesman, the dude she got engaged to is this foppish trumpet player or some shit.[/quote]

This made me laugh. Thank you for sharing!

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]SkyzykS wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]SkyzykS wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]SkyzykS wrote:
It depends on the guy, I think. After my early years of short term uncommitted banging around I looked forward to commitment with the right woman. A pretty distinct theme of similar characteristics which I liked in a woman had developed, and I finally found one I wanted to settle down and start a family with (she felt the same way too), so that is what we did. Earlier this month we celebrated our 6 year anniversary of marriage and yesterday was our sons first birthday.

On the other hand I have known a few guys who have always been very insecure and act like they have lost a limb if they don’t have a girlfriend. When they are single their one and only goal is to lock a woman down into a commitment (but not marriage), and until they do they are the whiniest most discontent entanglement of neurosis you can imagine. I speculate that they don’t feel like a man unless they have a woman on lock down, but at the same time since they know their own self (in a bad way)- don’t feel like they are good enough and have to keep proving their manhood (the ability to get women). One of the bad parts of these types of guys is that they will act like they are willing to jump through every imaginable hoop just for the right girl, but it’s all a lie.

Henry Rollins sums them up pretty well with this-

,and then it’s on to the next one.
[/quote]

Hmm. I don’t know. My limited experience is pretty much all long term relationships, and I believe that they’ve all exited reluctantly, or became reluctant after I said “enough,” and finally meant it, which takes a while for me.

I don’t think my question is about cheating - I shouldn’t have muddied things - more about how I can handle probing about what I’m doing with regard to dating others without being dishonest and without discouraging the questioner. Early dating things.

I just feel like my experience is the exact opposite of the stereotypical evasive guy, hopeful woman. Except it IS true, I am looking for a relationship (love) but just, I don’t know, not so quickly and before I’ve had time to catch my breath and kiss a couple of men, or maybe three, and see.

[/quote]

Yeah, I probably wasn’t so clear either. It takes a while to distill nebulous thoughts into succinct statement. The time frame I was speaking of is more than just a few months- More like a couple of years before it goes kaput.

I didn’t mean cheating either. More along the lines of a mans tendency to be dishonest about basic drives like sex, sense of security, vulnerability, Stuff like that. When a man says he is willing to forgo some of the basics he is not being honest with himself. Not honest with the other person either.

Given that I’m a probably more than a little aspy, I hit this stuff directly and appreciate the same in return. Sometimes that delicate dance around certain subjects like “what do you want out of this” just turns into a clumsy mess of ulterior motives and tickling each others ears.

So yeah, Honesty. Thats the best way to approach that getting to know each other phase. In any long term relationship I’ve been in I have said very quickly “Don’t tell me what you want me to think you are. Lets just do some stuff together and let me get to know you.”. Everybody loves world peace and thinks puppies are cute, but if a woman goes hiking with me after saying she loves hiking- but doesn’t have the shoes and hates it the whole time- She lied. Vice Versa- I’m not willing to act like I enjoy dinner theater nor would I make any attempt to do so just to develop a relationship.
[/quote]

Yeah, I agree. At this point I’m as likely to lead with my negatives, with which I’m pretty comfortable, as I’m also well aware of my strengths. A funny early conversation my ex-bf and I had was about what we’ve been called. I copped to “insufferable know-it-all,” while he admitted to having been recently called “a pompous prick.” Which was true on both sides.

But back to the point, because I think I do a good job of selecting men I like and who like me, with everyone cheerfully acknowledging flaws, what do I say when they start saying things like “just so you know, I’m not seeing anyone else” or asking about others? Should I decide these are the sorts of men I should seek or should avoid, or what?

AC, where are you? I’m ready for Phase II.[/quote]

If it’s within a month- I’d avoid but thats just me being theoretical. I’ve never dated a woman even short term that wasn’t relaying from last to next and consider that a foregone conclusion.

On the other hand, most guys I know, myself included are single for a period of time before starting another. Even then there is a good month or two of consistent companionship (feeling out period) before deciding on exclusivity.

