NYC Food Suggestions?

No no L&B isn’t lombardi’s. L&B is a spot in Brooklyn that makes a special kind of pizza. A square slice with the cheese under the sauce. It’s unique and heavenly. Too far away from where you’re going to be though.

About how you should tackle the order of the places. It shouldn’t be too difficult. Little Italy is directly east of the Holland Tunnel. So you can start there and then work your way north and eventually circle back. Are you going to be taking a cab everywhere or using the subway? Both?

FWIW you can clock a block in a minute in case you need to walk around. I like this idea of a highly organized feasting agenda.

bonez, I’ve never been to L&B’s, so i’ll check it out. I just looked it up and its located in “Spumoni Gardens.” fuck me! I didnt even know this place existed.

[quote]Mascherano wrote:
FWIW you can clock a block in a minute in case you need to walk around. I like this idea of a highly organized feasting agenda.

bonez, I’ve never been to L&B’s, so i’ll check it out. I just looked it up and its located in “Spumoni Gardens.” fuck me! I didnt even know this place existed. [/quote]

For sure. Get a few square slices and a small cup of spumoni ice cream afterward. You won’t be disappointed.

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:
No no L&B isn’t lombardi’s. L&B is a spot in Brooklyn that makes a special kind of pizza. A square slice with the cheese under the sauce. It’s unique and heavenly. Too far away from where you’re going to be though.

About how you should tackle the order of the places. It shouldn’t be too difficult. Little Italy is directly east of the Holland Tunnel. So you can start there and then work your way north and eventually circle back. Are you going to be taking a cab everywhere or using the subway? Both?[/quote]

Ummmm…nah, I thought you could just drive me around everywhere. That’d be awesome!

[quote]Mascherano wrote:
FWIW you can clock a block in a minute in case you need to walk around. I like this idea of a highly organized feasting agenda.

[/quote]

We could all just meet up and invade all these places. It’d be like Crossfit…
5 places to run in and eat for time

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:
No no L&B isn’t lombardi’s. L&B is a spot in Brooklyn that makes a special kind of pizza. A square slice with the cheese under the sauce. It’s unique and heavenly. Too far away from where you’re going to be though.

About how you should tackle the order of the places. It shouldn’t be too difficult. Little Italy is directly east of the Holland Tunnel. So you can start there and then work your way north and eventually circle back. Are you going to be taking a cab everywhere or using the subway? Both?[/quote]

I just got back from L&Bs alittle while ago.

I’m not sure if you mentioned the time of day you’re going to be in town but if you’re there from 5pm onwards I’d head to St Marks Place.

There are a ton of very good and very authentic Japanese places there.

Oh Taisho and Kenka (the name is only written in Japanese but you’ll recognise it by the cotton candy machine outside) are particularly good. Both serve a ton of dishes which are generally impossible to find outside Japan, as well as being cheap and having a constant party atmosphere (at 2am both will be full of people).

Carrying on down St Marks, past the Japanese places and tattoo parlors, you will come to the residential portion of the street. Here you will find Crif Dogs. Home of some of the best hot dogs and chili fries in New York.

Also hidden behind a fake wall, inside a phone booth, in Crif Dogs is a speakeasy called PDT. Their bacon infused old fashioned is quite possibly the best drink in the World. If you want to get in you’ll have to call to make a reservation (http://www.pdtnyc.com) at 3pm on the day you want to go. It’s worth it.

have to help out a bit…for “food network food” you can head to either brennan and car…which was recently on man vs. food…or you can head to roll’n’roaster(my pick)…for pizza…its either l’n’b aka spumoni gardens or if your into more of a brick oven style pizza grimaldis under the brooklyn bridge…hotdog is a hotdog…stay away from typical shit…btw these are all in brooklyn

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:
No no L&B isn’t lombardi’s. L&B is a spot in Brooklyn that makes a special kind of pizza. A square slice with the cheese under the sauce. It’s unique and heavenly. Too far away from where you’re going to be though.

About how you should tackle the order of the places. It shouldn’t be too difficult. Little Italy is directly east of the Holland Tunnel. So you can start there and then work your way north and eventually circle back. Are you going to be taking a cab everywhere or using the subway? Both?[/quote]

Maybe it’s different, but this sounds like what Little Italy on East 43rd calls a “sicilian grandma” slice. Jiannetto’s pizza truck on 47th and Park (sometimes at 47th and Vanderbilt) has these as well. Great stuff if you get them fresh and not from under a heating lamp.

