[quote]BradTGIF wrote:
I finally watched “Moneyball”
Boring. It’s no wonder why this movie took so freaking long to make.
Aaron Sorkin who also wrote The Social Network, wrote this thing too.
I also thought The Social Network was boring.
Maybe Spoilers
The film showed too much of Brad Pitt mulling things over, sitting in one place and sighing. Hardly any baseball action outside of TV broadcasts in the background, the scenes were deliberate and felt more like little vignettes than a combined story with a narrative.
Examples:
Billy sits in the stands listening to a game
Billy has a conversation with the scouts
Billy goes to Cleveland to talk with their GM
Billy talks to Peter in Cleveland
Billy talks to Peter in an office
Billy talks to Peter in a film room
Peter does math on a computer
Billy talks to Art Howe
Billy and Peter meet with scouts
Billy picks up daughter from Ex’s house
Billy listens to daughter sing a song
Billy goes to Scott Hattiebergs house
Billy watches practice.
Oh, it keeps going.
The whole movie, basically shot from the POV of Billy Beane.
Now if they were keeping true to the book, I guess that’s ok, but it doesn’t make for a compelling story. I wanted to see more baseball action, more interraction between the players and the manager, especially as it pertained to the wacky way they were putting their team together. There had to be confusion and dissent in the clubhouse, but the players were all portrayed as static… stagnant.
I mean, you’ve got a motherfucking acting BEAST in Phillip Seymore Hoffman playing the cagey Manager in Art Howe and you don’t let him off the chain? He looked bored. Spoke softly.
C’mon.
End Spoilers
I give it a C+
[/quote]
Just want to point out that it’s not a movie about baseball, it’s a movie about how Billy Beane utilized sabermetrics and unconventional approaches to building winning teams with a very low budget. It’s a movie with baseball in it, but not necessarily about baseball
I’m reading the book now, I’m taking a sports economics class next spring, and the book’s about the process that GM Beane went through, a little history about him and some of the undervalued players, but mostly about the statistics and economics behind his decisions.