[quote]JeffR wrote:
beowolf wrote:
The problem is no ones criticizing EVERYTHING.
Hey, beowolf.
You do know that there is a portion of people in the world that are doing EXACTLY that. Actually, you can look no further than this board to find people who are hostile to our very way of life.
They try nice little catch phrases such as “I just object to your government, not your people.”
No one should buy that.
Most people will agree our involvement in WWI and WWII was a good thing. They’ll agree we’ve set up a pretty good government, based off an amazing constitution. They’ll agree we still ahve more rights and freedoms than most of the world. They’ll argue we treat our people pretty damn well.
Agreed. However, some people find those rights dangerous. Some people deny others freedom to further their tyranny.
It’s only our most recent, post-cold war era foreign policy thats been shit.
Not true. We’ve just moved into an era that has far more grey.
We can’t force bin laden to have a ceremony on the USS Missouri and call an end to the conflict.
We are fighting a bad idea with a better one.
And the phrase “My country, right or wrong” is one of the most Un-American pieces of bullshit ever spoken.
Spoken like a true liberal. I’ll tell you what, if you don’t give your own country the benefit of the doubt, innocent until proven guilty, and so forth, then you need to spend some time in somalia.
An American Patriot will identify an error in government and work to rectify it.
Money, blood, votes, etc. He/she wouldn’t jump to overreaching conclusions. For example, “All politicians are scum” or “The U.S. Government is only concerned with oil.”
Criticism is the basis for everything American.
As is love of country. Criticism without action, is the lowest form of public discourse.
Our government, our constitution, and our nation is based on the people being allowed to criticize and change the government.
True. However, there are people like jlesk who rebel just to get attention.
I’m not a fan.
A social contract between the people and the government. The Government in America only exists because the people support it. That’s why our nation is special, that is what makes us incredible.
Well put.
When our government fucks up, it SHOULD be criticized. Fully and thoroughly. It’s the American thing to do. And if you believe it didn’t fuck up, then you should voice that opinion as well.
That is the start. The MORE important part is demanding and participating in the remedy.
But don’t defend the US just because you were born here.
Again, that is a LARGE difference between you and I.
I give the American people the benefit of the doubt from the get go. While I may not agree with every policy or decision, love of country has to include an inherent loyalty.
I encourage you to travel overseas.
I’ll bet you change your tune if you spent some time in Cuba.
Or, if you don’t have the finances, go to the coast of Florida.
You’ll see people dying to reach our shores.
I’d be willing to bet that this will change your tune. I’ll bet you become more loyal. Finally, I’d wager that your new found loyalty would make it more likely to participate in actions that improve your community and your country.
JeffR
[/quote]
The problem is some people give much more then the benefit of the doubt. I do love this nation, and I do believe it is innocent until proven guilty. However, that doesn’t mean I’ll accept anything it says without question. I will not defend America because I was born here, I will defend it when I believe it has done the right thing. More often than not, I do believe America does, at the very least, as close as we can to the right thing.
I don’t think all politicians are scum, by the by. Most of them are pretty good people, and honestly want what they believe to be best for our nation (I put George W. Bush, Bush Sr, Clinton (BILL), Obama, Ron Paul, Al Gore, John Edwards and others like them in this category), but there are those who just come off as total scum, looking out for their own personal interests just a bit to freakin much (Hilary, Dick Cheney ect). And of course there are those who just have way to much religion in em. I can do without those.
I know there is a portion of the world which blames us for everything, but that doesn’t mean some of the things they blame us for isn’t somewhat our fault. Obvious, we are not the worlds greatest evil. But we are no where close to being the worlds greatest international good. If you look back in history, a lot of people blamed stuff on GB like they do on us now. And if you look carefully, you’ll find GB fucked A LOT of stuff up way back when. As did Germany, who received a bucket load of blame. Doesn’t mean they were the ultimate evil, just that they made some evil choices.
We are not terrorists. I will not, and cannot compare what we do as a nation to the actions of Islamist extremists. But I will say this; we aren’t fighting for the side of pure good against pure evil. This is not a holy war. We sometimes do unjustifiable things. Does that make us evil? Not necessarily. It just doesn’t make us God’s super chosen nation, like a lot of people like to delude themselves into believing.