DB

Im in NYC for the second time this week. Thanks to all the locals for the recs. The little lady is gettin off work and I cant wait to try some of these places…

Id even, as a tourist, second Brother Jimmys - cheap eats and beer specials, tho I wouldnt go for a unique culinary experience (unless you think a $2 PBR in NYC qualifies). Ill be there for white trash wednesday this week, probably blasted out of my mind destroying weeks of gym gains with my old college buddies. Its kind of an ACC bar too if I remember right…

53rd and 6th hallal food stand chicken and rice with extra white sauce. ftw.

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:

[quote]ChrisPowers wrote:

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:
Do not get pizza from any random place. The best pizza is from Lombardi’s on Spring street between Mott and Mulberry in little italy. It’s coal oven pizza. Every other pizza place is gas oven and is completely different. If you just want regular gas oven pizza then take your pick of the thousands of places. Oh but if you go to Lombardi’s you have to order a whole pie. No slices. Polishing off a regular sized one is very doable though.

Shake Shack in Madison Sq Park is also worth it for a good burger and custard shake.
[/quote]

Never been to Lombardi’s, but it does have that reputation. However, it’s coal oven, which is great, but if you want to try the thin crust slice of pizza that made New York pizza famous, the closest I’ve seen to the glory days is the actual, REAL, original Ray’s pizzeria at 27 Prince Street. It’s gas oven pizza, still served by the slice, which is what old school pizzeria pizza is, in my book. Whatever you do, don’t just randomly walk into any pizzeria named Ray’s, or you will most likely be served absolute garbage. Try a plain slice to see what it’s all about, then grab a pesto slice if you want, which is equally good.

The same goes for the dirty water dogs. Maybe 20 years ago, you could get a great street vendor dog. Those days are long gone. The closest you can come to that now is Gray’s Papaya (Papaya King is supposed to be good also, but I’ve never gone). Whatever you do, don’t mistakenly walk into some random Papaya hot dog joint like Papaya Dog, or you will likely be served crap also. You’ll want to order a bunch of dogs (at least four, I’d guess), but get at least one plain with mustard. As your drink, of course do the papaya drink.

Sucks that it’s come to this in New York, but it has. The worst part is that you have tourists coming here, grabbing a horrible, cold, bland dirty water hot dog at the first stand they see, and thinking that that’s what made NYC hot dogs famous. Ditto for any random pizza joint. They leave thinking it’s all bogus hype, and that Chicago pizza is better than New York pizza. Not to knock Chicago, but what they serve is so different from true Neapolitan style pizza, I hesitate to call it pizza. I’m sure it’s great though. As for the Chicago hot dog? Eh, don’t get me started…[/quote]

Yes for sure original Ray’s for a slice of gas oven pizza. I live in Brooklyn and eat regular pizza here but Ray’s is good.

And seriously try Lombardi’s at least once in your life. Half plain/half calamata olives is the way to go.[/quote]

Will do. Thanks, bro. Cheat day, here I come…

[quote]Mascherano wrote:

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:

[quote]celibrate2047 wrote:
I think we’ll be meandering around NYC for 4-5 hours or until we get tired of the cold. We fly into Newark. My friend, the travel agent, explained that NYC is basically across the bridge from where we’ll fly into Newark. I’m assuming these places will be easy to find?

And I’m not really looking for steak houses perse. And I’m not worried about the cost. But I want that food that you see on the Food Channel when they talk about great places to stop. So I’m looking to stuff my face with as much ‘awesome’ food as I can in the likes of pizza and hot dogs and sausages and hot links, etc. I do appreciate all the comments…please keep 'em comin. The bbq did sound good but we have so many bbq places here. Some not so good, but enough of 'em pretty darn good. I think in general, the south loves bbq.

Okay, so stop at:
Hallo Berlin sausage stand
Lombardi’s on Spring street
Zabar’s Bakery
5 Napkin Burger
Greys Papaya[/quote]

I don’t think it’s that easy finding most of these places unless you have a well planned schedule. 4-5 hours will be tough to get it all done. Go on google maps and see how far apart the places on your list are from each other. If you take a cab from place to place youre looking at a $100 in fares. Subway is obviously much cheaper but good luck navigating it. [/quote]

Nah, I think it can be done in 4-5 hours. The NY subway system is hands down the most comprehensive mass transit system in the world (and we have a lot of dumb asses living in this city to prove it). But as someone else stated, getting to Newark is a bitch of a ride, so that might eat up a bit of time.