Thats why I consider trying to lock it down too quick a red flag. It’s needy and possibly deceptive. Lots of single guys cheat on their wives and S.O.s
[/quote]

Hmm. That’s a tough one, because we’ve known one another for a while, had a couple of dates during an off time (breakup) with my ex-boyfriend last year, and now have picked it back up. He apologized this morning for bringing it up, by the way, and acknowledged that it was premature. I’ve been to his house several times, so he’s not cheating on anyone unless he’s seeing other people while he’s out of town, which he is a great deal. (Maybe too much for me to consider a relationship, but although I want to ask whether this brutal schedule is usual, it feels too early, so with an effort I’m being cool.)[/quote]

That requires a better discernment of circumstance than I’m capable of.
I have to bow out at this point. I have to leave for Alabama in a few hours for a trip I haven’t been looking forward to for quite a while and need to do some last minute preparation. I’ll be back in a week or so though.
It was nice chatting with you though. I don’t think we’ve ever actually conversed like this.

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

How do you explain that they seem to be willing stay with me, then, seemingly into perpetuity? I’d had like three marriage proposals before accepting my ex-husband’s at 23. And so then I stayed married for one million years and read terrible dread things about my declining sexual market value here on TN, but then I divorced well into my market decline – but there they still were! And they’re still acting the same bewildering way!

And let me repeat this for the millionth time - I am NOT beautiful. I’m appealing and fit, that’s all. And I wear glasses, so that bit about not getting passes is bullshit, too. Is anything even real?

And the thing about creative IS insulting to me, because it suggests that I lack discernment in choosing my companions. [/quote]

Take it as you want, but I have never pulled punches when I speak to people. I wasn’t insulting you though.

And they probably stay with you because of WHO you are, not what you look like specifically.

Single guys who haven’t picked out “the one” are looking for women to fit certain roles.

Some of us need “the secretary”.

Some of us need “the mom”.

Some of us need the “ho”

Some of us need to the “housewife”.

My opinion is many guys look for these qualities to varying degrees in different women…until they find the one with most of them.

I don’t think it means anything bad about you specifically.

[quote]debraD wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:
Really? Under what circumstances? Is this a myth, meant to confuse women further? As if your regular incomprehensible behavior isn’t enough!

Because once again I find myself doing a deer-in-the-headlights thing as someone begins pushing in that direction, i.e. exclusivity. And we’ve been seeing each other only briefly, no sex.

So my question for the board is, how is this best handled?

I don’t understand men. Except orion.
[/quote]

I don’t know how to handle it so no help there but I share your experience and believe the notion that men are afraid of commitment is a myth. Personally that eagerness to be exclusive often scared me in the other direction I think because I sensed desperation, because it wasn’t like I wanted to keep sowing oats or anything. It was always the fear of having someone in my apartment all the time as opposed to just on Saturday and Sunday.[/quote]

Athletic women with nice bodies have a much higher value in the dating world…just saying…

It’s obvious that I’m going to have to slow my armpit development before things get any more out of hand.

I handled it myself, since ONCE AGAIN the men of tnation couldn’t agree on what the hell men are doing or what they want.

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]Aussie Davo wrote:
I’m not sure what the question is, if there is one.[/quote]

Question is: how do I gracefully handle questions or probing about whether I am dating others without damaging what may be a budding serious romance? So in other words, I want to give the potentially serious thing time to develop as it will, but without putting all my eggs in one basket. I don’t want to lie, and I don’t know what the correct phrasing or response is. I want to keep my options open.

[quote]People are still largely products of their culture and our culture still holds the “fuck a lot in your early 20s, settle down find a wife and start a family by your 30s” as the norm. Ive seen a few of my friends get married at like 22/23 god knows why, but it usually didnt last very long.

A friend of mine was on a fast track towards marriage, not of his own volition, but it seemed to be progressing down that path with no concerns from him before the girl got cold feet and fucked off back to her home, upon which she got engaged to some dude she had been friendzoning for however many years, within like a few months of the breakup too. Complete 180 in man choice too, friend is a good looking tall charismatic tradesman, the dude she got engaged to is this foppish trumpet player or some shit.[/quote]

This made me laugh. Thank you for sharing![/quote]

I suppose by just being honest with him… Reinforcing your interest but also making it clear that you don’t want to put the cart before the horse.

Your comments resonate with me because in the relationships I have been in, it was definitely the guy that was first to initiate exclusivity as well. Literally, from the age of 16 I was jumping from one long-term relationship to another (until I got married) with little “casual” dating in between. It wasn’t a conscious thing, it just seemed to work out that way.

[quote]pushharder wrote:
Em, should I be spinning a Partridge Family record here?[/quote]

Only if we get a montage of her singing and painting a bus or something.

So, let me get this straight. You are hoping to find a guy who exhibits a bit more of the long lamented male fear of commitment (jk, sort of) but, instead keep finding guys who want to go steady/move in/get married approximately 15 seconds after meeting you, perhaps while the 2 of you are waiting for a bus together or something.

