[quote]ZEB wrote:
I think you have some very good points my friend! Kids do learn by imitation. Your niece no doubt heard someone say “Shut up” so she said it.
That is the very reason that I don’t want children exposed to some seedy bum playing with himself in public. That just might put an idea or two into an impressionable young mind. Ideas that are not appropriate for, say a 9 year old girl. Would you play a pornographic tape in front of a child? No, of course not!(Did Michael Jackson? Oh never mind that’s a different topic)Call me crazy but I think that sort of scene is not a healthy and productive picture to put in a childs mind.
Remember, that just because some things are learned by tradition, that does not make them wrong. In fact, I think if we held more closely to our traditions there would be more respect for one another, such as my parents and grandparents had for their peers (and each other).
I also think you may have a different viewpoint when you have children of your own. I have seen plenty of reformed “free spirits” after they have children. Sometimes they even revert to more traditonal “core beliefs” when they are responsible for what goes into the brains of their little loved ones.
Don’t be to quick to question traditional behaviors. They are tradition for a reason. When something works it should be repeated.
[/quote]
zeb, fantastic post!
your comments about tradition and reformed free spirits are spot on. i look forward to having children one day and i know i’ll be a changed man when that day comes, even with knowing this and preparing for this im sure i’ll get blindsided anyway.
i have tremendous respect for tradition. i think a perfect tradition is one that allows for its own questioning. this is very much how the US of A is. maintaining tradition is important, yet evolving (yes, i know, VERY ambiguous word) is also important.
i believe evolution as a practical tool not as history. this makes me understand that our existence (biologically, astronomically, culturally) is always changing, and we must change as well. yet if we don’t maintain traditions then all is lost.
so im for upholding tradition even if it’s for the sake of upholding tradition, yet i hope we can learn from the mistakes of the tradition we were raised in [like how my father learned some things to not do with me because his father did them to him, and like how i’ll learn from my father’s mistakes when raising me (and hopefully not forget the successes he made)].
in trying to optimize the practicality of any philosphy i espouse, i have discovered the necessity for mistakes, hardships, blood and sweat and tears, confusion, etc. and i want my children to witness and experience these things when they’re old enough to learn from them yet still want to know daddy’s beliefs more than anyone elses.
i don’t want to forget the initial topic (a child witnessing public profanity) so i’ll revert to that. granted, i’ve never been responsible for young ones so if i was speaking from experience it’d actually be from out of my ass. what i can speak from is, though, a sincere desire to optimize my future childrens’ upbringings to enhance their lives, make them better than me, and give me a legacy (much like how my father hopes for me to be better than him and be his legacy).
i just imagine that if i had a nine year old daughter witnessing a man masturbating in the street it would be a prime opportunity for me to teach her something because she would be thoroughly intrigued by it, and i think humans learn best when they are intrigued and focused and listening.
yet, a society that doesn’t have a man masturbating in the street is a society that has a achieved a beneficial tradition through their (and ancestors) understanding of the negativities of said masturbating man. i just fear that if we shelter our children so much we will hinder their progress into adulthood and they’ll have to come up with their own ideas.
this, i believe, is why people like you uphold tradition dearly, because you know better, but if our children don’t learn why our tradition is important then they may just rebel and come up with their own crackpot ideas (i did).
example: if i were a monarchial world leader i would teach my sons the great benefit of peace, love, and understanding. but i wouldn’t neglect to teach them how to war and hate and repel other ideologies. because after i die and pass the crown they WILL meet with adversaries and find it necessary to war or hate or at least understand war and hate so they can combat it successfully.
has any of this correlated to the original topic? i guess im just trying to say that the immorality of public profanity creates a conundrum for me because i view it as a prime opportunity to teach the children i will one day have about public profanity, yet a strong and successful society has strong and successful traditions, and strong and successful traditions reciprocate a strong and successful society…and the goal is a strong and successful society.
zeb, what are your beliefs concerning the evolution (if you don’t like that word choose “adaptation, progress, change”) of traditions to better society.
P.S. i hope my post isn’t gibberish and sorry for some of its repetitiveness.