[quote]forlife wrote:
[quote]ephrem wrote:
[quote]forlife wrote:
[quote]ephrem wrote:
I’m not a masochist and abstain from self-flagellation Chris. I think that’s a ridiculous notion, and a malignant one.
Ofcourse suffering is not just feeling pain, physically or emotionally, suffering is the rejection of pain; “I don’t want this. Why me?”.
I believe that institutionalised religion does not teach people how to alleviate suffering for themselves, but merely covers it with a comfortblanket without really adressing the issue.
If you have few problems to begin with this is fine ofcourse, but for someone with a mountain of troubles the story is different.[/quote]
There’s something to be said for a comfort blanket.
That said, religion can actually create and perpetuate unnecessary suffering by judging and punishing people based on unproven beliefs. For example, there have been many gay suicides because people couldn’t reconcile their religious beliefs with their sexual orientation.
[/quote]
A comfort blanket is not a solution, and religion is not a solution to personal suffering.
As you said, it often creates more suffering.
[/quote]
I don’t think it’s either/or, but can be both.
Just because religion can cause suffering doesn’t mean it doesn’t help alleviate suffering in some cases.
For example, faith can provide a cancer patient with peace of mind, reduced stress, less pain and anxiety, and a stronger will to live. All good things.
However, if faith causes the believer to forego medical treatments, it can actually hurt them more than it helps.
Tiribulus recently shared how his faith has helped him through a difficult period, where he otherwise would have given up hope. How is that a bad thing?[/quote]
On a personal note, I actually cured myself of alcoholism. As in, I was, for years, the worst kind of alcoholic on an ever-downward spiral of deeper and deeper addiction. I was the kind of alcoholic that people eventually have interventions for, though thankfully I had not yet reached that point.
Today I am happy to say that I am a well adjusted NON-alcoholic, completely cured of that terrible malady. I actually still drink, even, but the demon that used to wait for me to take my first drink has been, ahem, exorcised.
I came to my cure through a combination of the most fervent, tireless prayer and the discovery of a system that actually works. Now, I firmly believe if had not put in all of that prayer time, I would not have discovered the system. But during the entire time I was praying, literally near despair for years and years, thinking my prayers would never be answered no magical cure came. The answer to those prayers came in the form of a very secular, scientific method of recovery.
And believe me, the suffering I was doing was in NO way edifying. Anyway my point is that sometimes, eph, you paint religious folk out to be these cardboard cut-out humans who think and act only one way. I think, if nothing else, our conversations here should have given you a few clues that we are a bit more three dimensional than that.