[quote]rainjack wrote:
Professor X wrote:
rainjack wrote:
You must have been watching it on Al Jazeera TV if you think for a second that the gov was calling anyone but her press secretary while the hurricane was still blowing.
I was wathcing CNN and Fos - they both had teams in the French Quarter two days before the hurricane struck talking about the possibility of a direct hit on NO. You’d think Nagin might have tried to err on the side of caution and d all he could. He didn’t. Neither did the governor.
FEMA dropped the ball. But you have them pegged as being responsible for things that are not in their scope. They had a complete ignorant dill hole running the show. He was pointing fingers just as fast and furious as was Nagin and the Governor.
As for Bush - he showed up 3 days before the Houston hurricane hit. There was no way in hell to divine the actual intensity of the hurricane. It was evidently a serious enough threat to evacuate most all of Houston, though.
You are one of the head cheerleaders for the “no matter what Bush does it’s the wrong thing” Brigade. And it shows in this last post.
Funny thing, Houston was able to evacuate - something that NO just couldn’t seem to grasp.
Why do you keep bringing up Houston as if you can’t understand that AFTER KATRINA, THE ENTIRE SOUTH WAS PARANOID!? No shit Houiston evacuated. My parents were stuck on I10 for over 14 hours just to get out of the city. We have never evacuated for any other hurricane that has hit the city growing up but they left for that one. Do you honestly think that many people would have fled if Katrina hadn’t occurred? If you think so, then you don’t know Houston very well.
My point is not that Houston evacuated. My point is that NOLA couldn’t get the job done.
NOLA is 12 feet below sea-level. You don’t have to be a rocket scientist to connect the dots here. FEMA didn’t have the responsibility to evacuate the city - that was Nagin’s baby all the way, and only got 80% of the job done.
SO let me recap. Big assed hurricane. Big assed city sitting 12 feet below sea level. Mayor with head up his ass.
I’ll leave you with your crayons to figure this one out.
[/quote]
RJ, you’re correct in that it was Nagin’s baby to begin with, but you also have to factor in the ignorance and stubborness of the people there. I bet if more of those people were really motivated to leave, the evactuation would have been better. But since a lot of the victims have sat through so many other storms, they felt that they could make it through this one, be it a CAT 5 or not. That was Nagin’s first stumbling block. He could not get the people to move fast enough. You can call for a mandatory evac, but if the citizens don’t react, how does one leaglly force people out of their homes. Let’s face it, these people were basically broke with little to no means of transportation.
Sure the busses could have been used, but again people were hesitant to get that ball rolling. It wasn’t until the storm hit that everyone discovered how wrong the were to not get the hell out. Yes Nagin should have been more forceful, and Blanco should have lit a fire under his ass to do so, but they underestimated the storm and got bit on the ass.