Zabar’s is way up on the west side tho, so how you to include that is beyond me. You can totally do (in this order) Hallo, 5 napkin, Greys on 14th and then Lombardi’s then get in a cab and scuttle over to Newark. But some of these places are sit down, so again there’s a time issue.

Tough call. This might be a lofty endeavor OP…

Maybe you can do, Katz’, Lombardi’s, grey’s papaya, which are all relatively quick eats and around the same neighborhood…

edit: I meant Grey’s on 6th ave and 8th st. [/quote]

If I may, I agree that Zabar’s is probably not worth it, but that’s easy for me to say since I’m in that neighborhood a lot. But nothing pops into my head as being “can’t miss.” The biggest benefit of going there is that H&H Bagels is literally right across the street, so you can pop in there and say you’ve been (they’re my personal favorite in NYC, with Murray’s right up there as well). Regarding etiquette, it’s not the Soup Nazi, but just so you know they don’t put anything on your bagel–you have to buy it separately. Best bet: walk in, ask what’s hot, get one of whatever’s hot. So good, cream cheese and butter aren’t even necessary.

The other benefit is that there’s a Gray’s Papaya on 72nd and Broadway. So you can hit that up, hop back on the train (or walk) and be at Zabar’s and H&H in a matter of minutes (80th and Broadway, I believe).

Also, real quick, I agree with Roman to skip on barbecue (that’s like going to Texas or the Carolinas for New York style pizza). But if you must go, I like Daisy May (tough to get to, but they have a cart somewhere also).

Finally, some of these carts are only open on weekdays (the Hallo Berlin cart, for one), so check in advance. And last piece of advice: familiarize yourself with the MTA subway map before you go, and map out a plan of attack. It’s complicated if you’ve never been, and it’s easy to get confused and waste precious, precious time that would be better spent stuffing your piehole.

Enjoy.

[quote]dollarbill44 wrote:

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:
No no L&B isn’t lombardi’s. L&B is a spot in Brooklyn that makes a special kind of pizza. A square slice with the cheese under the sauce. It’s unique and heavenly. Too far away from where you’re going to be though.

About how you should tackle the order of the places. It shouldn’t be too difficult. Little Italy is directly east of the Holland Tunnel. So you can start there and then work your way north and eventually circle back. Are you going to be taking a cab everywhere or using the subway? Both?[/quote]

Maybe it’s different, but this sounds like what Little Italy on East 43rd calls a “sicilian grandma” slice. Jiannetto’s pizza truck on 47th and Park (sometimes at 47th and Vanderbilt) has these as well. Great stuff if you get them fresh and not from under a heating lamp.

DB[/quote]

Nope not a grandma slice. Similar though, in look not in taste.

Bloody hell, all this New York food talk is making me salivate.

The pizza here is the size of a frisbee and they top it with mayonnaise and corn. Seriously.

Unfortunately if you want famous ny eats (i.e pizza, bagels, hotdogs etc) you have to go to the outerboros.

Here is my list. Being in Law enforcement you know where to get quick, good real NY eats not bullshit tourist traps.

PIZZA - ROSAS in Maspeth Queens in Grand Aveue, better than L&B’s also famous for a major heroin smuggling ring!
NEW PARK PIZZA - On Cross Bay Blvd in Howard Beach…John Gotti’s old hood
L&Bs - Really good its been mentioned before but it aint no rosas

HEROS

DEFONTES - Best Potatoe and Egg hero an italian classic, get it with melted provolone! 261 Third Avenue…They truly are assholes there but its worth it! http://defontesofbrooklyn.com/

MAMA’s - Ask for the special! Leo's Latticini (Mama's of Corona), 46-02 104th Street, Corona, Queens
Located in corona Queens. 104th street in Corona, Queens

JOHNS DELI - The best roast beef hero in NY smothered in gravy oon semolina bread. On stillwell avenue in Bklyn

LEMON KING OF CORONA - No better icees on earth, I used to work there as a kid right up the block from Mamas

Parkside Restaraunt - The best Clams and Mussells Posillipo also in Corona

WOHOPS - Simply great chinese food, Mott street in NYC…it looks like a dump but has great food

CHINATOWN ICE CREAM FACTORY - Also on Mott, some crazy ass flavors but real good.

