He’s either a complete fool or he’s just like the clowns using the dictionary definition of co-ops to mislead people into thinking a socialist government operates the same way.
Can’t let this go unchallenged.
This is complete bullshit with a socialist government.
SOCIALISM
Definitions:
State = The People; Citizens
Government = Public Servants managing(ruling) The State and it’s assets. Hence, the government is normally referred to as “The State” since it is democratically elected to make decisions on behalf of it’s citizens.
The State (All citizens) owns the means of production.
The Government DOES NOT own the means of production. It CANNOT own anything. It MANAGES the means of production on behalf of The State.
In a Socialist country, The State OWNS ALL CO-OPS. Which means, although technically, “workers own the means of production in their workplace”, so does the rest of the country.
ONE SHARE PER CITIZEN.
If we were to apply the principle of “1 share, 1 vote”, the GOVERNMENT would be making all decisions since it is democratically elected to make decisions on behalf of all citizens.
If this were done any other way, it would create a paradox since it would not be a democratic decision as workers in their workplace would have more of a say than all the other equal owners(the entire country’s citizens) of said workplace.
The government will do what they want to do with it because it has all the power in the world.
Just like any existing public service. You don’t walk into a public hospital and demand that you should have a say in what they do because you have 1 share of ownership, do you?
Management can be centralized, or decentralized. If it’s decentralized, then you can have a democratic workplace(which would contradict the idea of democracy and equality). As history has shown, it’s pretty dumb to bet on the latter. People keep getting fooled when politicians tell them what they want to hear.
ALWAYS READ THE FINE PRINT.