[quote]tom63 wrote:
ElbowStrike wrote:
mr_slick wrote:
Hey,atleast they got a good reason to be depress now. Everybody wins!
I’ll argue modern teens have good reason to be depressed. They’re at an age where they crave power and self-determination, their brains on any scan you put them through are indistinguishable from those of adults, and our society seems obsessed with controlling them, disempowering them, and at the same time robbing them of all personal responsibility.
“With no power comes no responsibility.” – Clerks II
Then we wonder why they do bizarre things like “go Emo”, join gangs, shoot up schools, and so on.
It’s like the articles on prison training here on T-Nation. The prisoners who take up training are the least troublesome for the guards. Why? They’re in a completely controlled environment with zero freedom, but still have one outlet for empowerment and self-determination.
Children in sports programs tend to be less trouble through their teen years than children and teens with sedentary lifestyles. Why? They have an outlet for empowerment and self-determination.
We surround our youth with restricting rules, curfews, censorship, age-restrictions of all sorts, rob them of any responsibility for their actions, and they respond in exactly the same way as any adult would under similar conditions – they rebel.
Their problems can be as simple as “getting a job”. There’s a successful youth rehab program in my city where they take first-time offenders and help them find power in their own lives.
One kid’s parents were flabbergasted as to why their teen joined a gang and started selling drugs. When interviewed they found the kid was surrounded by "not allowed"s. Why can’t he get his parents to buy his clothing of choice? “Not allowed” to wear those clothes.
They asked why he didn’t get a job for money. His answer? “Not allowed” to get a job.
The program brought in the parents, got them to give “permission” for their son to get a job, and a year later he was still keeping his nose clean.
Give a person “permission” to do the things necessary for healthy self-esteem and they come out alright. What a concept.
If I had to grow up in a society and school system full of “zero tolerance” policies where things like tag and cartwheels were banned at recess, and first-grade boys were expelled for kissing girls, where I’d have to be locked up at home with my parents by 10pm until my 21st birthday, I’d probably have turned out emo too.
It’s not just teenagers either. Depression rates are steadily increasing in the Western world across all demographics. “Emo” is just the teenage expression of that.
ElbowStrike
EDIT: Not to mention being raised on a modern diet chock full of high GI carbs, omega-6’s, and completely devoid of omega-3’s. That’s got to do a number on a person’s mental health.
Wrong, these kids are just lazy. Very few parents i know would not allow a job, sports, or other activities. The kids just want a lazy ass way of being different and superior. they want to stand out by way of a stupid haircut, not by the fruits of their efforts.
It’s a lot easier to pain your nails than get an A, improve your body, or actually master a skill. It’s not the parents, it’s the kids.[/quote]
I agree 100% with BOTH of you. Elbow, that post makes a lot of sense. tom63, you’re 100% correct too. It’s never just one or the other. I tend to blame the kids, because when it comes down to it the only person responsible for the direction you choose is YOURSELF, but it’s true that the reasons Elbow alluded to play a definite role as well. When society tells you nothing is your fault, guess what the dominate influence is? You get lazy and become a “victim”. And/or rebel.