Theres so many…I doubt you will get to go to any…but the real nyc is NOT in Manhattan but in the other four boros…fuck manhattan

MXL

Lemon ices?! The only good thing in Corona is Argentinian eats.

Mmmm…Asado. I just came.

I see a future eating extravaganza for the NY contingency…

[quote]MattyXL wrote:
Unfortunately if you want famous ny eats (i.e pizza, bagels, hotdogs etc) you have to go to the outerboros.

Here is my list. Being in Law enforcement you know where to get quick, good real NY eats not bullshit tourist traps.

PIZZA - ROSAS in Maspeth Queens in Grand Aveue, better than L&B’s also famous for a major heroin smuggling ring!
NEW PARK PIZZA - On Cross Bay Blvd in Howard Beach…John Gotti’s old hood
L&Bs - Really good its been mentioned before but it aint no rosas

HEROS

DEFONTES - Best Potatoe and Egg hero an italian classic, get it with melted provolone! 261 Third Avenue…They truly are assholes there but its worth it! http://defontesofbrooklyn.com/

MAMA’s - Ask for the special! Leo's Latticini (Mama's of Corona), 46-02 104th Street, Corona, Queens
Located in corona Queens. 104th street in Corona, Queens

JOHNS DELI - The best roast beef hero in NY smothered in gravy oon semolina bread. On stillwell avenue in Bklyn

LEMON KING OF CORONA - No better icees on earth, I used to work there as a kid right up the block from Mamas

Parkside Restaraunt - The best Clams and Mussells Posillipo also in Corona

WOHOPS - Simply great chinese food, Mott street in NYC…it looks like a dump but has great food

CHINATOWN ICE CREAM FACTORY - Also on Mott, some crazy ass flavors but real good.

Theres so many…I doubt you will get to go to any…but the real nyc is NOT in Manhattan but in the other four boros…fuck manhattan

MXL

[/quote]

This is the real truth. Well said.

Polished off a 3/4 hero from John’s earlier today. Nothing beats that.

[quote]BONEZ217 wrote:

[quote]MattyXL wrote:
Unfortunately if you want famous ny eats (i.e pizza, bagels, hotdogs etc) you have to go to the outerboros.

Here is my list. Being in Law enforcement you know where to get quick, good real NY eats not bullshit tourist traps.

PIZZA - ROSAS in Maspeth Queens in Grand Aveue, better than L&B’s also famous for a major heroin smuggling ring!
NEW PARK PIZZA - On Cross Bay Blvd in Howard Beach…John Gotti’s old hood
L&Bs - Really good its been mentioned before but it aint no rosas

HEROS

DEFONTES - Best Potatoe and Egg hero an italian classic, get it with melted provolone! 261 Third Avenue…They truly are assholes there but its worth it! http://defontesofbrooklyn.com/

MAMA’s - Ask for the special! Leo's Latticini (Mama's of Corona), 46-02 104th Street, Corona, Queens
Located in corona Queens. 104th street in Corona, Queens

JOHNS DELI - The best roast beef hero in NY smothered in gravy oon semolina bread. On stillwell avenue in Bklyn

LEMON KING OF CORONA - No better icees on earth, I used to work there as a kid right up the block from Mamas

Parkside Restaraunt - The best Clams and Mussells Posillipo also in Corona

WOHOPS - Simply great chinese food, Mott street in NYC…it looks like a dump but has great food

CHINATOWN ICE CREAM FACTORY - Also on Mott, some crazy ass flavors but real good.

Theres so many…I doubt you will get to go to any…but the real nyc is NOT in Manhattan but in the other four boros…fuck manhattan

MXL

[/quote]

This is the real truth. Well said.

Polished off a 3/4 hero from John’s earlier today. Nothing beats that. [/quote]

I think im gonna go today!

[quote]Mascherano wrote:
Lemon ices?! The only good thing in Corona is Argentinian eats.

Mmmm…Asado. I just came.

I see a future eating extravaganza for the NY contingency…[/quote]

The lemon ice king has over 30 (I think) flavors of water and creme ice. I believe in its infancy it only had lemon ice…you gotta try it.