You want this because you want a little room to move around without someone trying to snuggle with you every time you turn around , at least for the time being. Is this the general idea?

Many dudes are brutally insecure. This insecurity drives them (after the novelty of the hooking up wears off) to immediately latch onto any “appealing” woman who seems remotely interested in them, a little like a lost kid at a shopping mall who finds a sympathetic adult. This seems to be especially true of “nice” guys.

I can fully appreciate why this wouldn’t particularly work for you. It’s kinda sad.

Where the “fear of commitment” comes in with these guys is in the long term, after they have secured comfort, validation, regular sex etc and it’s time to actually make some real effort to invest in the relationship. I would also say that this has shifted over the years with ideas about gender roles, increased financial independence for women, pussification of men etc.

So, yes, today it is kind of a myth for a lot of guys.

My advice would be to be up front, honest and direct about where you’re at and what you’re doing. This would not need to include furnishing details about other guys you may be seeing, that would be weird. If this guy can’t handle that he’s a.) looking for something different than you are, or b.) brutally insecure. Either way, I expect you’re better off knowing before you invest too much time.

[quote]WhiteSturgeon wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]Aussie Davo wrote:
I’m not sure what the question is, if there is one.[/quote]

Question is: how do I gracefully handle questions or probing about whether I am dating others without damaging what may be a budding serious romance? So in other words, I want to give the potentially serious thing time to develop as it will, but without putting all my eggs in one basket. I don’t want to lie, and I don’t know what the correct phrasing or response is. I want to keep my options open.

[quote]People are still largely products of their culture and our culture still holds the “fuck a lot in your early 20s, settle down find a wife and start a family by your 30s” as the norm. Ive seen a few of my friends get married at like 22/23 god knows why, but it usually didnt last very long.

A friend of mine was on a fast track towards marriage, not of his own volition, but it seemed to be progressing down that path with no concerns from him before the girl got cold feet and fucked off back to her home, upon which she got engaged to some dude she had been friendzoning for however many years, within like a few months of the breakup too. Complete 180 in man choice too, friend is a good looking tall charismatic tradesman, the dude she got engaged to is this foppish trumpet player or some shit.[/quote]

This made me laugh. Thank you for sharing![/quote]

I suppose by just being honest with him… Reinforcing your interest but also making it clear that you don’t want to put the cart before the horse.

Your comments resonate with me because in the relationships I have been in, it was definitely the guy that was first to initiate exclusivity as well. Literally, from the age of 16 I was jumping from one long-term relationship to another (until I got married) with little “casual” dating in between. It wasn’t a conscious thing, it just seemed to work out that way.
[/quote]

Yes! 16, exactly!

One problem or factor is that I’m drawn to fairly aggressive/masculine men, and they tend to go after what they want. I think that may be something we women posting here share in common, hence our common experience. Deb, being slightly more assertive, simply says “no,” while I turn into a puddle of uncertainty.

I think I did exactly as you suggested, going back to my issue. He’s a nice guy, hopefully it will go down well.

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]WhiteSturgeon wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]Aussie Davo wrote:
I’m not sure what the question is, if there is one.[/quote]

Question is: how do I gracefully handle questions or probing about whether I am dating others without damaging what may be a budding serious romance? So in other words, I want to give the potentially serious thing time to develop as it will, but without putting all my eggs in one basket. I don’t want to lie, and I don’t know what the correct phrasing or response is. I want to keep my options open.

[quote]People are still largely products of their culture and our culture still holds the “fuck a lot in your early 20s, settle down find a wife and start a family by your 30s” as the norm. Ive seen a few of my friends get married at like 22/23 god knows why, but it usually didnt last very long.

A friend of mine was on a fast track towards marriage, not of his own volition, but it seemed to be progressing down that path with no concerns from him before the girl got cold feet and fucked off back to her home, upon which she got engaged to some dude she had been friendzoning for however many years, within like a few months of the breakup too. Complete 180 in man choice too, friend is a good looking tall charismatic tradesman, the dude she got engaged to is this foppish trumpet player or some shit.[/quote]

This made me laugh. Thank you for sharing![/quote]

I suppose by just being honest with him… Reinforcing your interest but also making it clear that you don’t want to put the cart before the horse.

Your comments resonate with me because in the relationships I have been in, it was definitely the guy that was first to initiate exclusivity as well. Literally, from the age of 16 I was jumping from one long-term relationship to another (until I got married) with little “casual” dating in between. It wasn’t a conscious thing, it just seemed to work out that way.
[/quote]

Yes! 16, exactly!

