[quote]HG Thrower wrote:
PB-Crawl wrote:
Proposed nationalized healthcare - Socialist
you mean the public option? do you realize there is a pretty significant difference?
and before anyone trolls out the death panels, im not in favor of it.
All the versions of the proposed bill nationalize parts of the system in one way or another, with the public option being the most obvious. The end result of any of these bills will be the insolvency of the private health insurance system, prompting the government to step in and nationalize, just like they did with the banking and auto industries. Which, BTW the Dem leadership has made it clear is their end goal (single payer, and Barney Frank is on record saying exactly that). Thus, socialist.
And FWIW, I don’t believe the “death panels” are written or intended in the bills, but something similar (rationing) will result as an unintended consequence.[/quote]
The majority of my family is tied into health care organizations, lobbys, and actual health care professionals. We’ve had long conversations over this subject at family get dinners, needless to say my family who work as lobbyists and in big the HMOs are not the slightest bit scared of public option spawning into a fully nationalized system and a death toll to private care.
of course the public option would have rationing, the government can’t purchase infinite care. But I have yet to see anything in the bill that would bar people in the public option from purchasing additional care from the hospital if they wish.
But i do think the fear of rationing in this debate is a reflection of a lot of american’s attitudes on health care, blame it on sensationalized tv shows or just lack of eduction, i see it day in and day out at work, people thinking if they just throw millions of dollars and resources at someone who is not going to live regardless, that somehow the person will live based on money spent.
anyways, you do realize how powerful the health care and big pharma lobby are? Theyre not scared of barney frank and theyre not going to just pick up and go home because he said so.