Very much agree with these. Overall, I mostly lack sympathy for adults who aren’t doing great in life. If you’re unwilling to get and keep a job, avoid breaking the law, and be a good example to your children (even if you’re not wealthy, you can still raise a decent human being), then that’s mostly on you, since you’re an adult who’s in charge of your own life.
However, Emily, like you said, I think it goes a lot deeper than that. I’ll just use my family as an example. I’m Native American, and while I am not from the reservation, my dad was born and raised there, and most of his family still is there. His dad, a decent guy, from what I’ve heard died in a car crash when my dad was (I think 8). My grandma and him had a good relationship - they actually loved each other and wanted a family and a future together, not just happened to have a kid through a one night stand. She was very brokenhearted after his death, and kinda went off the deep end. Became a heavy drinker, and pretty much took off, leaving my dad alone at their trailer houses on top of a hill, with the 20 other trailers they called their “town,” an hour+ from any hospitals, grocery stores, or stores. My dad began drinking and smoking pot daily, quit going to school, started getting into fights, watched his home become basically a party house that he was present at to watch the adults in his life be idiots, saw his uncle murdered, saw his aunts raped, and pretty much was on his own…before even finishing elementary school.
His mom kinda got her shit together, came back, they spent a couple years more there, then decided to move a few hours away to a real town, where I’ve grown up in. His mom met another dude, they had 3 daughters together, the guy physically abused my grandma in front of the kids, kicked my dad out of the house every few nights regardless of the weather, spent his money and free time drinking and neglecting his family, and my dad became more and more of an angry addict. He spent his high school years getting drunk/high, fighting, and working. That’s actually something that has never made much sense but is the #1 thing I respect about my dad - he’s an extremely hard worker and has held down a job nonstop since he was 16 years old. Not very unique, but for his demographic it’s impressive.
He had me with my mom at 17 (her) and 18 (him) years old, began working a 60+ hours a week for a masonry company where all of his coworkers and bosses expected him to quit within 2 weeks, because everyone knows Native guys only need that first paycheck so they can get another case of beer!
Anyway, he’s not an amazing dude now. He’s a good provider, and I love him, but he’s still angry, depressed, and an addict. His mom died a few years ago after 3 years of a very painful battle with cancer that no one was able to afford to help with. His sisters were 14 and 18 years old. His stepdad disappeared through it all. The older sister recently became sober after having a child who’s father is not in the picture and becoming a meth seller/user. The younger sister has abandoned her 4 year old son and has become an extremely bad meth addict. He’s still got a messed up life, and hasn’t really matured in the right ways to improve his mental health or change his ways of coping.
Anyway, didn’t mean to make that so long, but the point is, it’s not exactly the easiest thing ever to be an awesome person after becoming an addict at 10 years old and seeing horrible things, and to watch ALL of your loved ones ruin their lives. There’s countless stories like this, just within my own family, or within my tribe, and it’s the same all over the country. I’ve heard about intergenerational trauma, especially in the black and Native communities, and don’t know enough to comment on it, but it makes sense to me.
Bottom line, you don’t get a free pass to fuck up because your life sucked, but you also need to understand that some people’s perspectives on life and how they respond to things is VERY, very different.