One problem or factor is that I’m drawn to fairly aggressive/masculine men, and they tend to go after what they want. I think that may be something we women posting here share in common, hence our common experience. Deb, being slightly more assertive, simply says “no,” while I turn into a puddle of uncertainty.

I think I did exactly as you suggested, going back to my issue. He’s a nice guy, hopefully it will go down well.

[/quote]

Emily and Sturg, How are you meeting these guys? When your interested in someone do you ever make the first move?

[quote]pushharder wrote:
In no time we’d be zipping down the boulevard together under the gently swaying palms in my convertible with the top rolled down. Your long hair’d be whipping in the wind and a contented smile would adorn your lovely face as you leaned back in the seat soaking up the sunshine and breathing the ocean air.
[/quote]

Push, did you move?

I didn’t think there were palm trees where you live.

[quote]Aussie Davo wrote:
I’m not sure what the question is, if there is one.

People are still largely products of their culture and our culture still holds the “fuck a lot in your early 20s, settle down find a wife and start a family by your 30s” as the norm. Ive seen a few of my friends get married at like 22/23 god knows why, but it usually didnt last very long.

A friend of mine was on a fast track towards marriage, not of his own volition, but it seemed to be progressing down that path with no concerns from him before the girl got cold feet and fucked off back to her home, upon which she got engaged to some dude she had been friendzoning for however many years, within like a few months of the breakup too. Complete 180 in man choice too, friend is a good looking tall charismatic tradesman, the dude she got engaged to is this foppish trumpet player or some shit.
[/quote]
Did the trumpet player get a solid, steady gig with a major orchestra or a major band? A lot of women like musicians; add security to that and maybe the combination is a “winner”?

Wow. I am not qualified to contribute to this thread. I don’t know if there’s any such thing as true commitment or fidelity and I wish I was a willowy thing with librarian glasses who only attracted geeky intelligent types instead of narcissists and sociopaths.

I AM writing a paper on polyamory, however. Anyone got input on that?

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:
He’s a nice guy, hopefully it will go down well.

[/quote]

Not very likely

[quote]The Other Titan wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]WhiteSturgeon wrote:

[quote]EmilyQ wrote:

[quote]Aussie Davo wrote:
I’m not sure what the question is, if there is one.[/quote]

Question is: how do I gracefully handle questions or probing about whether I am dating others without damaging what may be a budding serious romance? So in other words, I want to give the potentially serious thing time to develop as it will, but without putting all my eggs in one basket. I don’t want to lie, and I don’t know what the correct phrasing or response is. I want to keep my options open.

[quote]People are still largely products of their culture and our culture still holds the “fuck a lot in your early 20s, settle down find a wife and start a family by your 30s” as the norm. Ive seen a few of my friends get married at like 22/23 god knows why, but it usually didnt last very long.

A friend of mine was on a fast track towards marriage, not of his own volition, but it seemed to be progressing down that path with no concerns from him before the girl got cold feet and fucked off back to her home, upon which she got engaged to some dude she had been friendzoning for however many years, within like a few months of the breakup too. Complete 180 in man choice too, friend is a good looking tall charismatic tradesman, the dude she got engaged to is this foppish trumpet player or some shit.[/quote]

This made me laugh. Thank you for sharing![/quote]

I suppose by just being honest with him… Reinforcing your interest but also making it clear that you don’t want to put the cart before the horse.

Your comments resonate with me because in the relationships I have been in, it was definitely the guy that was first to initiate exclusivity as well. Literally, from the age of 16 I was jumping from one long-term relationship to another (until I got married) with little “casual” dating in between. It wasn’t a conscious thing, it just seemed to work out that way.
[/quote]

Yes! 16, exactly!

One problem or factor is that I’m drawn to fairly aggressive/masculine men, and they tend to go after what they want. I think that may be something we women posting here share in common, hence our common experience. Deb, being slightly more assertive, simply says “no,” while I turn into a puddle of uncertainty.

I think I did exactly as you suggested, going back to my issue. He’s a nice guy, hopefully it will go down well.

[/quote]

Emily and Sturg, How are you meeting these guys? When your interested in someone do you ever make the first move? [/quote]

I have a history of acting SUPER socially awkward around attractive guys; morphing into the female equivalent of Napoleon Dynamite. So, making the first move would have been an epically badddddddd idea.