[quote]Professor X wrote:
That depends. In the mind of a true atheist, I can only assume that there is no base of moral right or wrong to pull from. That would imply that there is absolute good and absolute evil. They object to this idea so how can they justify what is absolutely right and what is absolutely wrong? In their minds, since there are no cosmic consequences for “wrong actions” or “right actions”, it makes little sense to assume that thay have strong values on anything. That is why I asked the questions above that have yet to be answered straightly.
rainjack wrote:
I agree with ProfX on this one. MM has been signing his little posts with “be your own god”. Either he’s completely full of crap and is arguing for argument’s sake, or he actually believes this and he is his own little god. Because of this, I think that the question of how his moral compass is built is a very pertinent question.
It jut so happens that MM has refused to answer this very important question. It creates quite the dilema for our favorite little elitist.
If he admits what is probably the truth - he got his morals from the same place as everyone else - Judeao-Christian principles that have been around for thousands of years - then he loses a little face. If he admits to what Prof X is arguing, then he is an amoral pig that is fronting as a law abiding citizen. Again he loses face.
[/quote]
Actually, I have already answered this question about the morality of atheists. Boscobarbell has also expounded upon what I had already posted, so I do not feel the need to repeat myself, nor quote what he has already said on the subject.
As for “Be your own god…”, you are already living up to that little catch-phrase. You go to work to feed your family rather than have faith that God will provide for you. If someone where to attack you, you would not turn the other cheek, but you would fight back (being a T-Man and all). In essence, you have taken control of your own life rather than putting it in the hands of a creator because you realize that based on the low success rate of your prayers, lack of any significant miracles, pain and suffering throughout the world, that your God is not likely to be there when you need Him.
Therefore, Be your own god means to take your life into your own hands, alter your environment to better suit your life and learn as much about the universe as you possibly can.
[quote]Professor X wrote:
I am truly interested now, where were you married and did you go to “any magistrate” in order to get married and avoid a preacher? I know I would if I opposed religion like you seem to.[/quote]
You actually seem sincere in your questioning so I will answer this one.
I am not married; I do not agree with the act of marriage–not for religious reasons but for the fact that one is required to get a license to be with someone they love. It just seems ridiculous to me. However, that is my own personal view and I did not want you to have any more fuel for your ad hominem attacks and straw man arguments to use against the other atheists just because that is what I personally feel, so I did not feel the need to mention it.
You assigned me the role of having a wife and children without knowing whether I had them or not. I was more than happy to go along with the hypothetical situation to see where your arguments were leading, but I never said that I was, in fact, married or had any children.