[quote]Dt546 wrote:
I am simply stating that my experience with addiction (personal and profesional) is that it is not a black and white issue. If telling people “Drugs are bad mmk,” kept them off drugs, than our prison systems would be a lot less crowded.
[/quote]
Well “Drugs are bad mmmkay” probably does a good job keeps the vast majority off drugs. I suspect the rest are pulled in by environmental factors, more so than genetics. I’m an EMT and most of the “patients” I transport who have either overdosed, or just can’t afford anymore crack/meth till the first of the month and are coming down hard come out of the same neighborhoods/trailer parks where we pickup all of the other crack/meth heads. I suspect the vast majority of the barefoot kids running around in front of my ambulance will be in the same shit before they reach twenty, and it’s not due to genetics. Most of the people I know who are recovering addicts who have stayed clean for any decent length of time have done so by removing themselves from that environment, which must be very hard when that’s all you know.
My main problem with the genetics argument is that it smacks of determinism, and the weak always want to clamp on to some excuse for their failings. I hope that instead of determinism, most of those barefoot trailerpark kids will instead believe in willpower and common sense.
I don’t whole heartedly support “drugs are bad mmmkay” the way it is taught in schools, because it demonizes marijuana, and is rather hypocritical when so many of the kids are already on behavior altering prescription drugs.